Last evening was my first one back to rehearsal after being absent since November of 2024 due to illness. It was an enjoyable experience overall receiving the new music for 2025 and working on parts from some of those.
However, I noticed that the winds section (brass and wood combined) was only at around half strength in regard to attendance. Some specific attendance numbers that I recall include 1 of 2 altos (me), 0 of 3 French horns, 1 of 3 trombones, 1 of 4 percussionists and 0 of 2 oboists. One of our assistant directors that pitches in for the alto sax section was off this week. If he had been there, I guess that you could say that 1 of 3 altos were there last night. The strings were in a separate room, but I think that their numbers were down, as well. I asked one of our tenors (3 of 4 were there) about the light numbers, and he told me that it had been the case pretty frequently. Specifically, to the alto section, he mentioned that the other individual had been attending intermittently of late. I had watched Monday night's rehearsal via Zoom where no altos were represented. Some of the music we are working on has some very important melody parts for the altos, so there would be an incentive to be there. I know there are reasons that no one can attend all, or even most. Still, it seemed disturbing to me and when I informed my dear wife of my impressions, it prompted a discussion similar to ones we had in the past.
I do recall, at the last rehearsal that I was able to attend in 2024, a small group of disgruntled members airing their grievances amongst themselves in the lobby. I don't think any of those folks were present last evening.
My wife claims that we have too much music to learn and that our director works us too hard, as we are there to "have fun". Many times, at rehearsals the word has gone out that "fun" is spelled "w-o-r-k". The focus has always been to learn music, not just tunes. Much time is spent on rhythms, scales, dynamics and the like. Those are then hopefully applied to the music that is being learned. There are many rehearsals (such as last evening) that, in two hours' time, do not see us attempting an entire piece, only specific measures. I tend to think that this is a good thing overall and I know that I play better now than I did a year or so ago. My wife seems to think that the band should be focusing on the tunes and maybe not as many. As of right now, we have five tunes with more coming for the summer/fall season. I do see my wife's point to some extent, as I'm never satisfied that I had learned all of those scores by the time the season has ended. However, I'd rather not spend my time learning how to play only Mary had a little lamb. My entire high school experience was spent in the G major scale and not knowing the purpose of all of those keys that I never had reason to use. I like it much better since I've been able to learn so much more in the past few years.
Having said all of that, what do you think? Is there a happy medium or is our director's focus correct? What is the role of musicianship in a group of amateurs such as ours? What route would you choose if you were the decision maker for a 70+ member organization?
Thanks for your time and input!
However, I noticed that the winds section (brass and wood combined) was only at around half strength in regard to attendance. Some specific attendance numbers that I recall include 1 of 2 altos (me), 0 of 3 French horns, 1 of 3 trombones, 1 of 4 percussionists and 0 of 2 oboists. One of our assistant directors that pitches in for the alto sax section was off this week. If he had been there, I guess that you could say that 1 of 3 altos were there last night. The strings were in a separate room, but I think that their numbers were down, as well. I asked one of our tenors (3 of 4 were there) about the light numbers, and he told me that it had been the case pretty frequently. Specifically, to the alto section, he mentioned that the other individual had been attending intermittently of late. I had watched Monday night's rehearsal via Zoom where no altos were represented. Some of the music we are working on has some very important melody parts for the altos, so there would be an incentive to be there. I know there are reasons that no one can attend all, or even most. Still, it seemed disturbing to me and when I informed my dear wife of my impressions, it prompted a discussion similar to ones we had in the past.
I do recall, at the last rehearsal that I was able to attend in 2024, a small group of disgruntled members airing their grievances amongst themselves in the lobby. I don't think any of those folks were present last evening.
My wife claims that we have too much music to learn and that our director works us too hard, as we are there to "have fun". Many times, at rehearsals the word has gone out that "fun" is spelled "w-o-r-k". The focus has always been to learn music, not just tunes. Much time is spent on rhythms, scales, dynamics and the like. Those are then hopefully applied to the music that is being learned. There are many rehearsals (such as last evening) that, in two hours' time, do not see us attempting an entire piece, only specific measures. I tend to think that this is a good thing overall and I know that I play better now than I did a year or so ago. My wife seems to think that the band should be focusing on the tunes and maybe not as many. As of right now, we have five tunes with more coming for the summer/fall season. I do see my wife's point to some extent, as I'm never satisfied that I had learned all of those scores by the time the season has ended. However, I'd rather not spend my time learning how to play only Mary had a little lamb. My entire high school experience was spent in the G major scale and not knowing the purpose of all of those keys that I never had reason to use. I like it much better since I've been able to learn so much more in the past few years.
Having said all of that, what do you think? Is there a happy medium or is our director's focus correct? What is the role of musicianship in a group of amateurs such as ours? What route would you choose if you were the decision maker for a 70+ member organization?
Thanks for your time and input!
