Saxophone beginners "Fun" vs. "Work"

ESJohn

Senior Member
Messages
1,645
Location
Ohio USA
Last evening was my first one back to rehearsal after being absent since November of 2024 due to illness. It was an enjoyable experience overall receiving the new music for 2025 and working on parts from some of those.

However, I noticed that the winds section (brass and wood combined) was only at around half strength in regard to attendance. Some specific attendance numbers that I recall include 1 of 2 altos (me), 0 of 3 French horns, 1 of 3 trombones, 1 of 4 percussionists and 0 of 2 oboists. One of our assistant directors that pitches in for the alto sax section was off this week. If he had been there, I guess that you could say that 1 of 3 altos were there last night. The strings were in a separate room, but I think that their numbers were down, as well. I asked one of our tenors (3 of 4 were there) about the light numbers, and he told me that it had been the case pretty frequently. Specifically, to the alto section, he mentioned that the other individual had been attending intermittently of late. I had watched Monday night's rehearsal via Zoom where no altos were represented. Some of the music we are working on has some very important melody parts for the altos, so there would be an incentive to be there. I know there are reasons that no one can attend all, or even most. Still, it seemed disturbing to me and when I informed my dear wife of my impressions, it prompted a discussion similar to ones we had in the past.

I do recall, at the last rehearsal that I was able to attend in 2024, a small group of disgruntled members airing their grievances amongst themselves in the lobby. I don't think any of those folks were present last evening.

My wife claims that we have too much music to learn and that our director works us too hard, as we are there to "have fun". Many times, at rehearsals the word has gone out that "fun" is spelled "w-o-r-k". The focus has always been to learn music, not just tunes. Much time is spent on rhythms, scales, dynamics and the like. Those are then hopefully applied to the music that is being learned. There are many rehearsals (such as last evening) that, in two hours' time, do not see us attempting an entire piece, only specific measures. I tend to think that this is a good thing overall and I know that I play better now than I did a year or so ago. My wife seems to think that the band should be focusing on the tunes and maybe not as many. As of right now, we have five tunes with more coming for the summer/fall season. I do see my wife's point to some extent, as I'm never satisfied that I had learned all of those scores by the time the season has ended. However, I'd rather not spend my time learning how to play only Mary had a little lamb. My entire high school experience was spent in the G major scale and not knowing the purpose of all of those keys that I never had reason to use. I like it much better since I've been able to learn so much more in the past few years.

Having said all of that, what do you think? Is there a happy medium or is our director's focus correct? What is the role of musicianship in a group of amateurs such as ours? What route would you choose if you were the decision maker for a 70+ member organization?
Thanks for your time and input!
 
🙂🙂 Spot on mate!! I had exactly the same experience in my local band. the director would call out tunes ad hoc from the 100 plus book instead of focusing on a couple of tunes during the two hour session. This resulted in the morale of the band nosediving and good players left. It was evenually seriously embarrasing to play at any event and being upstaged by a school band who were tight and obviosly had spent time learning the pieces.. We did mention this and were told that "This band is open to anyone and that is how we/I operate" The band is still operating but not with us...Regards..🙁🙁
 
You're not alone. I play within an orchestra of about 40 musicians, we do several concerts throughout the year.

Tha last rehearsal there was only myself and one alto player, rather than the usual 7 on horns. Other sections were down too.

I personally didn't play my best in the last concert, and sometimes it does feel like I'm winging it. We don't have the time to practice each piece to perfection. Overall it sounds good and the audience is usually impressed. We practice the pieces, and don't work on the theory, musicianship.

Our downfall is that the audience is often made up primarily of friends and family, so there's a pressure to add new pieces to mix it up. Where if we were promoting to a wider audience there's the potential to recycle more pieces, this get better at them.

There's always gripes about the venue sizes, we're often crammed into churches, and sell those out, but the organisers say we can't take on larger venues.

I go to enjoy myself, it's not my primary reason for playing, I've recently been working more on trying to improvise. The sax section gets together too and we do our own thing away from the orchestra. Usually playing simple quartet pieces which helps with our timing, rhythm and tuning and generally playing with a numpty like me.
 
It’s the age-old definition of “rehearsal band” scenario - a title often used for big bands in the UK.

Some players like to pull out anything from the pad, sight-read and move on, others like to rehearse a few til improvements are made. If rehearsed, some are more fastidious than others.

Some come for a bit of a blow and a social. Some might have played at a higher level or been in the forces and are used to getting in the weeds.

It will never be resolved unless all members are canvassed and admitted to an ensemble as like-minded players.

