- Messages
- 810
- Location
- London
"Resonance" is an interesting term that I believe is often misunderstood. If I take the mouthpiece off my tenor, finger low Bb and put the end of the neck (crook) up to my ear like a stethoscope, I will hear the "resonance" of the body of air inside the tenor that is set into vibration by that same frequency in the background noise in the room from a fan or other sounding device. That frequency is not only captured but also amplified by the vibration of the air column inside the body of the saxophone. This is an example of what is called "sympathetic vibration" when the "resonant frequency" of an object or a column of air is set into vibration by the sound waves having the same, or close to the same frequency.
If one goes up to a set of chimes and strikes the top corner of one of the tubes with a rawhide hammer, one will hear the "resonance" of the note that tube is tuned to. In this case what is heard is the metal body of the tube vibrating, not an air column inside which may also be vibrating, but is far too soft to be heard over the ringing of the chime itself. Contrast this with "Boomwhackers" which are colored plastic tubes of various lengths tuned to notes of the scale. When these are struck, it is the air column inside that "resonates", not the plastic tube itself.
When the saxophone reed is set into vibration by forcing air through the tip opening of the mouthpiece, the reed instantly vibrates at the resonant frequency of the length of the air column produced by that fingering setting up a "regime of oscillation" that includes the fundamental and all of the overtones below the "cutoff frequency" which is in the neighborhood of F#3. Of course there are higher frequencies produced that are above the "cutoff frequency" but these do not take part in the "regime of oscillation". It is well known and that the shape and size of the interior of the mouthpiece can have a great effect upon the relative strength of various frequencies contained in the reed's vibration. To my knowledge there have been no major scientific studies on the effects of the wall vibrations of the mouthpiece itself or the effects of different materials.
The phenomenon of the reed's closing the aperture of the mouthpiece is called "beating". At levels of mf and above, the blowing pressure against the reed closes it until the pressure of returning soundwave reopens it. On a conical woodwind the sound wave travels to the first open tonehole, reverses its course and then returns to make one complete wave. It is interesting to note that on a saxophone the reed's opening and closing (beating) is not symetrical. It is closed approximately 1/3 of the time and open 2/3 of the time. This is one reason a saxophone plays louder than a clarinet which is closer to 50 / 50.
The question at hand is whether the vibrations of the beak and/or tip of the mouthpiece somehow effect the reed's vibration when it touches the tip during the closed part of its cycle---remembering that at that point, the reed is not moving.
Correct, but what point are you actually making?
I think the study by Ralph Morgan mentioned previously is scientific enough to show that the material and its shape and thickness are hugely involved in what a player perceives as the resonance of any particular mouthpiece. Just because it doesn't ring like a bell does not mean it isn't resonating. Your head resonates when you play, as does your vocal cavity, chest etc etc.
