Saxophones Do all saxophones go sharp the same amount when it's hot?

"Resonance" is an interesting term that I believe is often misunderstood. If I take the mouthpiece off my tenor, finger low Bb and put the end of the neck (crook) up to my ear like a stethoscope, I will hear the "resonance" of the body of air inside the tenor that is set into vibration by that same frequency in the background noise in the room from a fan or other sounding device. That frequency is not only captured but also amplified by the vibration of the air column inside the body of the saxophone. This is an example of what is called "sympathetic vibration" when the "resonant frequency" of an object or a column of air is set into vibration by the sound waves having the same, or close to the same frequency.

If one goes up to a set of chimes and strikes the top corner of one of the tubes with a rawhide hammer, one will hear the "resonance" of the note that tube is tuned to. In this case what is heard is the metal body of the tube vibrating, not an air column inside which may also be vibrating, but is far too soft to be heard over the ringing of the chime itself. Contrast this with "Boomwhackers" which are colored plastic tubes of various lengths tuned to notes of the scale. When these are struck, it is the air column inside that "resonates", not the plastic tube itself.

When the saxophone reed is set into vibration by forcing air through the tip opening of the mouthpiece, the reed instantly vibrates at the resonant frequency of the length of the air column produced by that fingering setting up a "regime of oscillation" that includes the fundamental and all of the overtones below the "cutoff frequency" which is in the neighborhood of F#3. Of course there are higher frequencies produced that are above the "cutoff frequency" but these do not take part in the "regime of oscillation". It is well known and that the shape and size of the interior of the mouthpiece can have a great effect upon the relative strength of various frequencies contained in the reed's vibration. To my knowledge there have been no major scientific studies on the effects of the wall vibrations of the mouthpiece itself or the effects of different materials.

The phenomenon of the reed's closing the aperture of the mouthpiece is called "beating". At levels of mf and above, the blowing pressure against the reed closes it until the pressure of returning soundwave reopens it. On a conical woodwind the sound wave travels to the first open tonehole, reverses its course and then returns to make one complete wave. It is interesting to note that on a saxophone the reed's opening and closing (beating) is not symetrical. It is closed approximately 1/3 of the time and open 2/3 of the time. This is one reason a saxophone plays louder than a clarinet which is closer to 50 / 50.

The question at hand is whether the vibrations of the beak and/or tip of the mouthpiece somehow effect the reed's vibration when it touches the tip during the closed part of its cycle---remembering that at that point, the reed is not moving.

Correct, but what point are you actually making?

I think the study by Ralph Morgan mentioned previously is scientific enough to show that the material and its shape and thickness are hugely involved in what a player perceives as the resonance of any particular mouthpiece. Just because it doesn't ring like a bell does not mean it isn't resonating. Your head resonates when you play, as does your vocal cavity, chest etc etc.
 
The mouthpiece itself is a "resonance chamber" whose frequency is determined by the interior volume and dimensions, or in other words its "geometry". It is known that this resonance of the air inside the mouthpiece has a great effect upon the loudness and timbre of the sound. It is also known that the walls of a mouthpiece vibrate, set into motion by the vibrations of the reed that is mechanically attached to it. Players feel and sense the vibrations of the mouthpiece as they travel through the top teeth, to the skull and eventually to the inner ear. This is part of what is called the "bio acoustic feedback" the player gets from the instrument while playing. It makes sense that a thinner beak vibrates more readily and sends more of its vibrations to the top teeth of the player. It also makes sense that a player might interpret this as being a "more resonant" mouthpiece.

My point is that there is no scientific evidence to date that the wall vibrations of a mouthpiece have any effect whatsoever on the soundwaves inside. When a mouthpiece maker scrapes material from the beak and/or side walls of a mouthpiece and it plays better, couldn't it be because of the change in shape and volume and not because the mouthpiece vibrates more?
 
Last edited:
My point is that there is no scientific evidence to date that the wall vibrations of a mouthpiece have any effect whatsoever on the soundwaves inside. When a mouthpiece maker scrapes material from the beak and/or side walls of a mouthpiece and it plays better, couldn't it be because of the change in shape and volume and not because the mouthpiece vibrates more?

I agree that a change in exterior shape of a mouthpiece can affect the amount a player has to open their mouth, and this does subtly affect the timbre. I once experimented by altering the beak of a modern Berg Larsen ebonite piece to match a Vandoren A35, and although the timber was only affected in a minor way (it was still a Berg!) it became very much more comfortable to play.

