Theory & Impro Half diminished chords - minor 7 flat five (m7b5)

paulhughes

Member
Messages
36
Location
Essex England
Sorry if this is a dumb question, but I have been looking at a transcription of Art Pepper's Autumn Leaves and see there is a B half-diminished chord, notated without a '7':
'Bø', seemingly a half-diminished triad. Would I be right in thinking this is just a shorthand version of 'Bø7'. I have looked at the Jazz symbols chart on this site and there is no 'Bø' chord symbol, only a Bø7 (in fact to be accurate a 'Cø7').

Thanks
 
Solution
It has to be half diminished 7 (aka minor7 b5) as there isn't really such a thing as a half diminished triad. If it's a triad then it's a diminished triad not half diminished which needs a 7th to define it as such.

Someone more pedantic than me (if there is such a person) might try to argue otherwise.

e.g. it's a triad, but if it did have a 7th, it would be a minor 7 not a dimished 7.

That is almost a bit of a zen concept though.

It's kind of lazy shorthand, like in the Omnibook you see B- E7 A and I'm pretty sure that B- is a Bm7 not a Bm triad.

So we can assume that yes Bø is the same chord as Bø7 and is B D F A
I'm lucky enough to have a full transcription including the head, but as you say it's the odd chord notation at bar7 of the solo that was the issue for me.

The notation is wrong!

It’s actually best to think of that as bar 5 of the Harmonic progression. The first two bars are a pick up in to the “ top “ (Dm7)

Bar 5 of autumn leaves is not B sharp flat 5 !!!

It is B minor 7 flat five. ( also known as B half diminished )

He actually plays an f sharp here and also 8 bars later, when it next comes around.
Naughty man.....playing “ wrong” notes.
Of course it “should” be an F natural.
Obviously studied from the wrong theory books!!!!!
 
Last edited:
Vote:
Upvote 0
Indeed he does and again late in the solo. From what I know of Art Pepper I can't picture him slaving over his theory!

My transcript has a number of triads, the opening line being C and F all the way through and most, though not all of the A chords are shown as minor triads. Had they all been notated as 7ths as I expected I would have been more confident that the notation 'Bø' should have been 'Bø7'. It does make me wonder about the accuracy of all the other notated triads. Though I suppose playing a 7th even if it's not notated wouldn't be disastrous, not compared to playing an F# over a 'Bø' or 'Bø7'!
 
Vote:
Upvote 0
Sticking the 7 on the end of the half dim symbol makes no difference at all. It’s considered the same thing and is an “arrived at” abbreviation. As far as I learned, the symbol incorporates the 7 anyway. But any jazz rhythm section player is going to use the 7 anyway.
 
Vote:
Upvote 0
Indeed he does and again late in the solo. From what I know of Art Pepper I can't picture him slaving over his theory!

My transcript has a number of triads, the opening line being C and F all the way through and most, though not all of the A chords are shown as minor triads. Had they all been notated as 7ths as I expected I would have been more confident that the notation 'Bø' should have been 'Bø7'. It does make me wonder about the accuracy of all the other notated triads. Though I suppose playing a 7th even if it's not notated wouldn't be disastrous, not compared to playing an F# over a 'Bø' or 'Bø7'!

Analysing a note vertically (directly in relation to where it lies over the harmony) is merely a snapshot in time. Many players play note choices that come into focus - resolve - a little later.
Other players superimpose their own harmonic structure above the “written” harmony - eg Coltrane, Brecker.
Some players are masterful at completely “cutting the changes” and choose to.
Some players might forget the sequence. Others might imply different changes and maybe the rhythm guys don’t pick up on it - I think that Sonny Stitt is probably an example of this.
Nothing is cast in stone though, Bill Evans will have played his own “extras“ as will many.
 
Vote:
Upvote 0
Analysing a note vertically (directly in relation to where it lies over the harmony) is merely a snapshot in time.
This is exactly true. In the theory of J. Schillinger about the arts, he compares how art is perceived:
Painting, photography: all at once first, then possible examination of details
Sculpture and architecture, being 3D, take time to "walk around".
but
Music does not exist without time. The consequence of this is that you can't analyse music based on a snapshot like a photo or a painting. Harmony theory is just a way to try to understand what you hear. Most people listening to music have no need for it. It's just a rough, very rough idea of the possibilities.

In addition, The creation of tension and its release requires time and without it, there can be neither.
 
Vote:
Upvote 0

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,073
Messages
578,611
Members
8,133
Latest member
walthang
Back
Top Bottom