Saxophones Floating on GAS attacks already - talk me down....

I started 4 years ago on a Jupiter 500 series, picked up for £150 from a friend of my sister, who was emigrating and didn't want to take his daughter's beginner's sax with him.
After about a year, I took my grade 4 Jazz exam on it, and got a distinction.

I decided then to treat myself to an upgrade and went along to Trevor Jones on Christmas Steps, Bristol, where I was allowed to try out all their saxes within my price range for as long as I wanted. I took some music along that I could play, and I took my Jupiter sax so I could make a comparison.
I went along with the intention of buying a Yamaha - a good name, why would I want to buy any different?
However, I couldn't play the Yamaha any better than I could play my Jupiter. I also tried a Yanagisawa and a Selmer. I can't remember what else I played, but the Yanagisawa stood out from the rest. It was easy to play, and I could easily get every note from bottom Bflat to top F (I didn't know top F# existed at the time!)
So I walked away with the Yanagisawa, and even better, the shop gave me £150 as part exchange for my Jupiter!

If you WANT to buy a sax and have the means, then we are not here to stop you, but I'd agree with others, that it is unlikely to improve your sound at all - your technique and experience will do that.
Get your teacher to play your sax and demonstrate just how good it can sound with an experienced player on the thin end to appreciate that the bulk of a good sound is YOU!
 
The problem is no-one wants to say to someone go buy a £4000 sax.( then perhaps there is>:)) Then find out 6 months down the road they gave up. Stems from advising parents asking the same question when buying a sax for there kids.. " You told me to buy brand XXXX and now he/she doesn't even look at it it's all your fault".. >:)

Chris...
 
The saxophone itself is merely a piece of engineering. It is a means to an end.

To go with the pictorial analogy, I would compare it more to a paintbrush than a camera.

I can't think of an analogy to compare a gun with a saxophone, although it does look like a blunderbuss.
 
If you WANT to buy a sax and have the means, then we are not here to stop you, but I'd agree with others, that it is unlikely to improve your sound at all - your technique and experience will do that.
Get your teacher to play your sax and demonstrate just how good it can sound with an experienced player on the thin end to appreciate that the bulk of a good sound is YOU!

Hi Mandy, I have the means but recall the time it took to buy and sell countless rifles and cameras to find the 'best' one for me. It seems that saxophones may be different in that I can go along to a few sax good sax retailers and do what you did, try them all, and fairy immediately know what I want. That's something I couldn't do with my shooting hobbies.
No matter what sax gets hyped by whom, it stands to reason that I'll only know what ultimately suits me by reaching a certain standard where I feel comfortable doing that research. That's going to be a good few months yet.
 
The saxophone itself is merely a piece of engineering. It is a means to an end.

To go with the pictorial analogy, I would compare it more to a paintbrush than a camera.

I can't think of an analogy to compare a gun with a saxophone, although it does look like a blunderbuss.

Colin, are you by any chance in the "A car is to get you from A to B" camp?

:confused:
 
My personal views on this thread so far.

1 Your existing sax is perfectly adequate, better than the one I learnt on thirty odd years ago.

2 Buying a Yamaha 23 (great sax that it is) or similar will not give you something hugely better than what you've got.

3 The laws of dimishing marginal returns means that even a very expensive sax will not give an improvement in quality which is proportional to the increase in cost.

4 Not all Taiwanese saxes are the same - I'm very dubious about the claim that Antigua saxes are the same as Mauriat ones, for example.

5 If (as I suspect is the case) you have a few quid, you want to indulge a new passtime with something which will be as good as you ever need and you have a strong appreciation of fine manufacturing quality, then buy yourself some thing fine. I'd pass on incrementally marginally better student or 'intermediate' saxes and get something like the Yanagisawa. They exude quality, precision and durability. That is what I did.

6 Just don't expect your new buy to turn you into a master player overnight, or even make the process of learning any quicker. You might enjoy playing a lovely sax more, but you still need to learn to play the thing. Colin the Bear (Or Colin the Turtle, as my daughter calls him) is right about music coming from within and it taking time to learn. I love playing my Yani T992 (it is such a lovely thing) but see my post in the forum about a cheapy sax. I also like that, and my battered vinatage saxes as well. I just love playing, that's all.
 
My personal views on this thread so far.

1 Your existing sax is perfectly adequate, better than the one I learnt on thirty odd years ago.

2 Buying a Yamaha 23 (great sax that it is) or similar will not give you something hugely better than what you've got.

3 The laws of dimishing marginal returns means that even a very expensive sax will not give an improvement in quality which is proportional to the increase in cost.

