Tech/maintenance Does the loose neck cork have to be replaced?

Messages
367
Location
Malaysia
Level
Beginner
After practicing today, I notice my neck cork is coming loose. It has not totally come off, just that little portion in the picture.

Do I need to replace the entire cork, or can I go with an easier/lazy solution like... say... stuffing some contact glue into the gap?

(Note that the gap is a bit exaggerated because I'm applying pressure to make it easier to notice)

20250417_154452.webp
 
Solution
Contact adhesive will likely not work. There'll be all kinds of mess in that gap and you'll only get once chance at glueing it.
What I do is pop a bit of sellotape over the end ring to protect it, then get some superglue gel (it's less messy) and pop a drop on the end of a small stick. Work it into the gap, then press the cork down firmly hand hold for a minute or so.
Remove the sellotape to clean up.
@PigSquealer

Valentino.🥳 That's the name. I kept thinking Rudolphe and going down the reindeer rabbit hole. So much for memory cues. 🙄

Yes it works great for me.

We've all scratched something while doing repairs. A little tape round the neck to mask and guard it from the abrasive works. I now use self amalgamating tape. After reading how difficult it is to delacquer a Yamaha I was surprised that the pvc insulating tape whipped it right off.

Didn't JBT recommend a dowel and a long strip for sanding.

I can't believe how long this thread is for changing the neck cork. With the Valentino I've changed it between numbers.
 
Vote:
Upvote 0
Third time's a charm!

Hardware store was surprisingly closed for some reason today... did not get my medium grit sandpaper. However, I did find a rectangular block of wood to wrap my 150 grit sandpaper around, this made sanding the cork so much easier.

Cleaned it up with some wet wipes and let it dry before applying cork grease.

View attachment 28588

Slowly and carefully inserted the mouthpiece while twisting anticlockwise. The mouthpiece went in very smoothly with the twisting motion, but at the end when I just wanted to adjust the rotation without pushing in or out, it did feel quite tight -- which is apparently normal, according to my local sax tech when I raised similar concerns about the tenor that I bought from him.

Anyway, I removed and reinserted the mouthpiece three more times just to make sure everything was alright, then left the mouthpiece on for an hour to get it compressed a bit. It's looking good! 😀

View attachment 28589

Only one issue to mar the experience, during one of the earlier attempts I got some scratches on the neck due to a bit of carelessness while sanding the cork. Doesn't appear to be anything more than superficial, so I hope it doesn't affect the lacquer or coating.
If it is a new(er) neck, I wrap a bit of painter's tape around the neck, just leaving the front portion free, That prevents getting contact cement from getting on the lacquer and also scratches on the neck.

Everybody has a different technique for sanding and it'll depend on the "type of sandpaper" used. Regular sandpaper works best as described by @Pete Thomas above, but over here, a lot of the stuff is no longer paper but has some reinforced backing, often with fabric and that type works great if I cut a strip (thinner than the width of the cork and form an Omega loop that I hold in one hand and then I just rotate the neck inside that loop. As long as you don't put pressure on it, it's super easy. But, it won't work with regular sand paper.
 
Vote:
Upvote 0
@PigSquealer

Valentino.🥳 That's the name. I kept thinking Rudolphe and going down the reindeer rabbit hole. So much for memory cues. 🙄

Yes it works great for me.

We've all scratched something while doing repairs. A little tape round the neck to mask and guard it from the abrasive works. I now use self amalgamating tape. After reading how difficult it is to delacquer a Yamaha I was surprised that the pvc insulating tape whipped it right off.

Didn't JBT recommend a dowel and a long strip for sanding.

I can't believe how long this thread is for changing the neck cork. With the Valentino I've changed it between numbers.
That's why I am using painter's masking tape (yellow for delicate surfaces).
And yes, JBT recommended a dowel , it works great but with the newer materials I prefer the Omega loop.

The main reasons why I ditched the Valentino were:
- on my TT tenor, I had to pull out the MPC I used to use until it had only about 1/2 inch contact area and with the Valentino it was wobbling uncontrollably.
- It's not very durable compared to a good quality cork (yes, there is a lot of crap that you get when you order online).

Valentino cork is great, though for "quiet" regulation of low Eb key mechanisms where you can afford a little bit of sponginess.
 
Vote:
Upvote 0
As an aside, Valentino is the company started by Pete Valentino, who was a well known tech and crazy person in Los Angeles, Las Vegas and Reno NV in the 1970s and ‘80s. He invented the Valentino pads (synthetic), often today used in clarinets and piccolos. He actually repadded my picc. in 1983 or so, and it still has them in it - and they still seal perfectly.