However, according to Ralph Morgan's research quoted here: "Ralph found that as the beak was thinned, the response and tone production SUFFERED progressively. At a point somewhere near half the original beak thickness, the clarinet ceased to play, emitting mostly buzzes of various pitch levels. However, when the appropriate thickness was reached by more thinning, the sound and response suddenly reappeared at a greatly enhanced level."
So, there is no change in interior shape or volume of the mouthpiece itself because in this instance (and in my discussion with Ed Pillinger) material was only removed from the outside (the beak) not the inside (baffle). I presume something else is going on - that the 'resonance' of the mouthpiece has been affected, which seems a reasonable assumption.
 
Interesting. In the Ralph Morgan article I believe he was referring to a clarinet mouthpiece. I have never seen a clarinet mouthpiece with any type of baffle. My assumption then was that what is called the "beak" has both a top and bottom side, and that the material removal was done on the inside. I may have misinterpreted the article since he does use the term "scoop". It would be great to have other mouthpiece makers weigh in on the discussion of how the wall thickness and vibrations of a mouthpiece affect how it plays.
 
I have never seen a clarinet mouthpiece with any type of baffle.

I have one..............

Its a "Roc". An English mouthpiece.

I dont know much about it, and I dont play clarinet, so I cant tell you how it sounds.

The area just behind the tip looks conventional, but then there is a big wedged baffle contraption, dropping off into the chamber.

Im fairly sure you would not want to play the Mozart Concerto on this.
This beast is made for volume, Im pretty sure.
 
Technically, all mouthpieces have a baffle, it's just that usually a classical clarinet mouthpiece has one that is flat. How else do you describe the area from the tip to the bore?
I believe you are correct. I have always considered a "raised baffle" when using that term. Theo Wanne uses the term "baffel" for the area just behind the tip, and the term "floor" for the section below the baffel that goes into the chamber.
 
I have one..............

Its a "Roc". An English mouthpiece.

I dont know much about it, and I dont play clarinet, so I cant tell you how it sounds.

The area just behind the tip looks conventional, but then there is a big wedged baffle contraption, dropping off into the chamber.

Im fairly sure you would not want to play the Mozart Concerto on this.
This beast is made for volume, Im pretty sure.

I believe Acker Bilk and Monty Sunshine used them at one time.

Stick it on Ebay with a high reserve. I've seen them go for silly money.
 
Lots of interesting and knowledgeable replies so far (some of which go over my head 🙂 ). I have a 1960's Tenor sax and I usually have no problems getting it in tune ... except today. It was consistently sharp and even balancing my (old) mouthpiece precariously on the end of the cork (and lifting the neck a couple of mm on the body) didn't completely solve the problem. The weather has been warm here too and now it's humid. I've also read that the shape of the throat and mouth and the tongue position affects 'playing sharp or flat' so maybe I have a tendency to play sharp anyway.

I wondered whether my cork had just dried out so I put on some cork grease. I found the discussion on mouthpieces interesting so I tried tuning the sax with my (onyx) PPT. To my amazement, I had no tuning problems using the PPT at my 'normal' cork position. The cork grease helped get my sax in tune with my 'old' mouthpiece too. But I still had to pull the old (bullet) mouthpiece a lot further out than the PPT.

I should add that I much prefer playing the PPT but because it's a slightly wider tip opening than my 'old' mouthpiece, I have to keep my 'embouchure' in good condition to play the PPT for hours. When I don't practice often enough or just get lazy, I fall back on my 'old' (smaller) mouthpiece that takes less work.

Mike


Here's a theory question, probably with not a lot of practical use.

Last week it was very hot. I was playing in a saxophone group and I had my mouthpiece pulled out a bit further than usual in order to play at concert 440. I was wondering if all sizes of saxophone go sharp by the same amount when it gets hotter. So if we had all left our mouthpieces in their "usual" positions, would we have played in tune as a group? (Assuming that we can ever play in tune as a group and that there are only saxophones.) Someone in the group said that in her experience, tenor saxes seem to be worse than the others when it gets hot, but I don't know why that should be.
 
Hi there everyone, sorry for joining this discussion so timely delayed. Just stumbled upon it on a research and was delighted to find that accumulated, kind knowledge on such an important matter that is discussed too rarely. Just to round this up with my findings: facing length will also play a crucial role in how a mpc reacts:
Long facings will tend to be more affected by embouchure (or jaw) pressure/inconsitency, shorter less. Which leads to some of the following observations:
*e.g. Rubber Links have shorter facings vs. Vandorens. Vandorens played with the same pressure will have a higher (too high) mpc pitch, therefor play often out of tune. They also have a concave table that supports the long facing.
*Rubber vs. Metal: Rubber or plastic is easier deformed by the forces applied by the players teeth on the mpc. The thinner the beak, the more deformation takes place, which might also affect the facing length. This might lead to the "more flexible" tone observation by Ralph Morgan. "More resonance" might also translate to: less stable in the facing length.
*Tenor mpc have longer bodies than altos: they are more affected by the leverage applied between neck and teeth. Also the weight of tenor is higher.
*Humidity affects the reeds softness and how it reacts to the ligature, which might also affect the facing length.
etc.
So in my opinion, there´s a whole bunch of other factors to consider (facing length, embouchure pressure, leverage neck ...), that makes this topic even more complicated, but not less important - many saxophonists have a hard time to play in tune. The more we know, the more we can improve.
 
