Reeds Forestone baritone reeds

thomsax

Well-Known Member
Messages
7,428
Location
Sweden
I'm going to try a new reed on baritone. What's the difference between "Forestone Baritone", "Forestone White Bamboo", "Forestone Black Bamboo" and "Forestone Hinoki". The have differnet stenghts numebers/letter as well? I use yo play LaVoz or Plasticover but it's so hard to find the good ones.
 
I can only pontificate....err I mean comment or offer an opinion..... on bari reeds when played on a tenor mpc, which the only mpc I have played them on....I have also played Bari brand plastic reeds but they are real paint peelers so not to eveyone's taste. Good for killing loud guitar stranglers in noisy bar jams.

So for what it is worth, on tenor and alto my experience is that the tradional Forestone brownish-beige ones (not sure of the name of those) are very good. Not overly bright on most mpcs unless they are high baffle, and pretty much the hardness as marked in relation to most cane reeds. I actually have played those a lot on tenor and alto and like them for the convenience.

Regarding the Forestone Whte Bamboo I bought one a couple of years ago and because the word is that they are softer than the number of an equivalent reed of that number, I got the 4. That's because I usually play a 3-3.5 on most pieces. Well the damn thing....can't say if this is true for all of them or I got a fluke...is more like a 2 or a 1.5. To give you an idea of how soft it is I just went in took out my tenor and played it with my Metalite M11. That's a .125 tip and it was like cutting soft butter with a spoon. In other words up and down the range with no problem. So I took out a Plasticover 4 and could only get some very spotty sounds out of it and it was a hard blow. Next I put on a RJS 4s and I could play it but the bell notes were sketchy and too much work. I had a reed on there already that I had played the last time I played the M11 and it was a Rigotti 2.5 So this gives a picture of exactly how soft this thing is. Again, I don't know if this one I have is a fluke because I bought it when they first came out. If it is not though, They sure have screwed up with their gradation system and need to make 5s and 6s too.

I might mention that it also works great on some alto mouthpieces I have. I have frequently played reeds one size up on both alto and tenor....but never on soprano because the alto reeds really don't fit. I'm kind of unorthodox in that I like to try things to find out what happens when you do it even though people say it doesn't work. Baritone reeds on tenor are often a better blow sound wise on some mpcs and tenor ones on alto as well.

So if I were to say which one to get, I would buy the regular camel color Forestone. As to the Legere Sigs, I don't like the way they feel on my lip. They have this texture that irritates it after a while of playing. The baris as I said are bright plastic popsicle sticks good for cutting down trees from a distance. As to Plasticovers, I have played them for years on both A and T and I generally like them a lot. The main thing is that being real cane reeds under the coating they do vary a bit in how they respond, perform and hold up over time. The coating also does flake off and if that worries you, don't get them. For sure it is being ingested and passing into your body. The company never answered very convincingly about this when a few of us on SOTW wrote them asking for their Sanitary and health data about the coating. I think there was a proposition in California that required them to do it....at least for sale in CA....but I don't know if they actually complied with it. I just forgot about it given the amount of crud I breathe here in the Barcelona air, the most polluted in Europe for many years. Short of moving elsewhere or not breathing at all, what you gonna do anyway?
 
Before supper I played my Brilhart Personaline HR with some of those reeds. It was opened to .100 by Eric G. so I normally play it with either a 2.5 Rigotti gold or a Alexander 3 because they really bring out the rich mellow fullness of the mpc and my Comm III. Again it's a tenor so I can't say much about on a Bari, but when I played the White Bamboo 4 it was really clear...crystal clear, but perhaps a bit too brite. The regular tan Forestone sounded a bit less so but still to my ears like a synthetic. That is not to say I could identify the sound as a synthetic reed if someone else weere playing it, just that to me, hearing myself, I relate the difference in sound I hear between the cane and the Forestones as a synthetic reed sound. However, if you are playing a high baffle mpc I think it is going to make less of a difference since those are going to be brighter by themselves already with most any reed, cane or synthetic.
 
Hi,
tried them all.
Sounded horrible compared to any cane reed.
Best was Black Bamboo for me (maybe they have the thickest tip), but MH was too strong, and M too soft.
Could have lived with White Bamboo, but even the strongest was too soft.
Along with some plastic reeds of a German brand (Fiberreeds) they live inside a box and wait to get disposed.

