Introduction Deadly Saxophone

That's not exactly a normal clarinet embouchure. Most clarinetists rest their top teeth on the mouthpiece.

Yes, that's how I play the Clarinet. That's the embouchure form I was taught to use and it seems to work for me just fine on the clarinet. To be perfectly honest I didn't really think much of the embouchure on the sax. I just kind of starting playing in intuitively. I'm not even sure exactly how I was doing it now. I don't think I did it exactly the same as the clarinet because the mouthpiece angle is quite different. But whatever I was doing it seemed to work in terms of producing nice consistent tones. I was actually playing some melodies that sounded fair until they were played against backing tracks. Only then could I tell they were off key.

I did try changing the pitch via embouchure manipulation, but it just didn't seem possible to go as far as I needed to bring it back into tune. Like I say, I was totally unaware that the mouthpiece position could affect the pitch. I should have realized this because I know that on the clarinet you can 'fine tune' it if needed by not pressing the barrel in all the way against the body. And it doesn't take much to change the pitch. I also adjust my flute the same way, by how far I slide the mouthpiece section into the flute. I need to put it in until it bottoms out and then pull it back out about a half inch to get it in proper tune.

So I should have already been aware of the importance of the mouthpiece position. I just didn't think of it before taking it into the shop.

Well, I was having problems with the register too, but now I'm told that might also be related to poor mouthpiece positioning as well.

Oh well, at least when I get it back I'll know it was checked over.
 
Correct Nick, what I meant to say (probably getting into more trouble here) is the bottom lip should not be tucked under.
I think oboe-ists fold both lips in/ under.

Cheers
Jimu

The bottom lip should not be tucked under when playing a sax?

Oops! I'm pretty sure I was doing that. I was basically using the same embouchure that I use for the clarinet only a bit 'looser'.

I just did what 'felt right'. I seemed to be getting good solid notes and sounds. I didn't really notice a problem until I started playing against a backing track and realized that I wasn't in tune.

So I'm not supposed to be folding my lower lip over on a sax?

I wish I had the thing back to try some of these suggestions on. They haven't called me back yet. So I'm still saxless.
 
Clarinetists (almost) always tuck the bottom lip over the teeth. I've never seen one that didn't but I'm prepared to believe they exist.

Saxophonists probably mostly do similarly but not to such a great extent, ie. less lip tucked in. But there's quite a wide variety between them, ranging from tucked in a lot to completely protruding. There isn't such a thing as a correct embouchure, just one that works for you. But there are people prepared to argue that some work better than others.

As I said before, part of the problem with the octave key apparently not working may be too loose an embouchure.

<edit>(ever so slightly tongue-in-cheek) I suppose I should add that there is the usual divide between 'classical' players and 'popular' (or jazz) ones. 'Classical' players always believe there is a 'correct' way of doing something - usually going for the lip tucked in (because they all started on clarinet - a proper instrument, don't y'know). 'Popular' players go with what works best for them.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
If you dig through the UNSW music site, you'll eventually infd an article which talks a bit about this. About all I can remember is that the reed needs to be damped to control it's vibrations. More so on smaller instruments, and the lip in, reed down the chin style adopted by clarinettists provides the damping. The larger reeds on a saxneed less damping, and on a tenor, this comes from the air in the instrument, while on an alto some lip damping is still needed.

To me this explains why beginners are told to start with the lip in, as it provides the damping, that they'll otherwise need to provide with their lips/embouchure. But I stress, this is based on reading, not first hand knowledge - perhaps some of the teachers could comment.
 
You guys are making me anxious to try some of this stuff. I'm starting to feel bad that I took it into the shop. They'll probably charge me a hefty fee even if there was basically nothing wrong with it and just say that they made some "adjustments" to justify the fee.

It was probably all in the embouchure and mouthpiece position.

Darn it.
 
