Miscellaneous Forum format vs Social Media

Like @nigeld I left Facebook and I'm increasingly inclined to close other social media accounts as they tend to become ad platforms before anything else.

The forum is great. It allows each of us to focus on what we're interested in. I started using a forum (The Sailing forum) on CompuServe back in 94 and despite the limited connectivity, it was fantastic. Very much the same as this essentially without the rich media support and links... I met a number of great people there as I do here.

I prefer the forum format to anything else I've experienced so far by a huge margin.
 
There's nothing quite like this forum.

I use facebook to stay in touch with and reconnect with people I don't see anymore.
This place seems to attract an ecclectic mix of characters that maybe wouldn't meet in real life but have a similar addiction/compulsion/fascination regarding all things saxophone.
A mine of information offered freely, generously and patiently.
There is no comparison anywhere. Long may it continue.
 
At one stage I was admin on around 20 Facebook groups, all concerned with keeping fish, reptiles, invertebrates and other small animals, or the plants kept with them. This was a version of the subforums as found here. A team of experts running the groups, some general, some specific to a certain group concerned with their speciality. All from a spread of timezones so that there is admin present on all groups at all times.
The groups all had files saved, where you could find most of the information you might desire.
So disorganisation, lack of easy to find information, or lack of moderation is not a fault of the medium, it's a fault of the specific group's admin team, a Facebook group can outstrip the ability of a forum to provide information if run properly, but a group being run properly is a rare thing these days.
I don't think one is necessarily better than the other, they just vary in the level of personalised, immediate response, or perhaps gratification.
If you want to ask a question, or share an experience, and get an immediate response, and immediate interaction with others sharing your interests, then Facebook is the better choice.
If you just want to check some conversations once or twice daily, catching up while having a coffee, and don't like/want/need an immediate response or to engage in a real time conversation, then a forum would suit you better.
I really don't think one format is superior to the other information wise, a Facebook group has saved files and pinned posts, it just depends on the type of interaction you want.
 
So disorganisation, lack of easy to find information, or lack of moderation is not a fault of the medium, it's a fault of the specific group's admin team
Well, Indeed. And I'd add if the members are prepared to play ball.
Like the free market, it only works well if properly regulated and there's good compliance. And that depends on the members and mods getting something of value out of it... (And, maybe, that everyone has regular bowl movements?)
 
Is it that the forum format (that you all know and love) is too complicated these dyas when people are used to a much simpler experience on social media?
I don't know, I just read " Saxophones & Accessories", "Playing", Saxophone Tech, Repair and Maintenance" and "Breakfastroom" . I think CS it's too big!!!!!

Cafè Saxophone is the only internet forum I use to visit. SOTW no more.I have YT site as well.

For 15 years ago I thoght social media was the future. Maybe it is, but not for me. I had over 350 "friends" on Facebook. One day I removed "friends that I haven't been in touch with for the last 12 months. 32 friends remained. I also had 3 FB groups, "blues & rock", "rocksax", "rock & roll recordings". First my groups were open for everyone to read. But after some time they became private groups. Today I run my groups via e-mail. I can't see any reasons to communicate with friends via FB? But the "ROCKSAX" fanzine is over. The last numbers was easy to do. I just made the magzine in the computer and uploaded it to a A3 printer and printed out two double A3 that I folded to four double A4 that became an eight page fanzine. Very good pictures. The last Rocksax fanzine (i just printed out and mailed eight fanzines !!!!) I wrote about The Martin Magna saxes, resonators or reflectors, Rocksax Workout in A and E with a CD-R, three ways to play a bluessax solo ( an translation/commentary from Andrew Clarks column Rock And Roll Saxophone) ........ . Now more than 8 rocksax players wants the fanzine. "You never miss the water till the well runs dry".

rocksaxtva.jpg


So I'm pretty much back as I started back in the mid 90's when internet was new. I still believe that a thick envelope is more interesting and fun than an e-mail? Of course, I'm very narrow. It's just Rock & Roll saxophone.

Off topic. Sorry for that.
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,070
Messages
578,529
Members
8,132
Latest member
LouisJR
Back
Top Bottom