4 Not all Taiwanese saxes are the same - I'm very dubious about the claim that Antigua saxes are the same as Mauriat ones, for example.

5 If (as I suspect is the case) you have a few quid, you want to indulge a new passtime with something which will be as good as you ever need and you have a strong appreciation of fine manufacturing quality, then buy yourself some thing fine. I'd pass on incrementally marginally better student or 'intermediate' saxes and get something like the Yanagisawa. They exude quality, precision and durability. That is what I did.

6 Just don't expect your new buy to turn you into a master player overnight, or even make the process of learning any quicker. You might enjoy playing a lovely sax more, but you still need to learn to play the thing. Colin the Bear (Or Colin the Turtle, as my daughter calls him) is right about music coming from within and it taking time to learn. I love playing my Yani T992 (it is such a lovely thing) but see my post in the forum about a cheapy sax. I also like that, and my battered vinatage saxes as well. I just love playing, that's all.

Thanks Jon. Regarding 4, it was a saleswoman in a well regarded sax retailer who told me the Antigua rep had visited asking if they'd like to stock their saxes. She looked at his sample and said "that's a PM!" He said not, so she got their PM model to compare side by side and it was absolutely identical. She told me they then did more research and the two makes have a link up the chain to the same factory. The same day I spoke to another retailer some 100 miles away who understood the same was true. I had a Google and could find nothing to substantiate it, but the two retailers are very well regarded.
 
Being drawn to researching saxes on the 'net it's second nature to see what used models go for, and of course my 'nose' for a bargain has been twitching. The Yamaha YAS23 is still calling to me at £290 but I'm guessing you'd say stick with the Jupiter as it has more up to date keywork. I'd likely not be able to tell the difference between them sound wise, as has been said, with my lack of experience. What was the model you ended up sticking with, out of interest?

Hi DavidUK, to be honest with you because you are used to a bit of buying and selling I would probably go for the Yamaha, if it's in good condition you could play that for a couple of years and get your money back when you want to upgrade. I stuck with a Trevor James Revolution II but for my first year or so I had a Artemis, also from TJ. The Artemis was £110 which I had serviced immediately after purchase (something to look out for) and got my money back and a bit more when it was sold. You can get the TJ RII on Ebay for around £250 but I'd go for that Yam if I were you and sell the Jupiter on. (Not that there is anything wrong with the Jupiter)
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Ah, got it!

Out of interest, what's the difference between the TJ The Horn Rev II and the TJ Signature series?
Which is "better" and why?

:confused:

To play, I didn't really have the skills to tell but I believe it is mostly the action of the key work and quality of components used. The Signature was the TJ Pro sax until they released the Signature Custom a few years back and the Rev II was their intermediate. Tbh I really liked the sound I used to make on their student model the Artemis.
Have fun testing
 
Hi DavidUK, to be honest with you because you are used to a bit of buying and selling I would probably go for the Yamaha, if it's in good condition you could play that for a couple of years and get your money back when you want to upgrade. I stuck with a Trevor James Revolution II but for my first year or so I had a Artemis, also from TJ. The Artemis was £110 which I had serviced immediately after purchase (something to look out for) and got my money back and a bit more when it was sold. You can get the TJ RII on Ebay for around £250 but I'd go for that Yam if I were you and sell the Jupiter on. (Not that there is anything wrong with the Jupiter)
Yes, the YAS-23 is still calling to me so I may well take a look next week. Also had the chap selling the "mint" YAS-480 urging me to buy it at £475. The 480 doesn't seem to get much of a mention on t'internet. Is that because most go from student model straight to Pro model?

:confused:
 
Yes, the YAS-23 is still calling to me so I may well take a look next week. Also had the chap selling the "mint" YAS-480 urging me to buy it at £475. The 480 doesn't seem to get much of a mention on t'internet. Is that because most go from student model straight to Pro model?

:confused:

That would be my guess. By the time they've finished with their 23 they've saved up another £500 and can afford a nice 62. That 480 sounds cheap though, they're £1250 new.
 
The 275/280 is made in Indonesia for sure, but I think the 475/480 range continue to be made in Japan. I'm not sure that it matters where it was made, though. The main thing is, how does it play, and how well built is it.
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,061
Messages
578,381
Members
8,129
Latest member
Bartman
Back
Top Bottom