Saxophone beginners Difference between tenor and alto

We all start loud, it's the only way to get the notes until your embouchure and breath control develop. When I started and got the same comment, I asked my son, a pretty good clarinet player, what he did to play quieter. He didn't really know, except to say less air. Now I know he was right, but getting the note to stay steady with less air is difficult at first.
 
It is true that the alto is not a beginner's instrument, but it is cheaper than the tenor which I suspect is why many of us, of whatever age, start out on it. In my mind that's better logic than starting on a soprano "because it's smaller".

I've had a hard time choosing between tenor and alto, but have chosen tenor. Enjoy your playing!
 
Hello to you all.
Can anybody tell me the difference between tenor and alto sax not stating the obvious. I play alot by ear on alto and I know it's the same notes on the tenor, but is the difference when it comes to playing the dots etc music or is it just the transposing what matters, thank you charlie
 
If you play the same fingering on tenor, the note that sounds will be 5 semitones lower than it would on the alto. If you're playing by ear it will take some time to adjust. It's perfectly possible to play written music for either on the other, however you will have problems with playing along with other instruments and backing tracks etc.
 
Last edited:
=1 for the previous responses.

I only play tenor in Bigbands where arrangements (except for solos) are written out for different instruments, including alto en tenor sax players. Even the 'notes' on the 'Play-along forums' on the cafe are transposed for Alto/Baritone or Tenor/Sop. I've only ever played 'live' once with a band where I had no idea of their setlist or the keys they would be playing in. And in which I needed to transpose by ear 'on- the fly'. That would apply to whatever sax I was playing. It takes a bit of practice but - knowing the tranformation intervals - for tenor and alto - you can figure it out by trial and error. A better approach IMHO is find out what the 'concert C' key is and transpose from there.

In my one and only 'live' performance, I had the advantage of previously playing guitar. So I could look at the guitarist's left hand (concert C) and see what chord he was starting out on - the root key. A quick transormation gave me a clue as to which (transposed) chord I - on tenor sax - should be starting out on. Some (playing by ear) awareness of 'typical' tune structures and chord changes is also useful in anticipating when chord changes are likely to occur and to which new chords. In my 'live' performance it was pretty much all '3-chord' songs with a 'relative minor' sometimes thrown in.

It helps enormously if you already know (have ever read or listened to) to the tunes. Even without (mentally) knowing whether in a certain bar the root chord jumps to the II, IV or V (possibly with a minor or 7th), if you know the tune, you're better prepared for a change. The better you - by listening -can tell the difference between a root - IV change and a root - V change, and minor and 7th chord changes, the better able you'll be to anticipate the right change.

Playing along with different backing tracks is good practice!

Many music books (with backing tracks) are available for either tenor or alto saxes. Online sheetmusic stores also enable you to download transposed sheet music for tunes for either Tenor or Alto. But sometimes, all you can get is music written in 'C' (or any other key). If you're playing with other people, a vocalist, pianist or guitarist might choose to pay in (concert) C, G, D, E or any other key. Being able to transpose 'on the fly' (and being able to play in any key) is important for professional musicians.

For the moment, my suggestion is just to get used to transposing from whatever the backing track key is to alto.
 
@Chas in your "Hello" post, 2017, you said you'd prefer Tenor but got an alto to start.

Time to scratch that itch!
Good luck with the new horn.
As for difference... It's the same; always blow air in the sharp end... Bit more air for tenor
 
Last edited:
Playing from notes is the same for both as long as you have a part that was written for the saxophone you are playing. But when you finger a "C" on a tenor you will hear a lower note (Bb) than when you finger a "C" for alto (Eb).
 
Alto need more pressure and less air. Tenor more air, less pressure.

Tenor saxophone share the same range as the human voice. Lots of tenor saxophonists are/were also good singers. I can't say for sure if the are any connection between playing tenor sax and singing?
 
What's obvious to you may not be to me ... and vice versa.
We really need to know exactly what you're asking.
Like Colin the bear says, tenor is bigger stating the obvious.
=1 for the previous responses.

I only play tenor in Bigbands where arrangements (except for solos) are written out for different instruments, including alto en tenor sax players. Even the 'notes' on the 'Play-along forums' on the cafe are transposed for Alto/Baritone or Tenor/Sop. I've only ever played 'live' once with a band where I had no idea of their setlist or the keys they would be playing in. And in which I needed to transpose by ear 'on- the fly'. That would apply to whatever sax I was playing. It takes a bit of practice but - knowing the tranformation intervals - for tenor and alto - you can figure it out by trial and error. A better approach IMHO is find out what the 'concert C' key is and transpose from there.

In my one and only 'live' performance, I had the advantage of previously playing guitar. So I could look at the guitarist's left hand (concert C) and see what chord he was starting out on - the root key. A quick transormation gave me a clue as to which (transposed) chord I - on tenor sax - should be starting out on. Some (playing by ear) awareness of 'typical' tune structures and chord changes is also useful in anticipating when chord changes are likely to occur and to which new chords. In my 'live' performance it was pretty much all '3-chord' songs with a 'relative minor' sometimes thrown in.

It helps enormously if you already know (have ever read or listened to) to the tunes. Even without (mentally) knowing whether in a certain bar the root chord jumps to the II, IV or V (possibly with a minor or 7th), if you know the tune, you're better prepared for a change. The better you - by listening -can tell the difference between a root - IV change and a root - V change, and minor and 7th chord changes, the better able you'll be to anticipate the right change.

Playing along with different backing tracks is good practice!

Many music books (with backing tracks) are available for either tenor or alto saxes. Online sheetmusic stores also enable you to download transposed sheet music for tunes for either Tenor or Alto. But sometimes, all you can get is music written in 'C' (or any other key). If you're playing with other people, a vocalist, pianist or guitarist might choose to pay in (concert) C, G, D, E or any other key. Being able to transpose 'on the fly' (and being able to play in any key) is important for professional musicians.

For the moment, my suggestion is just to get used to transposing from whatever the backing track key is to alto.
Hello Mike thanks for the info bud very informative so if I was playing in a band and the guitar piano tune to concert pitch C would I just transpose to that whether it be tenor Bflat or alto E flat?
 
The best key for the tenor saxophone is concert Ab (Bb plays in tenor. The tenor comes out great in concert Ab. Bb flat major pentatonic: Bb, C, D, F, G is useful. Old school Honking in Ab!!
 
To sound right, every one in the ensemble plays in the same key.

Saxophones transpose. Tenor, soprano and Bass from Bb. Alto, baritone, sopranino and contra bass from Eb.

Some people find transposing from Bb easier. I find transposing from Eb easier. It's a matter of practice and familiarity. I seem to have developed an Eb brain and ear.
If you buy wisely and change your mind, you can sell on without financial loss.
A used Yamaha is a safe investment in all departments.
 
Tenor saxophone share the same range as the human voice.
Tenor saxophone shares the same range as tenor voice. Less than half of humans have this range.
Immature males and females usually have a soprano or alto voice.

A contralto or counter tenor have to be seen. I can't tell listening.

Baritone and bass are usually male but sometimes unusual female. 😉
 
Tenor saxophone shares the same range as tenor voice. Less than half of humans have this range.
Immature males and females usually have a soprano or alto voice.

A contralto or counter tenor have to be seen. I can't tell listening.

Baritone and bass are usually male but sometimes unusual female. 😉
Baritone (between tenor and bass) is also common male voice. I'm "tenore lirico". Bright and girlish.
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,076
Messages
578,680
Members
8,134
Latest member
banjo
Back
Top Bottom