Saxophones Excellent entry level alto

I saw your original post and thought 'that's a lot of money!'. My alto is a 1920s True Tone, and I really like it. I bought it a long time ago (before the internet) when 200 quid for an instrument, when I was borrowing one at the time, was 100 quid less than they generally cost, so I bought it, privately. It came with a rather chewed Selmer Soloist 'E' which I liked straight away, though it was a long time later (thanks to the internet) that I found that other people liked them too. These days there is also a Chinese who-knows-what alto hanging around here, which at 80 quid (from a shop!) was really really cheap. I like it as much as the Buescher, really; on the plus side the keywork is not worn out and rattly; on the minus it isn't very cool. Except for some odd reason it has a Selmer neck on it, which is why I noticed it. For some reason the Soloist mouthpiece doesn't work as well on it as it does on the Buescher. I don't think you have to spend a lot of money.
 
Or is it better to re-acquaint yourself with sax on a more basic model, then if you 'take to it', after a few years under your belt and your fingers, start honing in on the tangible aspects (or intangible) which move you (tonality, blowing response, etc) ? IOW, wouldn't a $650 used alto provide you with all you 'need' to re-start ?
Those were my thoughts exactly. One that is in decent playing shape. Plus, if one takes care of it, can sell it for about what one expended especially if it is a name brand or a name brand as a stencil sold under another name, like the Le Blanc Vito's.

Took my recently serviced by Tarpley Music, Lubbock, Texas, 1980's Selmer Bundy II alto out for a spin, and even it is a decent sounding / feeling / playing sax in its own right.

In tonight's Clovis (NM) Community Band rehearsal, I was playing the Baritone Treble Clef part on God Bless The USA by Lee Green arranged by Roger Holmes (band was missing the tenor part) on my Vito by Jupiter (closest match IMHO the Jupiter JTS-689) in its lower range down to low Bb.

Serviced, it didn't skip a beat, sounded good on the bottom end using a Bari Esprit mouthpiece and a #2 Rico reed with Rovner lig. The sax has an extremely nice full tone, balanced well with the upper woodwinds and augmented the lower brass well. It definitely holds up well to the intermediates.

With a year or two under one's belt, then one has a better idea of what the next step up sax will be.

Again, this is an option and I gather the OP has already in his mind what would meet his expectations. There is a lot of freedom in the music world. But, the nice thing about an interim sax allows one without breaking the bank to afford more time to get what one truly wants.
 
Is in decent playing shape, the same as,
in excellent playing condition with
an easily navigable scale? 🧐
My definition, as a tech and seller of refurbed:

"Decent Play Shape" - the horn speaks up and down all registers cleanly, has no serious body or neck damage, and is not filthy.

Honestly, you cannot realistically ASK for MORE if buying a used sax online from a private party/seller (IOW not a repair shop or experienced DIY repairer).

If sold by the latter, they should have the self-respect to prepare it better than the above. It should be cleaned and any dings removed, check for key play and correct if needed, and any pads which are beginning to look or act long-in-tooth should be replaced.

I see too many music shops with repair depts do the absolute minimum on their saxes before hanging a pricetag on 'em.
That's inexcusable, IMHO.
They have the shop right there, they could pay their tech for two hours of servicing and cleaning to take care of any higher-priority issues...for goodness sake.
Not like they'd 'lose' money.
 
OP, you didn't tell us what kind of tenor you're playing. Getting something closely related in an alto will make the transition easier (Conn tenor, Conn alto; Selmer tenor, practically any modern essentially-fungible Far East Selmer copy alto; etc.)
 
Thanks for this thread. A long-term exclusive tenor player, I've been considering buying a cheap, used alt sax for a while. Just for occasional use in my 'rock/pop band'. So a lot of food for thought from this thread 🙂
 
You could also rent an alto for a few months. Take some lessons and really see if you want to continue. Meanwhile review your options.
That’s what I ended up doing based on your suggestion. I rented a horn for a couple months so I can get back to playing the alto and feel like maybe I can do a competent test drive on a possible horn for purchase in early 2026.
 
That’s what I ended up doing based on your suggestion. I rented a horn for a couple months so I can get back to playing the alto and feel like maybe I can do a competent test drive on a possible horn for purchase in early 2026.
That is a sound approach. Local music stores get competition from Ebay, Amazon, Reverb, and etc. So to sell used instruments, some have good pricing. As @JayeNM mentioned, chances are, a decent music store will have their saxes properly serviced so you don't wind up with a problem out the door. Plus, you have an opportunity to try it out hands on.

I've been buying my saxes from Internet auctions, but for a time, I was being careful and doing my own servicing as well. But now they have a decent woodwind tech in nearby Lubbock, TX, store in town is a satellite, I've been taking my horns there to have them serviced. It is nice to just have someone do, pay some and it plays like it should.
 
That’s what I ended up doing based on your suggestion. I rented a horn for a couple months so I can get back to playing the alto and feel like maybe I can do a competent test drive on a possible horn for purchase in early 2026.
I agree good plan. If you want to buy a horn you can playtest first, which is always the best situation really, then either Craigslist or a local Music shop are really your options.

The drawbacks of CL are, depending on your locality, the 'saxes for sale' category may not have much going on. The drawbacks of a shop are, their prices tend to be significantly higher than what you can get the same exact model for, online. But shops are good to at least playtest certain models. And sometimes they will negotiate.

Drawbacks on both, honestly, might be the sax is NOT in top play shape.

A private seller often doesn't really have the tools to assess this, they just know it plays sorta OK. "It plays for ME" sorta thing....which doesn't mean top play condition.

And, oddly, a walk-in shop selling used instruments often does NOT actually have those instruments serviced by their repair person 😳bizarre as that may sound. So that might be another point of negotiation (on a brand new instrument -and again that is gonna be pricey, I am talking even a middling-sorta-medium-ok-reputation brand alto starts at around $1300 min. - they should absolutely guarantee it has been tech checked and setup, for free).

The third option is an online seller with a return policy...in which instance if the horn gets damaged in transit or is not as seller described, they will take a return and issue a refund.
 
That’s what I ended up doing based on your suggestion. I rented a horn for a couple months so I can get back to playing the alto and feel like maybe I can do a competent test drive on a possible horn for purchase in early 2026.
I’m curious if the rental is new or used and brand. Did the store offer maintenance included ? Lastly was an option of rent to own offered ?
 
Cannonball Alcazar. $45 per month that can be applied towards purchase of a new horn.
So you’re playing a used CB Alcazar. $45 monthly rental fee that 100% can be applied to a brand new one of same model?
Be aware that CB doesn’t allow price advertising. No phone shopping either. Prices are only offered in person at dealers.
So how are you enjoying the journey so far ?
 
Tuner w Eb setting. MP closer using Wanne NY bros vs. Jody HR (slightly flatter).
Quit switching back & forth between A & T for two weeks.
Set MPC to best play / tune position. Remove the neck & Mpc and blow again. You should be close to F4 on tuner.
Tune neck & Mpc to F4, install and play Bb. Then C (LH2)
If I didn’t know better I’d say the key heights are too low. Odd for a rental.

@skeller047 @LostCircuits can you guys make any suggestions to help ?
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,057
Messages
578,196
Members
8,127
Latest member
PJ2116
Back
Top Bottom