Playing the saxophone Dealing with a specific soft reed playing issue

Messages
367
Location
Malaysia
Level
Beginner
So on the topic of soft reeds, I'm reminded of one issue that I am experiencing.

On tenor, I play with Java Green 2.5 reeds. I rotate between several reeds each practice session. One particular reed out of the bunch, however, I've marked as noticeably softer than the rest and this specific reed is giving me an odd issue.

When trying to practice overtones, playing G1 tends to jump to the 2nd overtone (D3) when I'm aiming for the 1st overtone (G2). It takes a lot of control to wrestle it to play G2 as intended.
G# is also a little bit susceptible, but nowhere as sensitive as G.

So my natural tendency is to maybe just shun this reed, maybe throw it into the box of shamed reeds... maybe one day spend time trying to adjust it...... but on the other hand, I wonder if there is any benefit in trying to practice overtones with this reed. Like, would it really help me control better, or should I just chalk it up as a bad reed and just go on with my practice using all the other, working-normally, reeds?
 
IMO just dump it. Not worth the headache and the waste of time.
Or clip it….. but it ain’t the same.
At $4-6 apiece (and baritone is even more expensive) I don't "just dump it". I have to work for my money. Learn to adjust reeds.

Contrary to what so many people seem to believe nowadays, reed adjustment is not an exotic skill only a few specially gifted people can do. If you've got sufficient manual dexterity to play saxophone, you've got sufficient manual dexterity to adjust reeds. And you don't need $pecial $ystem$ or expen$ive tool$. A penknife, a straightedge, and a reed clipper (which you can do without in a pinch by using an emery board instead) are all you need.

Yes, when you clip a reed it becomes a bit different. Either learn to adapt to variations in reeds, or learn how to adjust the reed after clipping it.
 
At $4-6 apiece (and baritone is even more expensive) I don't "just dump it". I have to work for my money. Learn to adjust reeds.

Contrary to what so many people seem to believe nowadays, reed adjustment is not an exotic skill only a few specially gifted people can do. If you've got sufficient manual dexterity to play saxophone, you've got sufficient manual dexterity to adjust reeds. And you don't need $pecial $ystem$ or expen$ive tool$. A penknife, a straightedge, and a reed clipper (which you can do without in a pinch by using an emery board instead) are all you need.

Yes, when you clip a reed it becomes a bit different. Either learn to adapt to variations in reeds, or learn how to adjust the reed after clipping it.
I’m not privy to a trust fund either. I made my money myself. Here’s an idea: Write up a post about reed clipping, with images if possible. I’d love to recycle my old unplayables.
 
I doubt I could do it as well as any of the multiple authors who've covered it before over the last almost 200 years of single reed performance.
 
I have no idea what the problem might be with this reed. Personally, I play Java Red 2.5 on tenor. Since I found this online guide.

Just remember that different reeds out of the same box with the 'same strength' may well play differently. Not only in terms of 'general playability' but the ease with which you can play lower or higher notes.

Another important factor is 'reed placement and adjustment' which I recently posted here.
In summary - I've found a tenor sax reed brand and strength (Java Red 2.5) with which I can happily play on 2 different mpc's: a 'Big Band' mpc. that I can play for hours on and a PPT mpc with which I can cut through electric guitars and vocals. In both cases I use Steven Mauk's tips (see link) to 'optimise' my range between 'low' and 'high' notes.

I've never had occasion to (learn to) play overtones, So I can't comment on these.
 
What a joke!

"【Material】Sax Reed Cutter is Made of quality materials which is study and durable, reusable.
【 Trimming】This Saxophone Reed Trimmer Cutter can promise nice cut of reed without damaging any function of it.
【Size】The Reed Trimmer Cutter Repair Tool is 9x3.5cm.
【Lightweight】Lightweight and portable design, this sax reed cutter is easy to carry and easy cutting with a rotary knob.
【Perfect gift】Saxophone Repair Tool is a useful accessory for a professional musician or an amateur enthusiast."

go ahead and waste your money if you want to, but the key to a good reed clipper is a high carbon steel clipper blade/tongue, made with high precision to cut and not bend or mash the reed tip, properly hardened so it doesn't wear quickly (since these can't be sharpened), and accurately made to yield a proper shape of the reed tip. So, correct material selection, proper heat treatment, and accurate machining/stamping. All the things that are most absent in bottom-feeder Chinese knockoff mechanical products.

I would rather use an emery board, frankly.
 
What a joke!

"【Material】Sax Reed Cutter is Made of quality materials which is study and durable, reusable.
【 Trimming】This Saxophone Reed Trimmer Cutter can promise nice cut of reed without damaging any function of it.
【Size】The Reed Trimmer Cutter Repair Tool is 9x3.5cm.
【Lightweight】Lightweight and portable design, this sax reed cutter is easy to carry and easy cutting with a rotary knob.
【Perfect gift】Saxophone Repair Tool is a useful accessory for a professional musician or an amateur enthusiast."

go ahead and waste your money if you want to, but the key to a good reed clipper is a high carbon steel clipper blade/tongue, made with high precision to cut and not bend or mash the reed tip, properly hardened so it doesn't wear quickly (since these can't be sharpened), and accurately made to yield a proper shape of the reed tip. So, correct material selection, proper heat treatment, and accurate machining/stamping. All the things that are most absent in bottom-feeder Chinese knockoff mechanical products.

I would rather use an emery board, frankly.
The screw on my alto Cordier has stripped making fine adjustment a bit fiddly. Probably due to misuse, but maybe due to being bought second hand forty years ago. I was thinking I could use the Sino as a parts donor.
 
Even screws - the bottom feeder products typically have bad threads that'll gall and seize - made with dull taps and dies. And often in strange thread sizes.

You'd do better to have a local machinist turn one for you and put a threaded insert into the matching part.
 
Yes it would quite possibly help your breath control. Trying softer reeds than you are used to is great for working on your breath suppor
And also holding the muscles involved in using your embouchure / support (rather than biting, which will probably result in closing the reed on the mouthpiece in this case)
 
As a kid I was shown by an old dance band player how to trim a bit off a reed by holding it against an old penny, proper 1d penny that is, and burning a tiny bit off with a lighter, using the curved edge of the penny as a kind of mask or stencil if you see what i mean.
different dia. coins would work for different size reeds, alto, clarinet , whatever, the old big penny was for tenor as i recall 🙂
 
As a kid I was shown by an old dance band player how to trim a bit off a reed by holding it against an old penny, proper 1d penny that is, and burning a tiny bit off with a lighter, using the curved edge of the penny as a kind of mask or stencil if you see what i mean.
different dia. coins would work for different size reeds, alto, clarinet , whatever, the old big penny was for tenor as i recall 🙂
Yeah this is definitely old-school. I was shown this trick as a teenager in the early 60’s. Here in the USA, the coins of choice were a quarter for alto, half-dollar for tenor and bari. A nickel for clarinet.

I have to admit I burned an alto reed at a high paying gig once. It caused a discussion, with the older guys in the band congratulating me on using an old trick and the younger guys saying “Whaaaaat???”
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,061
Messages
578,378
Members
8,129
Latest member
Bartman
Back
Top Bottom