Teaching Extra scale/arpeggio practice!

If your making mistakes as you practice then your playing them too fast. When your learning something new such as scales you have to practice them so slow that you can play them perfectly every time. This can be challenging and tedious at times but I can tell you that if you are willing to do this then eventually you will be able to think a scale and your fingers will just do it.
 
Hello Everybody,

For those of you that love scales (we know there are some;}) I've got some extra scale practice. It involves:

Scales:
Major,
The three minors (natural, harmonic and melodic),
and a thirds patern on the above four scales, for example, here is the patern in C major:
C E D F E G, and so on.

Arpeggios:
Major,
Minor,
Dominant 7th

You play all of these in succesion in one key! So, if you started on all of these in the key of C, the next step is to find the 5th degree of C, which is G, and you repeat the whole process on G, when you have done this, find the fith degree of G, and so on. You are essentially going through the circle of fiths! This is very tricky to do, unless you know your scales very well!

Hope this helps, have fun practising!

Lewis

Major Request Here:

Could someone please record this entire exercise in one key so I can hear what's going on? I'm that lame. I need to hear what this should sound like.

Thanks in advance to any takers. :welldone
 
If your making mistakes as you practice then your playing them too fast. When your learning something new such as scales you have to practice them so slow that you can play them perfectly every time. This can be challenging and tedious at times but I can tell you that if you are willing to do this then eventually you will be able to think a scale and your fingers will just do it.

This is first-class advice.
 

I have a real keyboard, a real guitar, and a real sax too.

I just want to hear someone else play this exercise on a sax. :sax:

You people are no fun. :verysad

Should this exercise be played with a swing field?

What does it sound like when someone is really getting into it?

How do they play the arpeggios?

I want to hear someone play this exercise with SOUL. :mrcool

Come on now. Don't let me down.

Someone step up to the sax mic please. It's open arpeggio night!

1, 2, 3, 4,.... :sax:
 
You people are no fun. :verysad

I want to hear someone play this exercise with SOUL. :mrcool

Well, call me boring (oh, sorry, you just did) but I'm not sure that putting your soul into it is really the point of scale practice. By all means use varying rhythms and articulations to keep it interesting, but for me the idea is to learn your chords and scales well enough that your fingers (and your pitch adjusments) just find the notes without you having to work them out. It's more a matter of accuracy than soul. That comes later when you put this stuff into practice when you're performing.
 
Well, this is rather interesting.

I'm trying to do this myself, and you need to understand that I'm a RAW beginner on the sax. Plus I have a really cheap crappy horn, which has to be harder to play than a "real" saxophone. 🙂))

What I did was first record some guitar rhythm in the key of C at about 120 bps.

Then I started playing the sax over that in the C major scale.

It sounded HORRIBLE!

Then I realized that an alto sax plays in the Eb.

Ok, so I re-did the guitar back-up using an Eb chord progression.

Ah, MUCH BETTER!

Of course, I'm getting a lot of squawks and squeals, and bad fingerings. So it's far to early to actually try to record this. I'm doing more than just running up and down the scale, I'm playing a bit of a tune, but still sticking with working up and down the scale.

So what the heck am I doing?

Am I practicing the C major scale? Or the Eb scale?

These transposing instruments always confuse me. Should I have left the guitar chords in C major, and transposed the sax to play a C major scale against that? Which of course would be a different scale on the sax obviously.

This has always been confusing for me, even with the clarinet. I can transpose easy enough, but I never know what key I'm actually playing in.

If a guitar player wants me to play in the key of C, I guess I need to play a different scale on the Alto sax so that it actually comes out of the horn in the key of C to match the guitar.

This can be confusing.

Right now I'm playing the "C-scale" on the sax, but it's coming out in Eb, and so I need to play in Eb on the guitar so I can play in C on the sax.

Something doesn't seem right about all this.

If I want to play in the key of C (concert pitch), then I need to play in the key of A on an Eb alto sax, is that right?

So should I be practicing in the key of "A" and just call that the key of "C"?

As it is now I guess I'm actually playing in the key of Eb thinking that I'm playing in the key of C.

I knew someone else should have done this because I'm going to screw it up big time. 🙂))
 
Point of a transposing instrument is to take a part written in one key and play it in another. This is the transposition.

So stick to the written key that the part for your instrument is in - so if it's written in C, then call it C - or be specific and call it Eb concert. When it's relevant, worry about which key you're really in, otherwise do as you're doing and forget about it.

Although the alto actually plays down below the written pitch, it's easier to think of it as playing a minor third higher than written. A->C is a minor third up, so you're correct on the play in A to be in C. Difference is you're playing an octave lower than you think from the rule. So playing the A above middle C (2nd blank on the stave) on your alto gives you middle C in concert pitch.
 
When it's relevant, worry about which key you're really in, otherwise do as you're doing and forget about it.

Well, for me it's going to be relevant quite often since I'll be playing with other fellows who typically play guitar, bass guitar, and keyboard. For them, the key of C means Concert C.

I created a transposing wheel of fifths for the also sax. I couldn't find one searching the net. Now I can learn the important keys that I'm most likely to need and see at a glance how they relate to the concert keys.

sax_circle_fifths.GIF


Edited to add
: I suppose I should explain that I added the outer most ring to an existing circle of fifths. The outer most ring of keys are the keys the Alto Sax needs to play to be in the same audible key with concert pitch instruments. I hope I got this right. I think it's right.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
I'm not sure you're not going to confuse yourself more by doing this. Playing in the key of "C" on a transposing instrument means playing the fingerings for that key. IMHO, you should learn the key fingerings by their correct names and worry about how you fit in with the band separately.
 
I'm not sure you're not going to confuse yourself more by doing this. Playing in the key of "C" on a transposing instrument means playing the fingerings for that key. IMHO, you should learn the key fingerings by their correct names and worry about how you fit in with the band separately.

I agree. But that's precisely what I'm doing. If my friends want to play in the key of "C", then I need to play the "A" scale against that. I'm not looking at the A scale as being the C scale. I'm fully recognizing that I'm playing the A scale. So in that sense I am using the correct names for the notes on the sax. But by glancing at this chart I can know what scale I need to play against a particular key.

I'm talking about improvising here. If I have sheet music that's already transposed for Eb, then I'll just use that.
 
That nice Mr Thomas' Saxophone pages tell you all about transposition and there is a useful chart for Bb and Eb instruments against concert pitch that I always a carry a copy of with me http://tamingthesaxophone.com/saxophone-transposition.html
YC

Yes, I've seen those. All I did here was wrap the Eb column around a standard circle of fifths. It's just easier for me personally because already use this circle of fifths for music compositions in general anyway, so now I have the sax on the outermost circle for quick reference.
 
Why add another layer, when all you do is read the minor key but play the major starting on the same note? Saves another layer of translation.

Dave

Interesting observation. I didn't even notice that. It just happens to work out that way for Eb transpositions evidently. That's quite interesting. I was thinking of making another one of these for Bb instruments. But now that you've pointed out that Eb is the same as the minors then all I really need is a outer circle with the Bb transposing on the outside for trumpet and clarinet.

Like so:

Trumpet_circle_fifths.GIF


Now, you're probably going to say that I really only need to look at the minor key just in the next counterclockwise position to find the key for Bb. 🙂))

Well, you're right. But I would have never noticed either of these things had we not had this conversation. ;}

So I'm learning a lot about the circle of fifths today. :welldone
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,071
Messages
578,547
Members
8,133
Latest member
walthang
Back
Top Bottom