Hi there everyone, sorry for joining this discussion so timely delayed. Just stumbled upon it on a research and was delighted to find that accumulated, kind knowledge on such an important matter that is discussed too rarely. Just to round this up with my findings: facing length will also play a crucial role in how a mpc reacts:
Long facings will tend to be more affected by embouchure (or jaw) pressure/inconsitency, shorter less. Which leads to some of the following observations:
*e.g. Rubber Links have shorter facings vs. Vandorens. Vandorens played with the same pressure will have a higher (too high) mpc pitch, therefor play often out of tune. They also have a concave table that supports the long facing.
*Rubber vs. Metal: Rubber or plastic is easier deformed by the forces applied by the players teeth on the mpc. The thinner the beak, the more deformation takes place, which might also affect the facing length. This might lead to the "more flexible" tone observation by Ralph Morgan. "More resonance" might also translate to: less stable in the facing length.
*Tenor mpc have longer bodies than altos: they are more affected by the leverage applied between neck and teeth. Also the weight of tenor is higher.
*Humidity affects the reeds softness and how it reacts to the ligature, which might also affect the facing length.
etc.
So in my opinion, there´s a whole bunch of other factors to consider (facing length, embouchure pressure, leverage neck ...), that makes this topic even more complicated, but not less important - many saxophonists have a hard time to play in tune. The more we know, the more we can improve.
In 2005 I counted 27 variables in the mouthpiece area which affected the frequency. Too much to make a general theory on the subject. I didn't think of deformation of the mouthpiece as a possibility while the whole instrument is made from bendy material.

In those 28 variables volume is often overlooked.
In one concert I had to play low C FFF. to get the pitch right I had to play low C#.
The difference between some long and short shank mouthpieces could be that the short mpc's are designed for lower volumes.
 
... in fff playing you will automatically loosen jaw/embouchure pressure, which lowers the concert pitch of the mpc. Vice Versa in ppp you will have to incease pressure to make the tone audible, which will raise the concert pitch. The effect is even amplified when playing on a mouthpiece with a long facing curve.
Initial topic "temperature": with the mouthpiece leaving the "construction point" on the cork will also ruin the intonation of the sax tones in relation to each other, so some tones will play more off than others, which is even harder to control on mpc with longer facings.
 
I increase my pressure with volume, but at the volume the trumpet players start to look worried the correction is futile.
When I notice a need to increase pressure at ppp I just improve the pads.
 
Whatever your observations are: increasing jaw/embouchure-pressure while (air) volume increases (ff) will lead to a squeak or a completely blocking reed. Decreasing pressure while (air) volume decreases (pp) will lead to interrupting the reeds vibration
 
Just to complete my message about facing length / jaw pressure and temperature.
A reaction chain I´ve seen quite often with mpc s with long facings (like e.g. Vandoren V16 rubber: T7, T8):
Long facing -> high sensitivity of the mpc to jaw pressure -> too much pressure applied by player -> too high calibration tone blown on mpc alone (on tenor: tone G will raise to G# or A) -> too far pulled out natural position of mpc on the cork at standard temperature (21 C) -> hot outside temperature (28 C) -> mpc pulled out to the end of the cork -> instrument in itself completely out of tune - unplayable.
Remedy:
Training to enable correct tuning tone blown on the mpc alone (tenor: G, Alto: A) -> finding correct (loose) jaw pressure and bite length (prbly longer on long facing mpc) due to long facing of mpc.
 
Very few established players, that manage to play open Vandorens w long facings (eg A45) ok in tune: Steve Coleman and Greg Osby come to mind (quite often you can hear them struggling, but still with great sound). On tenor: Ralph Bowen is the master on Vandoren, but wisely on less open mouthpieces (prbly T6). Also playing long facing on tenor: James Carter on a metal Lawton (8 or 9?) and you can hear him struggling with intonation - but still with a wild and great sound.
Sorry got carried away.
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,064
Messages
578,436
Members
8,130
Latest member
tommyliehe
Back
Top Bottom