Venus Soprano Sax case zipper
After about 4 years of continuous use of my Venus straight soprano sax, the zipper failed and the inexpensive construction of the cloth covered moulded foam looked ragged on edges and especially around the Velcro nylon cloth handle.
It was the cast metal sliding zipper mechanism that failed. I bought a plastic universal replacement, it worked for about a year then failed, then bought a better quality metal one on Amazon. Continued to use it another two years. Finally the coiled shaped zipper track failed and wouldn't zip.
The case now ratty looking, in 2019 I bought a Protec PRO PAC Black Straight Soprano case for $110.00 US
(then last of the no state tax for out-of-state purchase). Although zippered, it is a much higher quality case with a quality zipper that well protects the sax, will last me for a while.
Horner Accordian
About the same time, I bought from MF a Hohner Hohnica 1303 Beginner 12 Bass Accordion in Red I bought about the same time from Musician's Friend for a little over $300.00 US as an open box item in like new condition (now they are $800 US new!

)
It has a quality internal zippered flap covered by an external latchable flap. So I gather that although slightly corroded, those European made accordian cases in contrast to the inexpensive sax cases from the Orient are more durable.
Zipper mechanism replacment
Pete, if the zipper mechanism fails, there are replacements in various sizes to suit. However, it required me to shop around to find a decent replacement. Since I bought the good replacement 8 years ago, can't remember the brand as I binned the packaging.