Playing the saxophone Dot reader or Make-it-up merchant?

Dots here, - can't improvise for toffee if I'm playing along with others yet if I'm noodling on my own I can - weird. I put it down to the pressure of playing with others and the panic factor sets in. I can read perfectly well when playing alone or in a group and no panic. Guess I'm just more comfortable with reading. A friend of mine and great jazzer suggest i use the dots as a guide only and put my take on a piece. I can feel my fingers tightening in panic just a the thought. I persevere with this impro though in the hope that I will relax one day.
 
I suppose the other question to this is, how many can hum, whistle, sing, an improv on a tune they are listening to?

I suspect those of us who can 'only read dots' can't do an improv with voice which suggests we don't have the skill (or whatever) to improvise rather than being able to improvise in our head/voice but unable to translate that into note on the sax.

Now you see, I can do that, no problem, although my voice does sound a bit like a tuned foghorn. I can hear the highest note in a chord and can sing a third, fifth or octave over a given note, and I can sing a tune in any key you care to give me, give or take my limited range. I just cannot, for the life of me, translate the note I hear in my head to the correct note on the saxophone and neither can I recall instantly the notes of the chords, scales or whatever that I'm expected to 'noodle' around. It all just happens far too quickly for me.
 
Dot's and/or improv

Fortunately I can do both although neither to a particularly high standard, but as a fall-back I can also compose: I am able to hear a tune in my head and then add accompaniment, descant, harmonies on all different instruments brass, woodwind, strings anything. Don't know why, I just can; I like it. 😀

Cheers

Mart
 
I'm a reader and I find trying to play by ear frustrating. The tune Unforgettable is in the key of G concert in the old busking book I have here, and it begins on D. For an alto that would be E, starting note B.

Jim.

Hi Jim

Thanks for that, you coudn't tell me what old busking book your talking about could you,and if there is a modern equivallent that I can buy and where to get it from, my searches have been friutless.

I do know that these books exist but I am not sure which one to get and I believe you can get cd of complete backing tracks but which and where I don't know,any advice would be much apreciated ,,,john
 
Hi Jim

Thanks for that, you coudn't tell me what old busking book your talking about could you,and if there is a modern equivallent that I can buy and where to get it from, my searches have been friutless.

I do know that these books exist but I am not sure which one to get and I believe you can get cd of complete backing tracks but which and where I don't know,any advice would be much apreciated ,,,john

There are many unofficial ones floating around, but this one (& the Eb) brother is legit: http://www.amazon.co.uk/Real-Book-B-Flat-Books-Leonard/dp/0634060848/ref=pd_cp_b_1

tracks/discs also available - see links off that page...

Have a listen to "grovetonemusic" on Youtube who has been working though many of the vol 1 book (Jazz standard challenge of 1 new track per day for a year!) - excellent by the way..

I'm sure Jim will chip in with more...
 
The book I referred to is called "Buskin Round It" and contains no musical notation. On the cover it says, " The Key, The starting note, be it trumpet, alto, tenor, clarinet, trombone, piano, guitar and bass. It's all in here for 2500 standard songs." The book was published by B. Feldman & Co. Ltd in 1965 and distributed by EMI. Most of the contents are long forgotten tunes. With a book like this we have to know the tunes we want to play. I was able to play " Unforgettable " because I knew the key and the starting note. A friend borrowed this book and decided to make one up for himself. The lay out looks like this.

Instrument.

Eb Bb Con s/n p/u

E A G D Unforgettable
E A G D * When Day Is Done
E A G D Way Down Yonder In New Orleans
E A G D * Twist Again
The songs with an asterisk begin with a pick up and not on the first beat of the bar. Happy buskin.

Jim.
 
Interesting subject this. I can only play a tune if I have the dots. If I try to play from my head, although I can hum or whistle the tune perfectly, it just doesn't happen! Does the ability to play 'from the head' eventually come, or is it a gift? I've been playing the tenor now for three years, but I can't remember how long it took me to learn to whistle. Mind you, when improvising some pretty good tunes appear from nowhere, I wish I could remember them and write them down, I could be a composer!
Oh well, keep on keeping on..........
 