He also had a line of mouthpieces, and if you find one buy it - these are from the same mold as the famous M.C. Gregory pieces. I have an alto one, Pete gave it to me, but I changed it by adding a step baffle to it. A useful addition, when backing up pop singers.
 
Vote:
Upvote 0
Sanding sax neck corks is not that easy. The best way to sand a cork is to use a sax neck holder (expandable mandrel) and then use a some kind of motor with low rpm (I use an old BD drill machine with "two gears"). I remove the octave key as well when sanding.

They say ist's reasy to re-cork a sax neck. It's not a big operation, but not done quickly.

This is what I do when I re-cork a sax neck with tapered cork tube. It's almost the same as it is described in "Band Instrument Reapiring Manual" by Erick D. Brand (1939, 1942, 1945,1946).

1. Remove the octave key from the neck.
2. Fasten a cord (c 60 cm long) in a hook.
3. Place the tube cork in a warm place (50-70 degrees C).
4. Scrap or burn/warm the old cork off the neck. All old glue or shellac must be removed. Sand the cork area on as well.
5. Heat the end of the neck over a flame until the shellac melt.
6. Rub an even coat of shellac over the "cork-area". Cool off to the neck and shellac.
7. Try the tapered cork tube so it fit ok. If you need to make the tube wider use a round file.
8. Slip the cork over neck/shellac.
9. Wrap the cord tightly around the cork.
10. Wrap one or two layers of aluminium foil around the cord/cork. Don't cover the ends of the cork/cork.
11. Hold the end of the neck over the flame from an alcohol lamp so the flame goes up the bore. Not to much heat.
12. Move the flame/heat outside the "alu-foil" as well. You can also cover the cork/cord with a brass pipe to protect from too much heat.
13. When the shelac is melting and begin to ooze out at both ends of the cork remove the flame and remove the cord.
14. Turn the cork on the neck. If it's not turning the shellac is not all melted and need more heat.
15. Cool off before sanding.
16. Sand down the cork to "cylindrical shape", the cork should have the same O.D. all over the cork. Use a vernier sliding gauge.

I started to re-cork old junk saxes before I re-corked my better saxes. So practise is important.
 
Last edited:
Vote:
Upvote 0
Is there some functional advantage to shellac (easier to remove?) or is it just a case that it pre-dates contact cement?
I've never used shellac for neck cork so I don't have a basis for comparison but I know that my neck corks last for a long time. And it is never the glue that gives in the end, usually the cork just wears out after a few hundred mouthpiece On/Off procedures. And, I never leave the MPC on the neck, even if I take a 30 min break during practice, I take everything apart, and wipe, including reed because if I don't, my experience has been that I'll get to that point 5 min after starting again, only that I wasted those 5 min playing on crud.
 
Vote:
Upvote 0
Is there some functional advantage to shellac (easier to remove?) or is it just a case that it pre-dates contact cement?
I don't know. When I started to do some works on my own saxes I bought "Band Instrument Reapiring Manual" by Erick D. Brand. I follwed the book. Shellac has low melt point and it smells good as well. Of course, better for the environment as wll.
 
Vote:
Upvote 0
This might be true, if treehuggers are to be believed. 🧐
"Shellac is controversial not only because it systematically kills lac bugs that get caught in the harvesting process but also because it's usually mixed with ethyl alcohol, which yields a nasty byproduct.

 
Vote:
Upvote 0
"... ethyl alcohol, which yields a nasty byproduct.
You do realize that ethyl alcohol is just plain old booze? Vodka, by definition, is ethyl alcohol diluted with water.

Certainly too MUCH ethyl alcohol can yield a nasty byproduct, but it's contained within the consumer of said excess ethyl alcohol.

I really wish that people who write stuff about environmental this and environmental that were required to at least have passed basic high school chemistry and physics.
 
Vote:
Upvote 0
You do realize that ethyl alcohol is just plain old booze? Vodka, by definition, is ethyl alcohol diluted with water.

Certainly too MUCH ethyl alcohol can yield a nasty byproduct, but it's contained within the consumer of said excess ethyl alcohol.

I really wish that people who write stuff about environmental this and environmental that were required to at least have passed basic high school chemistry and physics.
Well I passed O and A level so I'll be quite happy to write about environmental the other.
 
Vote:
Upvote 0

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,061
Messages
578,382
Members
8,129
Latest member
Bartman
Back
Top Bottom