Miscellaneous Downloads vs CDs vs Vinyl

What format might you buy (please read post before voting)

  • I'd like a 12" vinyl LP or EP

    Votes: 3 9.7%
  • I'd buy the download and burn my own CD

    Votes: 8 25.8%
  • No, I want a proper CD in a nice Digipak etc.

    Votes: 15 48.4%
  • I'll just download it free illegally

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • Vinyl, CD & legal download

    Votes: 5 16.1%

  • Total voters
    31
  • Poll closed .
I prefer CDs these days, although I still have a nostalgia for vinyl and often play things from my collection on a Technics deck. Only problem with CD is that the liner notes are often printed too small and in weak colours against too strong a background colour.

Does anyone know what 8 track was? It seemed to be something of a status symbol , but needed a cassette the size of a large book. As I couldn't fit anything in my MG Midget apart from a small radio I never even bothered to find out what 8 track was.
YC
 
The oldest music I have started on vinyl was copied onto cassette then to cd and finally to mp3 as each became available and affordable. I listen to them according to convenience, house, car or shed etc. as background so the detailed technical quality of each format does not really matter.
Even if you have the best system in any format what you hear is obviously affected by the the room and any other surrounding noise and your own hearing.
 
Hm... having recently moved house I've had an epiphany of trying to minimize my personal possessions... though, conceptually, I love vinyl for- well- big artwork, the fact it breaks down into 20 minute units, and the general nerdy mystique of it... I've recently decided to go entirely digital for the sake of less clutter (I blame my kids!).
 
I am sure much younger cafe members will extol the virtues of digital downloads which are sterile, can be lost if not saved properly. Vinyl is fastidious i am sure but a whole experience and CD is well, just pretty bland.
Before i get ranting replies, i think in this day and age we need to embrace all music types. I use my i-pod an awful lot in the car as i can just put it on shuffle and have non stop music for hours on end, when i have the time i really love to sit down and listen to my vinyl in my music room, that is really listen and enjoy the music. I admit that the future will be downloads and some companies such as Linn of Scotland have announced that they won't be manufacturing CD players anymore.
I am aware that listening to CD through a really good system and properly set up can sound fantastic but high end gear, ( or even mid range gear ) is out of the reach of most of us. When you look at £2000 Cd players and their matching sources costing equally as much, throw in a speaker package at the same level then spend 10% of your budget on good interconnects and speaker cables the budget goes through the roof.
I am sure that eventually we will all listen to downloads in spite of resurgences in an interst in vinyl. Maybe CD will follow the same route?
 
I just bought the new Bellowhead album, which came on heavy duty vinyl, with additional CD. Now I only get vinyl for special things, and CD for routine things, especially as they can often be minimally priced (£2.99 or so).
Currently hate download, prefer CD for usual reasons given above.

Kind regards
Tom
 
Phil, I don't think you should get ranting replies (on Pete's forum, surely not!) as what you have said is entirely sensible. Alhough my preferred format is also CD these days, I do download some stuff and I do still listen to vinyl, especially where I haven't got reissues on CD.
What Targa said is also very pragmatic. I have a good hi fi system but I am sometimes surprised when I hear my CDs played on others' - sometimes better, sometimes worse and not necessarily dependent on price or apparent quality. It is a lot to do with room shape, furnishings, floor and wall coverings. And while I am about it, yes buy qood quality cables and conectors but there's as much rubbish talked about them as there is about saxophone accessories.

Now, were's my wax cylinder recorder. I must record some stuff from the player piano before the paper rolls wear out.
YC
 
Just make sure you don't get typo cast........................;}

I appreciate the various ways of listening to music, but still cling on to vinyl and CD because it feels like a special product, something professionally designed/produced, and I do not like the idea of a plain CD or download which you either have to write on with felt tip/crayons etc.,which feels/seems very amateur, or that just exists as some text on computer - feels very unimportant and irrelevant.

Kind regards
Tom
 
Hi YC, i know everyone is really nice on the forum.
I am very fortunate as my mate owns angelsound hi-fi specialising in hi end hi fi, even bloody xylophone music sounds good through some of his systems. He has some lovely kit, so i do know how good some music can sound. your right about room shape, furnishing etc as when i went to get a new system a few years back in a reputable hi fi chain i asked if i could try out the system at home. They said that it would sound exactly the same as in their showroom!! They did not even ask if i had carpet, curtains etc, needless to say they did not get my business. Buff up that wax cylinder recorder. Phil
Phil, I don't think you should get ranting replies (on Pete's forum, surely not!) as what you have said is entirely sensible. Alhough my preferred format is also CD these days, I do download some stuff and I do still listen to vinyl, especially where I haven't got reissues on CD.
What Targa said is also very pragmatic. I have a good hi fi system but I am sometimes surprised when I hear my CDs played on others' - sometimes better, sometimes worse and not necessarily dependent on price or apparent quality. It is a lot to do with room shape, furnishings, floor and wall coverings. And while I am about it, yes buy qood quality cables and conectors but there's as much rubbish talked about them as there is about saxophone accessories.

Now, were's my wax cylinder recorder. I must record some stuff from the player piano before the paper rolls wear out.
YC
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,072
Messages
578,577
Members
8,133
Latest member
walthang
Back
Top Bottom