Mouthpieces Flying in the Face of Conventional Mouthpiece Wisdom

Just my 2 cts.,

I have just 1 sax (a tenor) with 2 mpc's that I regularly us: a (German) ESM 7* and a PPT 8*. Both with 2 1/2 (or ocassionally sanded down 3) reeds. I really enjoy playing my PPT, which is so expressive! But for long (Big Band) concerts of 60-90 minutes the PPT is too much of a challenge for my weak embouchure. So then I gladly use my ESM.

I also play in a pop/rock band where the PPT really shines! Since I'm not playing continuously, there's never any 'embouchure fatigue'. The same applies to the series of 10 (biannual) 'jazz workshops' that I've participated in. Three times on sax (playing my PPT) and twice on bass guitar.

Mike
PS. a couple of days ago, I noticed that my PPT mpc was 'missing' from its usual place in my sax bag. It's not at home so I'm still phoning around to find out whether anyone's found it!
Nice to see ESM mentioned. I have an ESM Heaven 7* for Tenor, couldn't believe the price for such a looker of a 'piece, and it's really fun to play, can get from jazzy to screaming with that surprisingly high baffle. Also have a black ESM jazz for Alto, simply because I just couldn't pass when it was on sale on Amazon for less than the price of a 4C (!). Only played it once so far as I don't have an alto, but it played brilliantly out of the box, after 30 years not having touched an alto.
Long story short - anyone looking for an inexpensive upgrade mouthpiece, you may want to give ESM a go.

That said, I do exclusively play the PPT tenor now. Sometimes switching to a Link modern vintage 7* for ease, but always come back to the PPT rather quickly.
 
😱 hope you'll find it soon !
Found it! What a relief! I found out that it was 'missing 'from its usual places. Either in my sax rucksack (with my sax + neck) or otherwise in my rucksack 'back pocket' with all my other sax stuff ( neck strap, reed case, cleaning swaps, etc.). I had no idea why it wasn't there! I'd played it last Saturday at a (pop/rock) band rehearsal and it was (I assume) still in my bag when I switched to my ESM mpc the day after at a (long) Big Band concert.

Although I leave 'sax junk' lying around at home, I couldn't find any trace of the PPT. I figured out that either I'd left it lying around (or it otherwise fallen out of my rucksack bag) at last Saturday's rehearsal of my 'Pop/Rock band' or Sunday' s Big Band concert. I decided to first check our 'Pop/Rock band's rehearsal rooms before phoning the location of my Big Band's (Sunday) Concert.

But this morning, at our weekly Pop/Rock band rehearsal, I discovered - when packing - that the PPT was in my sax rucksack all along 🙂. For some reason, I must have shoved it into the 'front pocket' of my rucksack (against my back) which is normally only intended (and big enough) for a couple of sheets of notes or music. Any binder with sheet music wouldn't fit, so I "never" use it.

When packing up this morning, I opened up the 'wrong' (front) pocket by mistake and lo and behold, there was my PPT!

Goes to show how limited my 'mental box' is! I'd carried my sax rucksack on my back to a concert and 3 rehearsals during the past week and I'd never felt the PPT mpc against my back. It never entered my head to check the front pocket too because I "never" use it 😉.

But I'm so relieved that I found it again! Otherwise, I would have ordered a replacement.
 
Found it! What a relief!
Glad you found it, @MikeMorrell . I've done similar with things. If I haven't worked on something for a while, sometimes finding a tool I used like in the garage for a repair project, escapes me until time passes, then one day I locate it.

Which reminds me, at last Monday's community band rehearsal, I was placing my tenor sax case behind me because the trombones in the rear row had a good bit of distance from me. Thought I had it latched securely, case opened sitting upright and didn't, all the contents (sans sax) dumped out.

I have quite of bit of junk in that front left corner pocket (several mouthpieces, ligatures, reed boxes and holders, cork grease cases, etc.). Took about 5 minutes to pick it all up.

When I got home, found I still had the cork grease (size of a chapstick case) in my shirt pocket, so I put it on the bathroom shelf. A week's gone by and it's still in the bathroom, need to put that back in the case before I lose it. 🙂
 
I have quite of bit of junk in that front left corner pocket (several mouthpieces, ligatures, reed boxes and holders, cork grease cases, etc.). Took about 5 minutes to pick it all up.

Carry in your case only what you might need - keep spares in their own box at home. Having too much Stuff in your case pocket increases the chance of losing or damaging something.