Here's how I get it. Have something play a song you know. While it is playing pick up your sax and try to pick out notes, then the key, then adding fill. There are 3 kinds of fill: Scalic, Chromatic, and Arpeggio. In scalic you just go up or down from one note to another for example in the key of F, if you started on a C, you could then play Bb A, g, F to get to an F that would have just been a jump from C to F (depending on the song and feel), in Chromatic, do the same except up or down by half steps. With arpeggio, place an arpeggio that is chord correct in a spot where you "feel" it. at least that's what I attempt to do.
 
Here's how I get it. Have something play a song you know. While it is playing pick up your sax and try to pick out notes, then the key, then adding fill. There are 3 kinds of fill: Scalic, Chromatic, and Arpeggio. In scalic you just go up or down from one note to another for example in the key of F, if you started on a C, you could then play Bb A, g, F to get to an F that would have just been a jump from C to F (depending on the song and feel), in Chromatic, do the same except up or down by half steps. With arpeggio, place an arpeggio that is chord correct in a spot where you "feel" it. at least that's what I attempt to do.

ok thanks, I'll experiment with your suggestions.
 
Here's how I get it. Have something play a song you know. While it is playing pick up your sax and try to pick out notes, then the key, then adding fill. There are 3 kinds of fill: Scalic, Chromatic, and Arpeggio. In scalic you just go up or down from one note to another for example in the key of F, if you started on a C, you could then play Bb A, g, F to get to an F that would have just been a jump from C to F (depending on the song and feel), in Chromatic, do the same except up or down by half steps. With arpeggio, place an arpeggio that is chord correct in a spot where you "feel" it. at least that's what I attempt to do.

I don't understand any of that, I'm afraid.
I try to find a little phrase from somewhere in the tune, and then build on that ....I sort-of just remember whether the next bit goes up or down and by how much! Fortunately I usually remember tunes very well.
Reading the dots is, for me, like learning Japanese .....I know just about enough to say "Two beers please" 🙂 But I struggle on ....band parts are a nightmare, as I have said elsewhere ...it's more like a japanese map...I am constantly 'lost' (and me a former navigator!!).
 
I'm encouraged by the number of people here who rely on the dots - I thought it was just me who couldn't play a tune without them.

I have been trying to to learn tunes without relying on the dots, but I have to play them nearly every day, otherwise I just forget them again. This annoys my wife immensely!!! (The continual playing of a tune, not the forgetting!!)
 
I'm encouraged by the number of people here who rely on the dots - I thought it was just me who couldn't play a tune without them.

I have been trying to to learn tunes without relying on the dots, but I have to play them nearly every day, otherwise I just forget them again. This annoys my wife immensely!!! (The continual playing of a tune, not the forgetting!!)

While I read, I do not remember (much). If I have to play it without dots, that's how it's got to be practised. I know what happens otherwise!
 
I'm encouraged by the number of people here who rely on the dots - I thought it was just me who couldn't play a tune without them.

I have been trying to to learn tunes without relying on the dots, but I have to play them nearly every day, otherwise I just forget them again. This annoys my wife immensely!!! (The continual playing of a tune, not the forgetting!!)

Hi Nick

I think your probably very much like myself in the learning stakes,I tend to go over and over it with the music in front of me and then try it without looking at the music and eventually you can do it, there may be bits that are a bit hit and miss but you just keep going over them till they're sorted as well

Now here comes the rub when you try it the next day do it from memory and when you come to the vague bits keep at them trying to do it from memory and playing about with the notes until you get them right I think this way you to tend to lock them into your automatic memory the way you lock fingering the right keys into automatic memory I'm afraid the the wife may get a bit ragged though...john🙂
 
Last edited by a moderator:

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,064
Messages
578,435
Members
8,130
Latest member
tommyliehe
Back
Top Bottom