Intonation Flat middle A B and flat high ABCDEF

MarkSax

Member
Messages
563
Location
UK
Level
Sometimes good.
Please anyone. My alto sax in in tune on all other notes except 25 to 15 cts flat on mid AB and high ABCDEF. I have to pinch to play in tune. Tried moving the mouthpiece but then the other notes play sharp. Same embouchure on FF#G in tune plays flat on the aforementioned notes. Checked the 8ve mechanism and both pips rise and fall as they should. Checked Haynes but not sure what I should tinker with exactly. Am out of ideas. Thanks for your input.
 
I will add one more question, so if you can answer all four asked, that'd help:

1) What model sax ?
2) How long have you been playing ?
3) Have you tried a new reed ?


and...

4) Has the situation always been this way or did it just 'start happening' (i.e. did the horn used to play more in tune)?

(FWIW...a few notes up and down the registers straying to a 15 cents variance...is nothing to ever lose sleep over, really.
25 cents, regularly, yeah probably....)
 
Oops.....one more clarification, sorry:

When you write "mid A/B" .....do you mean:

1) first octave A (A1) and second octave B (B2) ...which would be the notes played by upper stack fingerings, no octave key ?

Then when you write 'high octave ABCDEF'...I assume this means all those notes with the octave key depressed ?

IOW...do you mean from A1 to F2 ?

Or do you mean...

2) all notes from A2 upward (octave key depressed on all notes...therefore ranging into the LH palm key notes) ???

IOW...from A2 to F3 ?????
 
Adding to the "interrogation". 🙂

What pitch do you get when you play the mouthpiece alone using your regular embouchure?

What pitch do you get when you play the mouthpiece + neck using your regular embouchure?

What note do you tune your saxophone to?
 
Thanks for your responses.

It’s a The Martin alto. Does the same thing with both the Martin mpc and. an evonite Meyer 6M. Used 3 different tuners and all 3 show the same flat 15-25 cts deviation.
I’ve had it for 3 years and it was repaired and regulated by Steve Ocone in the U.S.
It hasn’t always been so out. I use a Vandoren Traditional 2 reed.
I have been playing/ practicing everyday for the past 4 years. I’m told I now have a good tone and can subtone, overtone, altissimo....etc although I am 90% self taught (books, youtube, cafe...)
 
Oops.....one more clarification, sorry:

When you write "mid A/B" .....do you mean:

1) first octave A (A1) and second octave B (B2) ...which would be the notes played by upper stack fingerings, no octave key ?

Then when you write 'high octave ABCDEF'...I assume this means all those notes with the octave key depressed ?

IOW...do you mean from A1 to F2 ?

Or do you mean...

2) all notes from A2 upward (octave key depressed on all notes...therefore ranging into the LH palm key notes) ???

IOW...from A2 to F3 ?????
The first one. A1 B2 and then A2B3C3D3E3F3 are all flat when all the other notes are in tune.
 
Adding to the "interrogation". 🙂

What pitch do you get when you play the mouthpiece alone using your regular embouchure?

What pitch do you get when you play the mouthpiece + neck using your regular embouchure?

What note do you tune your saxophone to?
Haven’t tried that yet. My neighbours would prefer I do it tomorrow 😉. As for tuning I usually use F1 F1# and C2 or G1.
 
Am getting F4 on both mpcs with the tuner set for alto sax with the neck and F5/G#5 on the Martin mpc and F5 on the Meyer without the neck.
 
The first one. A1 B2 and then A2B3C3D3E3F3 are all flat when all the other notes are in tune.
A common scenario when playing too high on the mouthpiece pitch---above A=880 on the mouthpiece or above Ab concert on the mouthpiece + neck is for the player to pull the mouthpiece farther off the cork to tune F#1 to concert A=220. Since "short tube" notes are affected more by lengthening and shortening the overall body tube, this causes the notes you mention to play flat. That is why I asked about the "input pitch".

On the other hand if the left hand G, A, B, and C are in tune in the first octave and then play flat in the second octave it means there is probably too great a taper in the neck. More taper reduces the octave spread, and less taper (more cylindrical) increases the octave spread. The tuning results mentioned do no fit "neatly" into either scenario so I am at a loss to offer any advice or solution.

The only other test I can think of is to have another experienced player play your sax with your set-up and check the intonation of every note again. There is a wonderful tuning app called "AP Tuner" that allows you to play complete scales throughout the range of your instrument and then gives you a chart showing the pitch of each note played.
 
Going sharper on the tuned notes to reduce flatness on the problem notes seems to work to play in tune most of the time. AP and Pitch tuner apps give me 87% in tune +/- 10 cts. Am waiting for the summer to get it seen to by a tech. Thanks for all the replies.
 
Oops.....one more clarification, sorry:
Adding to the "interrogation". 🙂
Don't be fooled by the smiley face and the calm questioning by these apparently benign sax technicians, @MarkSax. If you don't tell them everything, you might be wishing you already had dentures
olivier_laurence.jpg
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,064
Messages
578,435
Members
8,130
Latest member
tommyliehe
Back
Top Bottom