Cheers, Guenne
 
I don't know the Black Bamboo.....boo hoo hoo. :verysadAnd just as well. After my experience with the white 4 really being a 2 or less I'm not about to throw anymore money down that wishing well. The tan ones are fine when they work and when not I play cane.That said one could get a reed trimmer and just like with cane,trim the tip some to make it harder. In my case I have never had a tenor reed trimmer and am not about to buy one now. So I just play it on very big tips and on Alto mpcs from time to time. You could do that however instead of losing the investment.

Of course the other possibility is to put them on ePray as barely used, sterilized quality reeds and at least get half you cash back. Someone is bound to go for it I bet.
 
A man older than 50 might look funny putting black reeds on a black ebonite MPC especially in a jazz club πŸ™‚, and it could take some time.
Right there is the big reason not to buy them. I have a hard enough time with Plasticovers on HR mpcs even under a bright light in my study. It is very hard to tell one surface from the other due to the glare that reflects and blocks my acuity. I'm going to write them to request that they make them with white plastic so us old folks can see the mpc tip. It bugs the crap outta me.
 
A man older than 50 might look funny putting black reeds on a black ebonite MPC especially in a jazz club πŸ™‚, and it could take some time.

One of the reasons I switched to Ultem MPCs, I can see the black Bamboo! But seeing them doesn't solve the fundamental problem that they sound equivalent to something that was buried a very long time ago.

I mean, you can play them, and you can get a sound out of them but it may not be the sound you like. And in contrast to any natural reed, they only have one sound, which always stays the same.

You can improve them ever so slightly using a reed knife and thinning the "wings" and flatten the table portion but it's still more like adding rally stripes to a black Ford Pinto.
 
Thank you. Maybe I shall try a softer plasticover for baritone? I use to play #4 baritone reeds on both bari and tenor. So practical. I want a reed that is easier for me to play in lower register. The # 4 is hard to play soft down low.
 
Thank you. Maybe I shall try a softer plasticover for baritone? I use to play #4 baritone reeds on both bari and tenor. So practical. I want a reed that is easier for me to play in lower register. The # 4 is hard to play soft down low.
Well, as we all know depending on the mpc chamber, baffle, and tip size, the reed hardness is quite often the difference between being able to play the bottom end starting at pp or only from ff. The trade off for that is being able or not to play decent altisimo. I am certainly able to play some mpcs with a 4 reed but often the low notes only by pumping in a lot of air so that they are anything but soft. This also helps me get the altisimo, especially on a high baffle mpc. However, while that's great for a loud bar jam if I am playing mellow jazz at home I want to use a low baffle mpc with a smaller tip and play it with a 2.5 or 3 for more volume control of the low end. In that case I don't also concern myself with the altisimo because on my Comm III G3 is a notoriously fickle note to get anyway. I can get notes above that more easily and without even trying unlike the damn G3.
 
i recently gave the hinoki ones a try (tenor). I went MH, ( i have used fibracell for many years), and was initially really pleased with how it played and sounded. But what i did find was that after a week or so of playing it daily, the tip of the reed started curve inwards toward the tip of the mouthpiece, having the effect of reducing the gap between the tip of the reed and the tip of the mouthpiece quite significantly. The result being that the reed which initially played really nicely into the altissimo range became one that made this a real struggle as the reed started to curve......i have tried to show it in the photo. A bit disappointed really, because it all started so well for me, and now i have given up on it....
 

Attachments

  • DSCN3759 (640x480).webp
    DSCN3759 (640x480).webp
    3.5 KB · : 315
Last edited:
i recently gave the hinoki ones a try (tenor). I went MH, ( i have used fibracell for many years), and was initially really pleased with how it played and sounded. But what i did find was that after a week or so of playing it daily, the tip of the reed started curve inwards toward the tip of the mouthpiece, having the effect of reducing the gap between the tip of the reed and the tip of the mouthpiece. The result being that the reed which initially played really nicely into the altissimo range became one that made this a real struggle as the reed started to curve......i have tried to show it in the photo. A bit disappointed really, because it all started so well for me, and now i have given up on it....
Send it back to the company because that shouldn't happen that quickly. You could take it to the shop where you bought it and show them and get them to exchange it for you. They'll send it back to the company. If that doesn't work just send it to Forestone directly. They might send you several in return, who knows.

I should say that I have regular older Forestones I have played for years and only one has started with that curling tip bit. However, the curl is away from the mpc tip and up on one side towards my bottom lip. It's like it got wavy and then the last wave curled a bit but clearly it's from being used plenty. I think it might not play as well but I can't really tell.
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway πŸ˜€

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,070
Messages
578,521
Members
8,132
Latest member
LouisJR
Back
Top Bottom