- Messages
- 4,216
- Location
- london
Morning..How many semitones do I need to go up to change the key as above. Thanks
If you simply look at a picture of a keyboard, it’s just a matter of counting.That was harder than you will ever know @lydian..
There are never ever two of the same lettes in a scale. Having G and G# is a sign of an error, surely?F#, G, G# or G,G#, A.
We're talking about counting up semitones in the chromatic scale. With 12 notes and 7 letters, how do you avoid repeating letters?There are never ever two of the same lettes in a scale. Having G and G# is a sign of an error, surely?
Look at the numbers in my post. That's how to count semitones. The starting note is zero.Hope I don't complecate things here but if F# becomes A do you include the root ( if thats right) is it F#, G, G# or G,G#, A.
I think @mizmar was thinking of diatonic scales which is understandable, however when transposing to different key it could be any key so we would think of a chromatic scale in regard to the twelve available notes.Ignore mizmar. He's apparently in a different thread known only to him.
Wind ya neck in. I misunderstood what people where trying to say. Not too complicated.Ignore mizmar. He's apparently in a different thread known only to him
Exactly.Wind ya neck in. I misunderstood what people where trying to say. Not too complicated.
Just don't want to add more confusion than there already is. Love that expression by the way.Wind ya neck in. I misunderstood what people where trying to say. Not too complicated.
Fair enough.Just don't want to add more confusion than there already is
I like your approach. But it makes accidentals tricky and takes a few extra steps. First, you have to figure out how many lines/spaces the new is from the old. In this case the next line or space up (old note on space goes up one space, old note on line goes up one line), which you get from looking at F# and A on the page. Then apply the new key signature. Then realize that some accidentals, like naturals become flats, i.e., G natural is Bb in the new key. Not sure how Eddie would ever figure any of that out.Fair enough.
My problem is I'm on the verge of offering the "pick your root and apply the key signatur to the diatonic notes" approach - to avoid the "... Apply to each note" problem... A change of thinking I went through and found helpful. But was avoiding pilling in... And failed.
