Miscellaneous Escape from Idiocrasy

Just as an Explanation

I'm not attempting to call this music teacher an 'idiot' in a mean and venomous way.

In fact, I didn't really think he was an idiot until I got home and started thinking about everything that had occurred. When I got to his store I went in and commented on how quaint and cozy his store is. It's actually an old house on Main Street made into a store, and it is quite nice.

Then I asked him how sales were because I was curious as to how he is making out in a small town with the economy the way it is. His response was quite dismal. Evidently he's not making many sales. Then I asked him how he's making out with students. I was particularly interested to here about that because if he said he was swamped I wasn't even going to suggest my offer. But no, he wasn't swamped at all. On the contrary he gave a very dismal reply to that question to.

So here he is standing in a large music store with just me and him and no other customers to be seen. So I told him that I saw his brochure for music lessons and his offer to 'work with people's individual music needs'. That was the advertising LINE that actually caused me to drop in on him in the first place.

It was then that I proceeded to describe my 'individual music needs'. His rejection of my proposal was fairly abrupt, along with his explanation that this could ruin his reputation if things don't work out. So clearly he did have some sort of fear associated with trying something new. And I guess that did make him feel uncomfortable.

I talked with him about it, but he seemed more interested in arguing against it than in trying to "work with me" on it. Contrary to what he had suggested in his brochure.

So I left without pressing the point too much. No hard feelings. No skin off my nose. I was just looking to see if we could work something out.

It wasn't really until I go home that I starting to think, "What an idiot". I mean, here the man is with a big music store and the skills and talent to help out a potential musician. His sales are down, he has few if any students, and he's not even prepared to "work with people" in an effort to accommodate a new student.

So that was when I decided he must be an 'idiot'. πŸ™‚))

So it wasn't actually mean as a venomous attack on him.

In the meantime, I don't truly care. Whether the teaching arrangement would have worked out or not I'll never know. And neither will he.

In the meantime I'm happy with ordering educational materials over the Internet.

If he's happy standing around in an empty store with no students, more power to him.

That's all I know.

I'll retract the judgment that he's an idiot, and just leave things the way they stand.