I play the clarinet with a double lip embouchure and I'm very comfortable with it. I've seen the way I play the sax described as the pouched mouth embouchure. The idea is to look in a mirror and observe the shape of your mouth as you say pouch mouth. Now hold that position and insert your thumb into your mouth, and give it a suck. Observe that shape and try to replicate it on the sax. Don't suck the sax though. This embouchure looks like a lip pout. Maybe I should have told you to wash your hands first.

I've been using an embouchure like this since long before I read any of the above. I like it, and I never get a sore mouth.

Jim.
 
Maybe I should have told you to wash your hands first.

Yep, now I'll probably get sick from sucking my dirty thumb.

Thanks for the description. I called the shop today and they haven't even looked at it yet. I almost feel like telling them to forget it and I'll just take another peek at it myself. I think they'll have something to say about it tomorrow. If they say it needs to be repaired I think I'll just pick it up and investigate it further myself first. I don't trust anybody. (ha ha)

It's brand new. There's really no reason why it shouldn't be working. The register key worked in the spring. It should still work in the fall. All it did was sit in the case all summer. It's probably just me.
 
You never know with saxophones. They can and do go out of whack when they are left unused, this happens with mine. When you get it back play it regularly. Johnny Hodges was one of the greatest alto players ever, and he played with a double lip embouchure.

Jim.
 
When you get it back play it regularly.

That I will do!

I ordered this sax in February of this year, for two reasons: I had the money. (ha ha) And I was ordering other instruments at the same time. I bought a set of drums, a bass guitar, two electric guitars and some amps. And some studio mixing equipment.

I tossed the saxed in as a "pipe dream" simply because I had enough money on the budget and I've always wanted to try one. So it was kind of a "Sweet Dream". See, there's a madness to my screen name.

I got it out in the spring just to try it out and make sure it wasn't damaged right out of the box. It seemed to play just fine, even though I had never played a sax before. Evidently my experience on the clarinet was enough to get me started. Of course, I didn't play much, only a few very simple tunes, and I didn't even check it for concert pitch or against a backing track. It seemed to play fine including changing registers. So once I was satisfied it was working properly I cleaned it out, put it back in the case and put it aside with the intent of getting out this fall.

Well, it's fall.

So I'm actually right on schedule with my "Pipe Dream". This was the original plan.
 
Status Update: For those who might be interested.

I got my toy saxophone back from the shop today. He found nothing wrong with the horn other than the fact that it's just an inferior instrument. 🙂))

I already knew that much.

He was able to get a Bb on it with no problem and he marked the mouthpiece position that he used to achieve that. It was indeed about an inch further onto the neck than I had been doing. In fact, as soon as I got home I tried it in that position I too got a perfect Bb.

so that was indeed the Bb problem all along.

As far as the register change key is concerned, he said that it's "working" and he can't see anything physically wrong with the valves that open and close with this lever. However, he too noticed that it's not very responsive and it take a lot of embouchure technique to change the octave as well. So he suggests that it's just not a very responsive horn is all.

He confessed to not being a saxophone specialist and suggested that someone with more experience at repairing and working with saxophones might potentially be able to do something to improve this, but then again maybe not.

From my point of view this is good information. At least it tells me that it's not me. It's the horn, and I'll just have to deal with it, or get a better horn.

I've tried the register change myself, and using the information he's given me I am able to change octaves using just embouchure (along with the register key). But the register key itself just doesn't seem to to much.

In fact, what I've just now discovered is that for some notes I can blow a high-octave, or low-octave at will whilst keeping the register key pressed down. I can't blow a high-octave without pressing the register key though.

So in theory I could just clamp the register key down permanently and just change octaves like a Trumpet player. :mrcool

Well, anyway, I got the thing back so now it's time to get down to business with some lesson plans. It's not a great sax by far. But it might be playable enough to get by learning some slow ballads. That's good enough for me for right now.
 
Thats good news about the sax, I hope he didn't charge you too much for the information though! It'll also give you the chance to have a bit of a play and to see whether the sax is for you or not. If it is then you could resell that one and get something a little nicer!
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,072
Messages
578,562
Members
8,133
Latest member
walthang
Back
Top Bottom