Playing the saxophone Eye pressure (Intraocular). Doctor says don't play for months

In a Mayo Clinic study, only 12% of second opinions matched the first diagnosis.

Doctors aren't Gods. Medicine is a very inaccurate science. If you are concerned about any aspect of a diagnosis seek a second opinion. Individual Doctors have differing biases, philosophies, experience, and knowledge that colour a diagnosis and suggested treatment.

For more information on the benefits of seeking a second opinion see Second opinions reference.
 
I hope the massed expertise here can help me with a crucial question.
My eye specialist has just warned me off playing sax (mostly tenor), at least until I have recovered from a forthcoming operation. That could take me through until October.
The problem is internal eye pressure. The suspicion is that playing sax will make a critical condition worse – and the potential damage is permanent, so no scope for messing around.
I’ve seen earlier threads here on the medical side of things: the science is not clear. However, my consultant is a professor whose partner plays tenor sax, so I’m obliged to listen to him.
My crucial question is: what strategies have people used when forced to stop playing sax for a fairly lengthy period?
I have a few ideas and may develop more once the sense of shock wears off (new strings ordered for my long-abandoned electric guitar, theory books already pulled off the shelf, work started on long-planned new playlists I’ve always meant to create, and sheets of music set aside for analysis).
In the meantime I’d be grateful, please, for all suggestions to keep me from losing too much in the coming months.
I have a roland aerophone 5 that i use to practice fingerings with headphones. It takes almost no air to make sounds So little in fact that whe n i go back to the sax im amazed how much air it takes. No good for embouchure but ok for fingers
 
To be fair it's a no brainer, your health is way more important, I have had to take a number of periods off from playing sometimes many months due to cancer treatment but its really surprising how quickly you get your lip back in and your knowledge to date will stay with you.
If your surgeon has said no playing, then he/she has said that for a reason, sit back and listen to some great music and the time will fly to when you can play again.
 
@BertieBut - the question that really strikes me about your original post in this thread is why you are on earth do you ask the opinion of non-medical people instead of referring back to your surgeon for advice? It seems insane to me, to go to a medical professional and then ask from advice from a bunch of (for the most part, I suspect) amateur musicians. It's like taking lessons with a top professional saxophone player, questioning the professional advice you get, and then asking your GP for advice on playing the saxophone.
If your surgeon has said don't blow - don't blow.
My original post said: "My crucial question is: what strategies have people used when forced to stop playing sax for a fairly lengthy period?"
There's no way I would listen to anyone here who does not have a medical qualification that trumps my specialist's (he's a professor with years of experience) when it comes to whether to play.
I was interested in what people have done/or doing when banned from playing.
I listed a few non-blowing options and asked for other suggestions.
 
What I took from the question was regarding things that would help but without actually playing the saxophone. So the question was/is valid.
Spot on.
It's true there have been suggestions to play the flute and in this regard it could be a feasible thing to do so may be helpful -however - your are right in that it is something that should be referred back to the professional. (See my post #34 above)
I'm hoping to find out more about the benefits and, more importantly, the risks of playing a classical flute. If the risk is greater than, say, ordinary speech, I'll be inclined to move on.
It does seem like it could well be true that flute does not have the same pressure issues - but someone already diagnosed and taking advice from a consultant should not just take this as safe advice because forum users (non-medical people) suggested it asa possibility.
As mentioned elsewhere – and with all respect – I was asking about strategies to use while forbidden to play.
When it comes to assessing risk, I am working as someone with only one functional eye (the other was lost in a 1,000-1 risk situation related to the conditions now in my "good" eye) and so my tolerance of risk, at any level, is zero.
This means I might well be looking at losing my precious sax-playing altogether.
My specialist knows at least one saxophonist, but that doesn't indicate any particularly specialist knowledge in the area on their part. The medical literature is patchy and often quite lightweight on the rare occasions it touches on IOP and woodwind instruments.
 
