Playing the saxophone F# fingering problems

Messages
50
I'm working my F# major scale. Playing just the scale straight up and down I use the side A# key no problem. Flows nicely to B. But practicing thirds the only way that seems right is to do this: F#, bis-A#, G#, B, side-A#, C#, etc. It feels weird to twiddle back and forth between the bis and B. But using the side-A# instead of bis-A# seems wrong too. Thoughts?
 
I'm working my F# major scale. Playing just the scale straight up and down I use the side A# key no problem. Flows nicely to B. But practicing thirds the only way that seems right is to do this: F#, bis-A#, G#, B, side-A#, C#, etc. It feels weird to twiddle back and forth between the bis and B. But using the side-A# instead of bis-A# seems wrong too. Thoughts?
Play whatever feels comfortable

Have you tried the left hand B key plus right hand F# key fingering?
 
There's no right or wrong IMO. Try both, and any others you can think of. Work on the awkward tranistions (eg F# - side A#, bisA# -G# - B) in isolation backwards and forwards, starting slowly and working up, and see which one is giong to work out best for you.
 
I play a lot in F# ...comes from associating with guitar players. I use the Bis key or the side key in both chromatic and jump moves depending. If you intend playing rock/blues/funk/pop one needs to be comfortable in this key. Depending on what level you want to end up technically, either follow @jbtsax's advice and go with side key or...........

use Bis for jump moves to Bb and use side for both chromatic and jumps. Make the moves really slowly at first so your brain can consciously feel the finger movements. Once you can do them unconsciously and completely relaxed bring em up to speed.

Don't forget fork Bb. For those playing fingertip style in some fast jumps, its almost a necessity.

Using the Bis chromatically is really only practiciable for those playing flatfinger style and in my case, having the tech move the Bis key on my tenor so it is positioned just right. I can trill Bb/B using the Bis with my setups. Being essentially lazy, I find the fewer keys I have to coordinate the better.
 
Last edited:
If it feels wrong, then it is. The saxophone is a compromise. Sometimes there's no right but a less wrong option. F# to Bb seems a no brainer to me to use long with middle finger RH. Just moving two fingers.

My go to Bb is A+side but some arpeggios/chords can be negotiated faster and smother using long. I don't use Bis.
 
It appears that different instruments have slightly different lower fingerings for the best FORK Bb.🙂
Typically each fingering produces a Bb with a slightly different timbre and/or pitch. On my saxes I find that the E key on the RH gives the Bb that most closely matches the 1+2+S. If the music is fast, the choice of fingering is determined by ease of fingering, not by sound.
 
This was talked about in another recent thread. have a look.

Chromatic fingering?

For me facility with both the side key and bis are essential. posts 7, 10 and 12 in that thread covers my view

Long Bb not so commonly used, but can be useful
ie Somewhere over the rainbow, starting on B. i would probably use long Bb on f sharp key for 3rd note. Because of where it goes to for next (4th) note

I would do this as trying to slide from b natural onto the Bis is a No No in my book. it is so hard.

And in the same situation, fingering the Bb with SK is not so good either as it takes my hand out of position for the note F sharp following. I can get away with that problem in a ballad, but not at speed.
 
Last edited by a moderator:

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,059
Messages
578,317
Members
8,127
Latest member
PJ2116
Back
Top Bottom