Tech/maintenance Expanding Selmer tenor neck tenon

saxmad

Member
Messages
110
Location
North Norfolk
My SA80 neck/crook was loose and neck tightening by the screw made no difference. In the absence of a neck expander I found a socket that was a tight fit, inserted in the socket handle and gently put it in the horns neck and applied little sideways pressure. It now fits snugly.
SA80 neck.webp
 
So what OP's probably done is to slightly upset the 1 or 2 mm immediately above the open end, giving the thing a slight bell mouth. I had a horn that an incompetent repairer did something similar and it was tight to insert but wobbled once in.

What you need to do is to expand that whole cylinder evenly. You need to take measurements as you go. There are a couple different designs of tools that do that job.

For that matter, unless you measure the thing you don't even know if it's tapered or in which direction, barrel shaped, hourglass, out of round, and/or any combination of the above.
 
I call that a 'shop fit'.
It takes quite a lot of time to fit a crook properly, and many players rightly perceive a loose crook fit as an issue that needs to be adressed. So some shops give a loose crook tenon a quick whizz on an expander so that the joint feels tight. But that's often all it does - it doesn't necessarily mean the joint is airtight...which is its whole point.

As Turf3 says, you've very probably stretched or distorted the end of the tenon sleeve - so that the joint bow appears to be tight - leaving the rest of it as loose as it ever was.
You might have got lucky though. If the joint seals all the way around the bottom of the sleeve then, technically speaking, it'll be sealing. But it's unlikely to last very long, and it raises the prospect that wear will be created at the bottom of the tenon socket.

There are a couple of simple tests you can do to check for this. Pop the crook in the socket/receiver, leave the clamp screw loose and then try to rock the crook up and down from the the mouthpiece cork. If the joint is a good or at least reasonable fit, it won't budge.
Next, take a Sharpie and draw four evenly-spaced vertical lines around the tenon sleeve. Allow the ink to dry then instert the crook in the normal fashion. Remove it in the same way, the examine the marks to see where they've been rubbed off. The scuffing should be even all the way round and should extend up to at least where the expansion slot in the socket sits...and preferably beyond. This is the minimum qualification for a fit.
Look particularly for 'air paths'. Any unscuffed areas will allow air through, so it could track, say, halfway up one line then move across to another one and track futher up

But before you do any of that, remove the crook clamp screw, gently slip the blade of a large screwdriver into the slot cut into the clamp and give the blade a careful twist to attempt to open the slot out...while looking at the underside of the clamp directly below the slot. What you're looking to check for is that the clamp is securely fitted to the socket. It's very common (particularly on Selmers) to find that the solder has broken down (via selective galvanic corrosion). If this is the case it'll be almost impossible to achieve a decent fit until the clamp ring has been removed, cleaned and resoldered in place.
 
I’ll have to admit many years ago I did use the same technique as the OP has. But it was more to round the tenon than to expand it. Anyone attempting this technique it is very important that the inside of the tube is extremely clean. Oil or smear of grease is good Insurance for preventing a stuck assembly.
As a DIY fit with this technique it’s very important to have measuring tools. Measure the inside of the receiver. Measure the outside of the tenon. Measure crossways in three different locations, and then top, middle and bottom of each side. @ 0,1 mm / .004 you will have a leak. The neck/crook should slide in and out with ease when the fit is absolutely correct. No binding. Maybe a little rotation while inserting but it should not be forced.

Check your starting point fit. The T shaped tool is a inside caliper. Measuring the inside of the receiver. One side is spring loaded. Inserted into the receiver to the measurement point. Locked down and then extracted.
The measurement is then taken with a caliper.
1708108065116.jpeg

Next measure the tenon. The difference in the measurement is how loose the fit is.
1708108187990.jpeg

Rotate the part to measure it again at the same location. But at a cross / right angle. This will show if it is out of round.
1708108337112.jpeg


Checking fit with a colored sharpie is a helpful guide as Steve mentions above. My initial pre-repair I coat the part heavily.
1708107676315.jpeg

Obtaining fit on this one I used a can opener style expander. There are different type expanders. There are also shrinking tools to round/shrink the part for a exact fit. The cost of these tools far exceed the DIY tech. This is why it’s best to take it to a tech if possible. A knackered repair cost double for a tech to fix. Consider this post information of what you get in value having your tech do the repair.
1708108620435.jpeg


Final check before I do a leak test. Before and after picture. Notice the bands in three locations. This is also where I take the measurements.
1708109017320.jpeg
 
Last edited:
1708109071649.jpeg


Good enough for leak checking. I use an expanding plug below the receiver.
1708109146893.jpeg


1708109188193.jpeg


Insert the neck/crook into the joint. Unclamped blow on the cork end gently. Hold A finger over the octave hole. Positive pressure should be felt. It’s also possible to put a light brushing of soapy water on the fitting. Any leaks will show as bubbles. Bubbles at this point a DIY should stop and have a professional technician address fit. The clamp only keeps the neck from moving while playing.
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,070
Messages
578,524
Members
8,132
Latest member
LouisJR
Back
Top Bottom