Playing the saxophone Eye pressure (Intraocular). Doctor says don't play for months

Four months doesn't sound that long. If you're having to cancel gigs/shows then that would be a pain but four months of not playing or the rest of your life with damaged eyesight ... those months will pass in the blink of an eye. And you'll get to see them, too.
 
That the pressure increases playing the instruments but why?
My knowledge of biology is rudimentary but the lungs aren't connected to the eyes. The sinuses are around there somewhere, anything to do with them?
It's not the lungs direct effect on the eyes, more that forcing air out, locally and temporarily increases blood pressure, which is connected to ocular pressure. If you already have an issue with ocular hypertension, or you've had eye surgery, that's where there are risk factors. I wasn't able to read the full article as I don't have a current subscription to PubMed, but from the abstract that's what it appears the researchers were looking at.
 
If surgeon says 'no', then 'no'. A friend of mine is a conservatoire trained bassoonist (plays oboe and sax as well). He had an issue a few years ago and surgeon's advice was the same - do not play. That was regularly reviewed and he was allowed to resume playing some time later.
 
I agree that the time will fly. It is a good discipline to do other things you will be a better player when you come back to it. I am not sure even lower pressure wind instruments would be safe so if it is for a short time and your livelihood doesn’t depend on sax playing go for learning about chord structure, harmony and or rhythm on a non-wind instrument.

My thought of asking about alternative lower pressure instruments will just take up yours and his time and will probably still entail some risk.

Make sure your precious sight is protected and have a new focus and plan for the interim ideally with a teacher / mentor on guitar, bass, keyboard or drums so you learn transferable stuff optimally
 
Thanks for all your comments.
I appreciate every one.
The science: I suspect it’s the resistance involved in blowing into a mouthpiece with a reed which raises eye pressure. Pop yourthumb in your mouth, seal and blow!
I’m certainly not arguing with my specialist!
One other factor I have to consider is the operation not being a full success, and the pressure issue remaining, so thanks in particular to those who mentioned flute.
I’m arranging a couple of interviews to see if playing a flute is so low resistance as to pose me no threat.
What do doublers think?

I plan to review all your suggestions in a while to provide a resource for people who might ask a similar question on the future.
 
I agree that (providing your consultant say it's OK), flute is a great idea. Not Oboe, I think it may cause even more pressure than saxophone.

Not playing is no stranger to me. I have been unable to play for months for other health reasons, but am determined to keep trying from time to time.
 
Last edited:
I hope the massed expertise here can help me with a crucial question.
My eye specialist has just warned me off playing sax (mostly tenor), at least until I have recovered from a forthcoming operation. That could take me through until October.
The problem is internal eye pressure. The suspicion is that playing sax will make a critical condition worse – and the potential damage is permanent, so no scope for messing around.
I’ve seen earlier threads here on the medical side of things: the science is not clear. However, my consultant is a professor whose partner plays tenor sax, so I’m obliged to listen to him.
My crucial question is: what strategies have people used when forced to stop playing sax for a fairly lengthy period?
I have a few ideas and may develop more once the sense of shock wears off (new strings ordered for my long-abandoned electric guitar, theory books already pulled off the shelf, work started on long-planned new playlists I’ve always meant to create, and sheets of music set aside for analysis).
In the meantime I’d be grateful, please, for all suggestions to keep me from losing too much in the coming months.
@BertieBut - the question that really strikes me about your original post in this thread is why you are on earth do you ask the opinion of non-medical people instead of referring back to your surgeon for advice? It seems insane to me, to go to a medical professional and then ask from advice from a bunch of (for the most part, I suspect) amateur musicians. It's like taking lessons with a top professional saxophone player, questioning the professional advice you get, and then asking your GP for advice on playing the saxophone.
If your surgeon has said don't blow - don't blow.
 
@BertieBut - the question that really strikes me about your original post in this thread is why you are on earth do you ask the opinion of non-medical people instead of referring back to your surgeon for advice? It seems insane to me, to go to a medical professional and then ask from advice from a bunch of (for the most part, I suspect) amateur musicians. It's like taking lessons with a top professional saxophone player, questioning the professional advice you get, and then asking your GP for advice on playing the saxophone.
If your surgeon has said don't blow - don't blow.
What I took from the question was regarding things that would help but without actually playing the saxophone. So the question was/is valid.

It's true there have been suggestions to play the flute and in this regard it could be a feasible thing to do so may be helpful -however - your are right in that it is something that should be referred back to the professional. (See my post #34 above)

It does seem like it could well be true that flute does not have the same pressure issues - but someone already diagnosed and taking advice from a consultant should not just take this as safe advice because forum users (non-medical people) suggested it asa possibility.

It could be down to whether the consultant has knowledge of the issues with various different wind instruments, iff proper clinical trials have been carried out. My gut feeling however is that they would err on the side of caution and just say no winds at all.
 
Last edited:
I'm pretty sure the best thing is to find a non blowing instrument.

On the more academic side... I found this study on intraoral pressure - which is somehow related.

Which has this graph which does suggest the flute is better than sax and is between not much worse than taking and about twice the increase in pressure... So? What's safe?


Screenshot_20220703_115031.webp
 
That table is very interesting but it's possible the saxophone could be way higher for some people as I imagine the test instrument had an average strength reed and facing.
 
Last edited:
No doubt.
I've got some form of overtone flute and the difference in air pressure (speed) needed to sound higher and higher (over)tones, and different length instruments, is really significant... And is documented in this paper (figures 7/8) One would have to dig up the paper on the sax / western instruments to see what's covered.

But it's useful to actually see the scale of things relative to talking.
 
Last edited:
I imagine the test instrument had an average strength reed and facing.
Curiosity got the better of me


Appendix B

Both saxophonists where classical alto, 3.5 reeds, Vandoren A28 and Selmer C*.
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,076
Messages
578,679
Members
8,134
Latest member
banjo
Back
Top Bottom