For instance: If I am playing a jazz gig, I leave my classical mouthpiece/ligature/reeds at home. After my first 20+ years of carrying a backup neck strap in my gig bag, I stopped carrying a spare neck strap because I never needed one. If you carry only reeds that you know are prepped and in good playing condition, you don’t need to sort through a bunch of reeds on the gig to find a good one. Cork grease - one is enough.
 
During tonight's community band practise for our concert on May 15, am enjoying the Bari (US manufacturer) tenor sax mouthpiece. I can play soft in the low end as backing for the upper woodwinds and brass soloists, I can make it reasonably loud when required too.

Also I can make it soft and breathy especially in the lower end for relaxing jazz. Looking at its specs I'd roughly say that its probably equivalent to a Yamaha 5C, but at half the price. But from appearance to include it came with a decent metal ligature and plastic mouthpiece cap, it's polished shiny quality finish belies its humble price.

I am very happy with it. Wednesday, I have a new Bari Bb soprano clarinet mouthpiece to arrive at the house. This I will use on my latest GAS, my 3rd Boosey & Hawkes Edgware in Grenadilla wood.
 
Conventional wisdom has to watch his back on this forum
I know there is a story behind your statement, however it escapes me for the moment. 😉

It was said that at times, Charlie Parker showed up on a performance with a beginner sax. I can't say specifically, but I imagine that there could have been a good likelihood that he used the "beginner" mouthpiece that came with it.

Two years ago I purchased the book, The Leak Light Speaks: Saxophone Purchase, Assessment, Set Up, Repair, Overhaul, Customization and Reflections. by Tom Levitt. In it he mentions that overall, saxes classified as beginner models manufactured before 1967 were of intermediate grade. It would also be reasonable to assume that they came with a decent mouthpiece, too.

(In the early 1970's in my Hawaiian high school, my father purchased me a Yamaha YAS-61 pro model alto sax for only $239 US on half price clearance in Honolulu - with 4% local sales tax. The same things were being said about Yamaha musical instruments that they now say about Chinese saxes today: "The metal is softer, keys bend easily and the body dents easily. Save yourself trouble and go buy a reputable brand like Buescher, Selmer, Le Blanc, King, etc." Yet when it was stolen in 1999, I didn't realise at the time it was worth $3,000 US in the well preserved condition I kept it in.)

My carrying an extra mouthpiece in my case has saved me on more than one occasion. The beauty of a hard rubber and some plastic mouthpieces is that they play well, but are easy to break. Sometimes even in my younger years, with fumble hands have dropped a mouthpiece shattering its tip rendering it useless.

Having an extra mouthpiece saved me during that rehearsal or performance. Carrying extra reeds in different grades too, not because only the embouchure but the characteristics of the mouthpiece determined the strength to use, to sound "correct" and vibrant.

An extra neck strap has also saved me. How about during a late night gig I've put away the sax but wore the neckstrap home? Or during a practise session at home, I've forgotten my neck strap on the stand or living room furniture and was saved by an extra in my case? Or, a fellow sax musician showed up at a rehearsal or gig and my having an extra saved him or her?

And, how often does one buy a box of cane reeds and finds that out of that box of 10, maybe only 5 or 6 are decent and the rest require additional work and some actually end up being binned? (Or used as garden seedling labels?) 😉
 
Conventional wisdom has to watch his back on this forum
I know there is a story behind your statement, however it escapes me for the moment. 😉

One has been known to poopoo conventional wisdom here (see my death threat story). Perhaps it's what makes for such lovely, fine and yet somehow always respectful and healthy debate.
 
During tonight's community band practise for our concert on May 15, am enjoying the Bari (US manufacturer) tenor sax mouthpiece. I can play soft in the low end as backing for the upper woodwinds and brass soloists, I can make it reasonably loud when required too.

Also I can make it soft and breathy especially in the lower end for relaxing jazz. Looking at its specs I'd roughly say that its probably equivalent to a Yamaha 5C, but at half the price. But from appearance to include it came with a decent metal ligature and plastic mouthpiece cap, it's polished shiny quality finish belies its humble price.

I am very happy with it. Wednesday, I have a new Bari Bb soprano clarinet mouthpiece to arrive at the house. This I will use on my latest GAS, my 3rd Boosey & Hawkes Edgware in Grenadilla wood.
Now you have raised another question for me. At the risk of digressing from the original subject. I assume your Boosey & Hawkes clarinet is a large bore model. How is the resistance? I have a Selmer Series 9 that I bought because they are less resistant than typical classical clarinets. I am a doubler and not a classical clarinetist so I prefer less resistance to get a feel slightly closer to sax. It sort of works but I wonder if there is an available mouthpiece that will get me closer to my goal.