My apologies for ranting about it at the Cafe Saxophone. It got here only because it was music related.

~~~

Oh, by the way, I was going to start off with Saxophone lessons. But like I say, even he confessed to not be so great at playing reed instruments. So maybe it's best for me that things turned out the way they did after all.
 
Re: Just as an Explanation

The thread raises some good points.

In many ways I agree with the teacher, but not his attitude. And it sounds as if he's driving business away with the way he deals with people.

However someone learning to play many instruments is going to have to compromise on what's attainable, given the time required to learn and maintain the necessary skills.

I can't understand why he'd be worried about his reputation - firstly a student's progress depends on the work the student puts in, and the teacher's reputation comes more from word of mouth and this depends on personal factors as much (or more so) than teaching ability.
 
Re: Just as an Explanation

However someone learning to play many instruments is going to have to compromise on what's attainable, given the time required to learn and maintain the necessary skills.

I agree, and would go a bit further. Suppose you have two years (or 20 or whatever) to learn, say, saxophone and trumpet as well as you can. I think the time would be better spent learning one of them alone first, and only introducing the second after a year or so (or maybe 4 years if you're working to a 20 year schedule; I'm just making the numbers up as I go along). Naturally I'd go for the sax first as its much more important >:). That way you already know what it sounds and feels like to play a wind instrument to a certain level. This will make your practice on the second instrument much more productive when you do start on it.
 
Re: Just as an Explanation

Re. finding a teacher...I found a great teacher at a gig once. I'd gone to a blues festival and saw a guy play there. I thought - he's fabulous, I wish I could play like that, it's exactly the sort of sound I love. Anyway, I went over and talked to him afterwards and he had just moved into the area and said he would give lessons. It takes me around an hour to get there and I only see if once every few months for maybe an hour and a half. But I learn enough from him on technique and things to practice to last me until the next time I see him. So maybe it's worth going to see live bands and if you like what you hear, it's worth asking. You could be seeing a lot of different types of music with all those instruments! Great fun.
 
Re: Dealing with an Idiot

My take on this is this: I wouldn't go to anyone who claimed to be able to teach all those instruments unless I had heard him play and I was sufficiently impressed. My tack would be to go to a really good player and teacher of each instrument separately even if it meant I had to pay more, travel further, and/or go less often. Sometimes it's better to go and have a longer lesson if you have to travel further.

Pete
 
Re: Dealing with an Idiot

My take on this is this: I wouldn't go to anyone who claimed to be able to teach all those instruments unless I had heard him play and I was sufficiently impressed. My tack would be to go to a really good player and teacher of each instrument separately even if it meant I had to pay more, travel further, and/or go less often. Sometimes it's better to go and have a longer lesson if you have to travel further.

Pete

Yes, agreed. But Sweet dreamer is over a barrel as he has no other choice in his area.
 
Re: Dealing with an Idiot

He must have a choice if he is prepared to travel further - that's why I said "even if it meant etc etc.

I sometimes drive more than 2 hours to have the an occasional 90 minute lesson with someone who is really worth it.

Pete
 
Re: Dealing with an Idiot

He must have a choice if he is prepared to travel further - that's why I said "even if it meant etc etc.

I sometimes drive more than 2 hours to have the an occasional 90 minute lesson with someone who is really worth it.

Pete
Same here - I used to travel 2 hours each way to see a viol tutor. Fortunately, I've now discovered that there is a good one only 20 miles away.
 
My Dream Last Night

I've decided to share with everyone my personal insecurities and emotional instability by describing the dream I had last night. It reveals my overly fragile sensitivity to rejection I suppose:


The Music Store Nightmare

I dreamed that I was at the music store proposing my plan for my personal musical needs concerning music lessons in the most sincere way that I could muster. The music teacher was completely insensitive to my needs and harshly dismissed them as being the the futile dreams of a pathetic looser.

I begged for the music teacher to hear me out and accept my sincerity on pure faith. But he was relentless in his dismissal of my needs. He began to shout at me, screaming that I'm a disgrace to the musical community and that there couldn't be one once of sincerity anywhere in my entire body.

Then he poked me in the chest really hard. His hand penetrated my flesh and he grasped onto my heart and ripped it from my body. He stood there stabbing my heart with a dozen or so razor-sharp French-cut Bari reeds. He then plunged my reed-laden heart back into my chest and told me to get my pathetic insincere butt out of his store, and to never show my musically disgraceful face in his store ever again.

I was emotionally devastated. I ran from the store wailing in emotional pain. A river of tears trailing my every step. I fell into the muddy berm of the road, and crawled home in the mud suffering the shame of being such an insincere musical wannabe.

When I got home I sat in my yard in a pool of tears as my aching bari-reed ridden heart throbbed in my chest to the syncopated beat of forlorn blues.

Suddenly the clouds parted in the sky and a brilliant beam of sunshine pierced the dismal mist and focused at my feet on the ground before me.

The Angels Came

An archangel appeared before me as a vision, and said unto me in a soft loving voice, "Don't let that bully teacher bring you down. All of heaven knows that you are sincere, and no mortal bully can change that. Rise up and become the musical wonder you were born to be.

A host of angels envelope me healing my wounds and kissing away my tears of emotional blues. The bari-reeds that sticking in my heart were magically transformed into golden trumpet cups. The angels descended upon the trumpet cups of my heart and placed their lips upon them. They began to play a melody in middle-C filling my heart with the rhapsody of ecstasy as they blew divine harmonic raspberries into my throbbing pump filling me with supreme intonation.

The archangel said unto me, "You will become a great self-learner, and Amazon dot com will love you forever and will always accept your money with great love and respect for you musical sincerity. Go now with the music faeries, and they will show you the way.

The Music Faeries

From behind the archangel appeared a troop of music faeries. The leader of the troop took me by the hand and led me into the magical musical forest where every tree was alive with the spiritual essence of a particular musical instrument.

The musical fae told me that it is wonderful that I desire to play many different instruments and that this is a rare quality among the mortal humans. The fae understand and appreciate musical diversity. She told me that her troop has been assigned to help me in my self-learning journey from within.

She then sprinkled faery dust on me and said, "This is for the saxophone". Another fae swung from a vine in a tree sprinkling faery dust on me saying, "This is for the trumpet". Many other fae, in-turn, sprinkled fairy dust on me for drums, guitar, fiddle, cello, and even my new goat-skinned bongos.

She then said, "Whenever you play, if you are having problems with anything, just be silent for a moment, think of us, and we'll be there to guide your way"

I Awoke from the Dream

I feel much better now. The angels love me. The faeries love me. Amazon dot com loves me too. And that bully teacher doesn't bother me at all. His bari-reed attack on my heart has been transformed into magical trumpet cups and I've been filled with divine intonation from the lips of angels. Now I even have an entire troop of fairies assigned to help me on my self-learning journey.

;}
 
Re: My Dream Last Night

just a few comments

1. Never be afraid that you are, or will be called, a loser, whether by yourself or anyone else. There's no such thing. Life is not a game to be won or lost. It's a fantastic opportunity whch we all won on the day we were born, and will lose on the day we die. We should all try to make the most of it, and have to decide for ourselves what that "most" consists of.

2. It is great and noble that you love music and want to devote a significant amount of your life to making music.

3. In my opinion, it would be wise to look around at other people who make the kind of music you like, and find out how they achieved the skills needed to do it. I doubt very much if any of them learned purely from books and CDs, useful though those things can be. It's extemely helpful someone with experience who can listen to what you're doing and point out where it differs from what you think you are doing, or why a certain approach may be unproductive. Various people on this site, who are more accomplished musicians than you or I, have given you advice here on how to learn and whether it's a good idea to learn many instruments at once. Of course you're perfectly free to ignore that advice and follow your own pre-set course. But it's likely that you'll get much more pleasure from your musical journey, if you find someone (or ones) you respect and let them guide you along the way.

I'm not sure if the above comments make me a faerie, an angel or a nasty music store guy with a stabby reed. I hope I'm none of them --- just a bloke muddling along like everyone else, who happens to love playing and listening to saxophone music.
 
Re: My Dream Last Night

I agree with your comments Big Martin.

What I'd really like to do even more than finding a teacher is to simply get together with other musicians and just jam, practice, improv, or whatever. Inspired and encourage each other.

Deciding to go to a teacher was really almost a choice of desperation. And when the teacher wasn't even interested when I was willing to PAY for the company, that was like the final blow.

I can't even pay someone to play music with me. That's a pretty sad situation to be in.
 
Re: My Dream Last Night

For me the term 'loser' is reflexive. Always.

Well, in a psychological sense, it may very well be the case. I don't doubt that for a second.

I mean think about it.

You read a brochure from a music store offering to "Work with your personal musical needs".

So you go over to the music store with cash in hand prepared to purchase their service.

When you arrive they say to you, "No, we aren't willing to work with YOUR personal needs! We think you're an insincere person, get lost, we don't want your money or your patronage".

I think at the very least you'd toss their brochure in the TRASH CAN on your way home.

πŸ™‚))

And I seriously doubt that you would be inclined to say nice things about them after that.

And if you're a very sensitive person the experience may very well cause you to feel like a 'looser'.
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway πŸ˜€

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,075
Messages
578,663
Members
8,134
Latest member
banjo
Back
Top Bottom