Some players are always there, some are often not. Some are completely retired and some are not. 🤷🏻‍♂️
 
To play in a eight piece band was too much for me. Nothing wrong with the guys in the band but we suddenly discovered that we talked more than we played.

For me music (saxophone and singing) is something joyful. I can share my interest with other players that are into the same music as me. No competion, no "mesure-stocks", no "am I good enough" feelings .... just playing and having fun. "Blowing my brain out" or "Crying my heart out" ..... .

I'm searching for a new pub rock band. Just four guys in the band. No tuning, no rehearsals, no reading, no clever thoughts or reflections. This type of music was good for me back then and I think that's what I'm missing?
 
What can be a solution, to make a group of players, with diverse skill levels, have fun making music and not noise?
This is for a community wind or orchestra group.
I think that is the primary question that our band faces. I think one goal is to bring those at lower skill levels up to a higher level over time. Another issue is to keep those at the higher skill level, and we do have several of those (I'm not one of those), interested enough to continue on with the band.
One tool is our frequent use of flex band music, which helps balance out the sound while taking in as much account as possible of the gaps in the instrumentation. Another is the amount of time that is taken to help us understand music in general and to keep us working on the fundamentals. I have also seen adjustments being made in the music selection, such as our switching last Christmas season from the full version of Sleigh Ride to a simpler one. We've also abandoned some pieces from time to time. I know that we have grown over the past few years. It just seems that some members wish to limit how much they want to learn.
The rehearsals are enjoyable, and the director has a very good attitude. I think the core group will continue to attend and make efforts. Others may go elsewhere.
 
For a 70+ strong organisation you could split it into two groups - a training band and a higher standard band. This is what the saxophone orchestra that I'm in has done: Saxophone Orchestra Manchester — Saxophone Orchestra Manchester.

With twice-yearly concerts there is a constantly growing repertoire to keep the members stimulated. We're expected to work on the pieces in our own time, with the monthly rehearsals orientated towards bringing the individual parts together into a whole. Learning scales is something for the indivudals to do away from the orchestra, taking individual tuition if needed.
 
Hey Davidk! Great idea! How much is at ticket from Cleveland to Manchester?
If my memory serves me correctly, one of the participants at the 2023 Saxophone Christmas that I attended belonged to a band that had such a structure. Individual NHB's are free to set their own destiny. Ours accepts any and all, so that one could actually buy an instrument and pick it up for the first time in the morning and be part of the band that evening. We also have some very experienced members. One of our tuba players was in the Ohio State Marching Band and I think that he had "dotted the I" during his experience there, such as below:
View: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4L96UAPEbWQ

Of course, the decision would not be mine, but if what I saw last week was an indication of a trend, it could be something that a member could bring up. We have a total (a few are for small groups, and one is for the strings only) of 11 concerts scheduled for 2025.
Some very good thoughts from all of you, by the way! I'm hoping that experience of my first day back was not something that continues.
 
I've been a glum about the orchestra I play with, skipped Mondays rehearsal.. I didn't play my best in the last concert, and we're straight into prepping for July's, with more new pieces.

Last rehearsal much of the group was missing, sight reading new parts, and just not enjoying it, no time to sit and practise the parts, recently it felt like a bit of wing and prayer "that'll do"

I was chatting to my teacher about it, and it seems a common thing with bigger bands, very little work on musicianship, just play it, and onto the next... If it's a real struggle shelve it.

Certainly takes some of enjoyment out of playing. As section when we get together we've started playing our own pieces for our own enjoyment.
 
Ever hear of pointing a finger at someone and not noticing that three fingers are pointing back to you? That was me yesterday. We had been out most of the day and by the time we got home, the last thing I wanted to do was to drive the 45 minutes needed to get to rehearsal, so I spent the evening at home. This Thursday, our rehearsal is at a venue much closer to me so I am planning on going. The issue with that rehearsal day and time is that it is in the daytime when several members are still working. It is also further for others to drive, so some skip this one on a regular basis.
Sometimes I think that it is a problem inherent in most voluntary organizations these days. I also do some reenacting (American Revolution) where, with a membership in our particular unit of over 60 members, our commander is constantly having to beg folks to come to events and we usually net 20 or less when they do happen.
My attitude in general is to do what our leadership tells us to do. Concentrating on learning music has helped when I have wanted to play tunes that are outside the band's portfolio. The band has been around since the early 2000's and started with a group of less than 10.
It is good to know that there are others here that deal with the same issues. Everyone needs to make their own determination as to situations that arise from time to time.
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,061
Messages
578,383
Members
8,129
Latest member
Bartman
Back
Top Bottom