Playing the saxophone Earl Bostic Example False Fingering Query

saxxyknickers

New Member
Messages
2
Location
Canada
Hi all –I'm a noobie here.
I'm coming from the TamingTheSaxophone.com site –some really great info there –Thanks Pete!

I'm learning the sax by myself, and I do have a question about how to play an example listed on TamingTheSaxophone.com.

Under Lessons & Tutorials/Saxophone Effects/False Fingerings, there is an example of a passage by Earl Bostic, with the G above the staff played 3 times in a row –the first as regular G (natural), the second as G with an open circle "o" above it, and the third as G with a plus sign "+" above it (this appears in both Bars 1 + 3) –the text above the passage says that it's alternating between a regular G in the upper register (G2), and a low C fingering (C1) sounding the second harmonic (G2).

Which of these fingerings do the open circle and plus sign symbols stand for (as the first G is already natural), as it goes: G, Go, G+
[Note the "o" and "+" signs were above the second and third Gs –also in Bar 3, there's a minus sign "-" under the "+" sign (not sure if this is a typo?)]

If Mr. Pete Thomas might possibly be available, perhaps he might be able to address this –or if anyone has any ideas, that would be really great.
[I did already read the post on Plus and Circle Symbols over Notes, but didn't feel that it completely addressed this question]

Also, in this example in Bar 2, it says "Shake" over a G half-note (or minim, I believe) –does this literally mean to shake the saxophone while playing it, or is it some kind of trill? And if so, how exactly would it be played?

Sorry if this has already been asked,
Thank you
 
I will need to check this but I think the o is regular and + is the false fingering. So really no difference between G without a marking and G with o, it’s just a way to indicate the alternation between open close like with trumpet mute notation. Oo wa oo wa

Shake is just a very wide vibrato.
 
Last edited:
This is something best learned by ear, or trial and error maybe, rather than transcribing and reading...

Here it is slowed down

 
Last edited:

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,079
Messages
578,702
Members
8,136
Latest member
peterdehelegrote
Back
Top Bottom