(If admins feel like this is a separate subject, please let me know)
 
The saxes I play decide ....
My own status as player decide ....
Groove decide ....
Location decide ....

I play Rovner Deep-V on tenor (from #8-#10). A Metalite M9 or Saxgourmet "Low Rider" 120 on bari. Soprano Dukoff D6 or Selmer Classic Metal D on soprano. I can change mouthpieces and reeds during a "sèance" as well.
Are different strengths, type, brand of reeds used for each musical style?
 
Now you have raised another question for me. At the risk of digressing from the original subject. I assume your Boosey & Hawkes clarinet is a large bore model. How is the resistance? I have a Selmer Series 9 that I bought because they are less resistant than typical classical clarinets. I am a doubler and not a classical clarinetist so I prefer less resistance to get a feel slightly closer to sax. It sort of works but I wonder if there is an available mouthpiece that will get me closer to my goal.

(If admins feel like this is a separate subject, please let me know)
Your question related to mouthpieces is fitting in this thread IMO as clarinet is a related instrument and a good number here double on both sax and clarinet. My Bari brand clarinet mouthpiece is due on my doorstep tomorrow. I'll know more when I get to test it out, maybe this weekend.
in the Café. Being that it is a lesser known brand particularly outside England, company was bought by another and the name vanished, it has been more or less an underdog, depending one which year (some years had poor quality keys), is overall considered as the poor musician's doubling instrument as it is wide bore enough and has a pleasing sound for jazz. There isn't a consistent thread on this model, just bits and pieces in various threads.

Being an underdog especially here in US where I live, I bought 3 Edgwares:
  • 2015 - $46, parts instrument needing much work,
  • 2020 - $76, needs some work but overall in much better shape than the first,
  • 2025 - $106, needs minor work.
As they all need work I haven't done much with them yet. However being a pensioner and the last shows promise, at the right time post a demo. I've always wanted to own my personal wooden clarinet and the prices new are a bit more than I'd want to spend.
Regarding Admin's involvement, I think that we can initiate a thread without involving them. Sometimes if a thread takes a significant tangent, then Admin may move it to a new thread so this thread can maintain its continuity.

Give me some time and I'll initiate a thread.
 
Are different strengths, type, brand of reeds used for each musical style?
I play hard (#4) plasticover baritone reeds on tenor mouthpiece when I'm playing on my own or when as was the only hornplayer in the band. Give a bigger sound. Also change the timbre a litttle bit a, more multiphonic .... . When I played in a hornsection I played plasticover (last time was in 2018) tenor reeds on tenor mouthpiece.

I play LaVoz MS baritone reeds on baritone mouthpieces. I play baritone in different way compared to tenor. Less pressure. I prepare my bari reeds as well, Some sanding, scraping ....... and I also drill baritone reeds.

This works for me. Rubbish .... says most other players. I'm not writing that you should do this. I'm just playing electric blues, rockabilly, Rock & Roll, rock and we are not so picky .....
 
I play hard (#4) plasticover baritone reeds on tenor mouthpiece when I'm playing on my own or when as was the only hornplayer in the band. Give a bigger sound
That’s an interesting thing. How “scientific “ is this for you - have you tried it on several mouthpieces against several tenor reeds?
Why would it be? Is it stiffer, making you blow harder etc? Have you tried it against a harder tenor reed - giving the same sort of stiffness?

Not that it matters as it works for you - just wondering..
 
That’s an interesting thing. How “scientific “ is this for you - have you tried it on several mouthpieces against several tenor reeds?
Why would it be? Is it stiffer, making you blow harder etc? Have you tried it against a harder tenor reed - giving the same sort of stiffness?

Not that it matters as it works for you - just wondering..
A baritone reed is thicker than a tenor reed. I have a firm embouchure (we can call biting as well) so a baritone reed is better for me when I push. The plasicover baritone reed gives me a buzz-, multiphonic-, big/full sound. My Rovner Deep-V tenor mouthpiece and ligature holds a baritone reed in a good way. That's important. I find a hard baritone reed easier to blow compared to a tenor reed. I play a #4 plasticover bari reed but a 3½ tenor reed. I don't understand why a hard bari is easier to blow compared to a hard tenor reed? To play bari reeds on tenor mouthpices is an old trick. I read about it for many years ago but never tried. Then I started to play Rovner Deep-V mouthpices and it was John Laughter who recommended me to try the combo. When I play with other wind players I don't use bari reeds. Change the timbre but the height is ok. Good enough to honk woodshed blues, - pub rock, -rockabilly.... maybe also punkblues? Plas Johnson is playing soft baritone reed on a .130/0 Berg Larsen mouthpiece .... . Lenny Picket is playing bass clarinet reeds on a Berg Larsen 130/0 metal piece. High baffle and wide tip onening seems to be common??
 
