Phil, I don't think you should get ranting replies (on Pete's forum, surely not!) as what you have said is entirely sensible. Alhough my preferred format is also CD these days, I do download some stuff and I do still listen to vinyl, especially where I haven't got reissues on CD.
What Targa said is also very pragmatic. I have a good hi fi system but I am sometimes surprised when I hear my CDs played on others' - sometimes better, sometimes worse and not necessarily dependent on price or apparent quality. It is a lot to do with room shape, furnishings, floor and wall coverings. And while I am about it, yes buy qood quality cables and conectors but there's as much rubbish talked about them as there is about saxophone accessories.
Now, were's my wax cylinder recorder. I must record some stuff from the player piano before the paper rolls wear out.
YC