Mouthpieces Focused vs spread mouthpiece

You do realise, that makes absolutely no sense at all? Mouthpiece are never designed to work with either synthetic or natural. They are made (hopefully) to work with reeds.

Now there are some mouthpieces that have some concavity that is supposed to allow for natural swelling of cane reeds as the get damp. But even those do not work better with one or the other. My personal opinion is that is pointless, and that mouthpieces tables should be flat. if you do find one that works better with either synthetic or can then it's time to ditch that mouthpiece. Or works better when playing into a mirror or wall.
Sorry but both the 10mfan and Lakshmi work with both synthetic and cane reeds..i guess i mean sound ok..for example i had to change the lig on the tw as i couldnt get the built in lig to hold..i found some sound better than others
 
Keep in mind that the pasticover reeds lose a lot of frequencies in the spectrum. Yes they are brighter but IMHO they typically sound awfal for anything other than loud edgy stuff. You might do better with other synthetics as opposed to reeds dipped in asphalt.
 
I have a deflector, which I presume is similar but honestly these things are great for being able to at least hear yourself in a loud live situation, but practising with one or playing into a mirror is bad because it flatters your sound. It's far better to hear your sound naturally in a room that isn't too live (or outdoors is also good) so you hear what it really is and can work to improve it.
I agree 100%, I don't have one,I just thought it might help Eddie and would be cheaper than a new mouthpiece.
 
Personally, my preference and recommendation is to buy one, good, saxophone mouthpiece and one, good, saxophone, that give you something decently close to what you want, then learn how to play them well.
This is so true, a beginner or improver should follow this advice, but many don't, when things on the journey seem to go in the wrong direction many try to blame gear and think this is the answer but mostly it's because you need to work through it with more practise.
This where having a good teacher works well.
 
Yes, a deflector is great in situations where you can't hear yourself - gigs with/without adequate monitors. They can be a lifesaver then. But being used to "hear what others hear" at 5', 10' and beyond won't give you a sense of this.

The playing in a corner can be an interesting reference, but again, not good for any length of time or to be used often either. Let's not forget that placing speakers in/near a corner causes bass wobble/trap - which is the scourge of studios and hi-fi audiophiles.
 
I agree 100%, I don't have one,I just thought it might help Eddie and would be cheaper than a new mouthpiece.
Hey but not as much fun...lol..TBF i am at the point where I have 2 metal pieces link and tw lakshmi and the 10mfan "the classic" all give something different. The tw plays best with cane no 3 vandoren greens but will play with a 2.5 legere sig so i can play in the caravan in the summer. 10mfan is dark enough to take a plasticover and plays most songs well..ill keep the link its good for general pop and works well with the plasticovers or legeres..end of mouthpiece madness..focus on playing.
 
.end of mouthpiece madness.
Except it just sounds like continuation of mouthpiece madness, ie having three mouthpieces

all give something different.
Using mouthpieces while at a stage where you could instead be learning to develop your own ability to have more control over the sound by sticking to, and getting used to one mouthpiece.
 
10mfan is dark enough to take a plasticover and plays most songs well.
No MPC (when it's not damaged) plays a song bad or good.
Going for something middle of the road as a sax player is always the best idea, especially when you are still developing your style (not talking about "real" classical playing here).

Whats that..
TW has very good names for his MPCs (buddhist gods or goddesses like Brahma, Durga, Shiva, Lakshmi, Gaia, etc.) Nirvana was a joke, obviously a bad one.

People who sell MPCs, especially the ones who tend to write mostly in capital letters or spend much time in naming them want to make you think that you constantly need something new and better suited for you.
I'd rather invest in a high quality teacher. You probably get 10 lessons that make you practice 3 years (with fun and goals) for the price of such a boutique beauty.

Cheers, Guenne
 
This is so true, a beginner or improver should follow this advice, but many don't, when things on the journey seem to go in the wrong direction many try to blame gear and think this is the answer but mostly it's because you need to work through it with more practise.
This where having a good teacher works well.
Think there are so many mouthpiece variables you have to learn what you need. Aside from the material there are a lot of variables in the pieces then throw reed type and selection in its difficult..Happy that i have 2 pieces that meet my needs but it has been hard work getting there..Its only since playing in the van that i have been able to utilise the mirror and notice the difference. I have also done some care home gigs through the cube and noticed the difference..i always practice away from a mirror but tried it and noticed the difference. It was Steve Neffs review of the 10mfan Robusto that led me to ask the oruginal question. It is meant to be a more spread piece than the classic. He said that when played into the mirror the sound was almost the same as playing into the room, which he liked..course it could be marketing..it did make me wonder if i would prefer the Robusto to the classic but the classic is a great piece that sounds nice recorded which i guess is what people are hearing..
 
Except it just sounds like continuation of mouthpiece madness, ie having three mouthpieces


Using mouthpieces while at a stage where you could instead be learning to develop your own ability to have more control over the sound by sticking to, and getting used to one mouthpiece.
I 100% agree @Pete Thomas..other factors do contribute tho..don't they ? ..Playing in the caravan in summer led me onto legeres or plasticovers..over 100 degrees in the summer..Now playing through a speaker which at least gives an oppurtunity to hear what others are hearing.. Its the same as recording hearing what you sound like..but regardless of mouthpiece i do practice 2 hours everyday..I havent used the lakshmi for a while and have generally stuck with a piece..guilty of buying into hype tho as i stand accused..
 
I have owned a Robusto, very good mouthpiece, I don't think it will make a massive difference to your playing over the one's you already got, haven't you already tried one of these a few years ago?
Well remembered..It was a first gen metal piece really didnt get on with it..I was thinking hard rubber..2nd gen and sell the classic..but...having moved on playing through the speaker / recording im not sure..i love the lakshmi and if i could play cane all year would focus on that piece..I dont want to change from metal to hr for a couple of months..fighting gas what is happening to me..
 
Your cure is stop watching Steve Neff's reviews
Or taking note of any other reviews, you so rarely get anything unbiased and even then just because a player likes a mouthpiece is no reason to waste your money on the same thing for yourself, as if there was any relevance. This especially applies to overpriced mouthpieces touted by influencers or endorsers
 
Well if you can afford it go for it, but the kind of mouthpieces you keep buying are well pricey, not much change from £500, expensive mistakes if they don't work for you, maybe find a dealer that will let you trial one first.
Lol i cant afford it tbf..its cash that has been set aside from buying and selling..the Lakshmi was a silly purchase as bought new..i only play for fun its a nice piece but honesly ridiculous paying that for a hobby..got the 10mfan at a steal as I couldnt get the tw to work with the legeres in the summer..didn't like the rovners on it..but found a discontinued rico metal lig that fits a dream..so can use the legeres..took ages tho and couldnt play in the summer..I kind of play the classic all the time but Steves review on the hr robusto got me thinking..fighting it lol..first time ever..
 
Or taking note of any other reviews, you so rarely get anything unbiased and even then just because a player likes a mouthpiece is no reason to waste your money on the same thing for yourself, as if there was any relevance. This especially applies to overpriced mouthpieces touted by influencers or endorsers
Fighting it..lol..2 pieces well 3 inc the link give me everything and more than ill ever need..change of environment, weather, recording etc..it will whittle down to one..maybe..
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,070
Messages
578,524
Members
8,132
Latest member
LouisJR
Back
Top Bottom