Are different strengths, type, brand of reeds used for each musical style?
Good question!

Personally (as an amateur) I play exactly the same reeds (brand. type, strength) on each of the 2 mpc's on which I regularly play. 1 mpc primarily in a Big Band and 1 in a pop/rock band. I've just found that these reeds suit me best.

I know very little about reeds (brands, cuts, etc.). Other members, please correct me!

My gut feeling is that the choice of reed is related to things like:
- the choice of mpc('s)
- genre (classical vs. jazz//rock/pop)
- embouchure strength
- duration of playing at rehearsals/performances

I've read that classical players tend to choose mpc's with little or no (or even a negative) baffle. See this PDF. Add choose slightly stiffer reeds than jazz players might for 'pitch accuracy' and a 'dark, round' sound. I suspect that 'blending in' with the orchestra is a higher priority for classical players than individual sax players in a rock or pop band. Who don't usually play continually during concerts but need to occasionally 'cut through' the other (amplified) instruments on solos/fills. They may also choose a 'high baffle' mpc that helps them deliver a (bright, edgy) 'pop/rock' sound.

FWIW, over the years, my journey in terms of mpc's and reeds has been roughly:
- I have mpc and reed strength with together play fine, until after a year or so ...
- I find I can't get enough enough 'air' into the mpc to play at the volume I want (solos)
- Initially, I try a slightly higher reed strength which works well for a while, until I decide to
- Buy a mpc with a wider tip opening (and a lower reed strength)
- Repeat steps 1-4

In NL, there are basically only 2 reed brands that are widely available in local music stores: Vandoren and Ricoh. You can of course order other brands online. But I try to support my local music stores.

Back in the day, my personal experience was that:
- Ricoh reeds were easier to play 'out of the box' but wore out more quickly
- Vandoren (V16) reeds took more time to 'work in' but lasted longer

Vandoren (and probably) many other brands have YouTube video's that illustrate the differences between their reed types. This one is only about 'jazz reeds' but after viewing it, I switched from 'V16' reeds to 'Java Red' reeds. Which suit me fin
 
Plas Johnson is playing soft baritone reed on a .130/0 Berg Larsen mouthpiece .... . Lenny Picket is playing bass clarinet reeds on a Berg Larsen 130/0 metal piece. High baffle and wide tip onening seems to be common??
Interesting. I wonder if Plas found that combo easier for his portamento sliding around?
 
Interesting. I wonder if Plas found that combo easier for his portamento sliding around?
Plas Johnson's sound was an inspiration for other Rock & Roll saxophonists as well. Steve Douglas was impressed with Plas fall off's.. When Douglas had the opportunity to play with Plas Johnson in the recording studios he really watch Johnson's fingers when he did fall off's. Droping the jaw Light fingers and just fade away? This is also one of Clarence Clemons signum. I think scooping and fall off's in rock music comes out better with baritone reeds on tenor mouthpices. But it's my personal opinion.

Plas Johnson is playing #2-#2½ platicover baritone reeds on his Berg Larsen metal (130/0 ?) tenor mouthpiece. Soft reeds!?!?! He is playing Yangisawa or Yamaha saxes. According to an interview in Saxophone Journal Jan/Feb 2005.

I think Plas Johnson is playing "relaxed" solos!?!?! Maybe to play the bass line on tenor or/and baritone and to be a part of rhythm section, gives us diifernt solos? More in the context of the music and less stressy freaking out solos? Many good sampes of saxes reinforcing the bass line from the past. Lee Allen and Red Tyler maybe influenced Plas Johnsson as well. To play on blues and rock jam is very important for saxophonists. You learn how to play the bass lines, often just with a guy sings what you should play. Learn by ear. One of the best shools and teaching methods?

Portamento sliding around: That's important in blues, country, Rockabilly, Rock & Roll. Even to tune a sax to A 443 or 444 Hz is important. I know a player that is playing great RockSax on a high pitch tenor. A four pice band so they have to tune the guitar and bass differnt.

Here is Plas Johnsons playing the bass lines and a solo on Larry Williams "You Bug Me".
View: https://youtu.be/hX52Y4R42LY?si=qAuYleBaqNQh6V4b


Back to topic.
 
I think scooping and fall off's in rock music comes out better with baritone reeds on tenor mouthpices. But it's my personal opinion.
That’s the interesting part. I think much of it is down to the huge mouthpiece he played on, but there’s also him of course.
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,061
Messages
578,378
Members
8,129
Latest member
Bartman
Back
Top Bottom