Reading up on the subject, there is a transient increase in IOP that is related to how hard the players actually plays/blows, which is followed by an immediate drop in IOP below baseline as soon as the player stops. Moreover, more experienced players with a better developed embouchure see less of an IOP increase than casual players who strain.


I'd follow the doctor's recommendation, especially if you have a high risk for IOP-related glaucoma or if you have an enlarged optic nerve head. Recorder and flute don't appear to impact IOP into a dangerous range.

But keep in mind that any physical exercise will increase IOP, it's just the way things work, the extreme case is weight lifting:


One study finds a higher percentage of glaucoma in wind players compared to non-wind players but the difference is not significant since the average age of the wind players was higher and some other factors also came into play that mitigated the prevalence of wind players for open angle glaucoma:


Again, do what the doctor is telling you!
 
Every musician should be familiar with a keyboard.
A few piano lessons will benefit the understanding of harmony and exercise your reading skills.
It's the only instrument, imo, that is so universal and logical.
No faffing about tuning up or lipping it in.
Lift the lid or flick a switch and away you go. An electric will have a headphone socket. Practice any time in your own world.
Hard to actually play though.
If you aren't allowed back on saxophone, it's a source of endless entertainment.
Exercising my arranging and composing interest and making backing tracks, or complete tracks is a side line for me at the moment.
If I had to pack up saxophone I think I'd upgrade my band in a box software and satisfy my musical interest there.
 
Or the banjo.
So, Colin, you’re ruling this out as the next step in my musical career?
I defer to your seasoned opinion!
BE3CE748-325C-40C5-B2AE-4B1A1EBEC35A.webp
 
Every musician should be familiar with a keyboard.
A few piano lessons will benefit the understanding of harmony and exercise your reading skills.
It's the only instrument, imo, that is so universal and logical.
No faffing about tuning up or lipping it in.
Lift the lid or flick a switch and away you go. An electric will have a headphone socket. Practice any time in your own world.
Hard to actually play though.
If you aren't allowed back on saxophone, it's a source of endless entertainment.
Exercising my arranging and composing interest and making backing tracks, or complete tracks is a side line for me at the moment.
If I had to pack up saxophone I think I'd upgrade my band in a box software and satisfy my musical interest there.
Hey Colin, I have heard of whistling pigs but how about whistling bears?

I tried to teach this one but all he did was dance. And when I turned around he broke my pick up window and was sitting on the passenger seat.

P1010008.webp
 
I have a roland aerophone 5 that i use to practice fingerings with headphones. It takes almost no air to make sounds So little in fact that whe n i go back to the sax im amazed how much air it takes. No good for embouchure but ok for fingers
I agree. I use my Aerophone on holidays. For me, it demotivates me because the sound sucks but I force myself to practice fingerings on it.
 
any physical exercise will increase IOP, it's just the way things

I hold a post-graduate qualification in Exercise and Sports Science. I was taught in Physiology that when exercising the exercising muscles vasodilate and the non-exercising remainder vaso constrict (increasing localised blood pressure). Isometric exercise increases total body blood pressure more than dynamic exercise. The lower the proportion of body musculature exercising the higher the total blood pressure.

Saxophone playing or any breath-holding activity is effectively isometric contraction. IOP will rise and sustain for the duration.
 
My original post said: "My crucial question is: what strategies have people used when forced to stop playing sax for a fairly lengthy period?"
There's no way I would listen to anyone here who does not have a medical qualification that trumps my specialist's (he's a professor with years of experience) when it comes to whether to play.
I was interested in what people have done/or doing when banned from playing.
I listed a few non-blowing options and asked for other suggestions.
Apologies, I should have referred back to your OP more carefully.
 
Sometimes a complete break from playing has great benefits in the longer time frame of one's journey, you can come back refreshed with a renewed purpose, personally I would check with your consultant as to if there is an alternative instrument you could take up with no risk to your health.
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,076
Messages
578,679
Members
8,134
Latest member
banjo
Back
Top Bottom