Theory & Impro Guide Tones for Chords (especially 3 note and 5 note Chords)

rhysonsax

Well-Known Member
Messages
6,418
Location
Surrey, UK
I know a bit about guide tones as important pitches to use when improvising over the harmony (e.g. of a jazz standard). For a melody instrument such as a saxophone, players will often focus on the 3rd and 7th of each chord, partly because they define the difference between different chord types (major 7th, minor 7th, dominant 7th and diminished 7th) and also because the bass player would usually take care of the root and 5th.

But what are the "guide tones" for a 3 note chord (e.g. C minor as opposed to C minor 7th) or for a 5 note chord (e.g. C7b9) ?

Rhys
 
Hi!
I don't know whether my definition is correct or not, but....

Guide tones would be notes defining the chord (is it major or minor, is there a major 7 or a minor 7)
You hardly will find triads in jazz I think, although sometimes you will find symbols like C- in fake books.
If so I'd analyse if this chord functions as a tonic or subdominant chord and use a major 7 or a minor 7.
Often you can use both, depending on the sound you want to get, and of course the voicing the harmony instrument plays.

I'd define a flat 9 in a C7 as a tension, not a guide tone (I may be wrong). That does not alter the function of the chord.
Nevertheless you will find very good lines using tensions.
Take for instance the opening of "Laura". There's a major 9 in a m7-chord going to a #5 in a 7-chord going to the 9 in a maj7-chord.

Cheers, Guenne
 
The other thing about 3rd and 7th, not only are they important in defining a chord, but they also are important in defining a melodic cadence, eg In G7 to C the B often (or rather, traditionally) resolves melodically to C and the F of the G7 to the E (3rd) of the C.

Think of extensions as suspensions, as that is how they are derived from classical harmony. Although it is not necessary to either prepare or resolve them.
 
Last edited:
BTW:

 
Thanks everyone. That's clear about the extensions, but I'm less clear about simple 3 note chords.

The tune I am working on at the moment is Luiz Bonfa's Manha De Carnaval. iReal and lead sheets from several sources show the first chord as A minor (rather than Am7) which I suppose is the tonic. Would the guide tones be C and G ?

Rhys
 
The other thing about 3rd and 7th, not only are they important in defining a chord, but they also are important in defining a cadence, eg In G7 to C the B often (or rather, traditionally) resolves melodically to C and the F of the G7 to the E (3rd) of the C.

Think of extensions as suspensions, as that is how they are derived from classical harmony. Although it is not necessary to either prepare or resolve them.

OMG - same question from me over ten years on !

Is there a suitable emoji for shame at total lack of progress, lack of memory, lack of ability to use the search function ?

Rhys
 
No.
I'd rather play F# and G# and not G on an A minor tonic unless it's Dorian mode of course.
But it could all be down to the context of the song and your choice of notes. Am tonic with this song could work well with a G. I’m not arguing against what you say, because it can be very subjective.

But then the concept of guide tones could well be a pedagogic tool rather than a necessary part of improvising.

It’s certainly something I never heard of until the internet and people out of Berkeley started saying you were supposed to use them when improvising.

It is definitely good however to know the defining notes of a chord, and I see nothing wrong in having a triad or min7 or min maj 7 or min6 if it sounds best in context.
 
All I remember from music theory in college is that 3 and 7 of a dominant 7th chord form a "tritone" which is unstable and wants to resolve to a major 3rd which is more at rest. I had not heard the term "guide tones" until reading this thread. They were called "leading tones" that resolve a half step up or a half step down. Maybe these are two different names for the same thing.
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,079
Messages
578,717
Members
8,136
Latest member
peterdehelegrote
Back
Top Bottom