Jazz Dave Pollack's #onechordchallenge

mrblackbat

Opinionated grumpy northerner
Messages
1,301
Location
United Kingdom
So Dave Pollack posted a video recently of him improvising over a Cm7 chord for an hour:
View: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TVdxkzGoPUM&t=0s


I guess the point is to exhaust yourself of ideas. Whilst there's definite wobbles in there, generally this is pretty creative still. And he threw the gauntlet down to see how other folk do; so I did a whole ten mintues, which sounds pretty terrible on the whole! 😀

View: https://youtu.be/yQvO38JYcdw


Worthwhile? Who knows.
 
It;s all about isolating many parameters and using your creativity to exercise your mind. This is the only way I could ever approach jazz. The simple and slow path that leads to a magical moment that complex things happen on their own when you combine stuff you practiced isolated.

It's a "To see a World in a Grain of Sand" approach for me. I wouldn't do it for one hour though. But I remember spending an enormous amount of time in playing "isolated" exercises .....r hours, days & months ....... and I still do ... only to see my self feeling more able to play in complex situations .....
 
I’ve got a recording somewhere of me improvising over a Cm7 chord for about 10 minutes back in about 1990. When I get home (on hol at mo) I might dig it out.
Did you manage to find it, would love to listen!

Obviously with this kind of stuff the leaning is usually towards modal jazz, but then I also think of Kenny Garrett's solos on Miles' Human Nature. So many live recordings available and towards the later shows Miles really let Kenny keep cutting loose, I think a few start pushing then ten minute mark. Obviously there's a point where the harmony does start to move, but a huge swathe just on that one chord.
 
Well, this is it - all 16 minutes of it. Not remotely like Dave Pollack's effort. Not remotely 'jazzy' either.

A friend gave me a cassette of a drone type backing that he'd produced so I transferred it to my trusty Yamaha 4 track and noodled all over it on soprano (Yanagisawa S6). Well done if you make it to the end.

 
I don't see any point to Dave Pollack's video other than as clickbait to get views.

It would be much more productive to play over a set of changes set on repeat [but I'd never do it for an hour]. Create a line. Try starting at different times. Use leading tones. Try different rhythms. There is so much more that could be accomplished in an hour.
 
I don't see any point to Dave Pollack's video other than as clickbait to get views.

It would be much more productive to play over a set of changes set on repeat [but I'd never do it for an hour]. Create a line. Try starting at different times. Use leading tones. Try different rhythms. There is so much more that could be accomplished in an hour.
I presume you’re not a fan of Coltrane’s modal explorations. I find ‘playing over the changes’ to be really tedious. "Productivity" seems an odd concept when referring to music. Whatever floats your boat of course.
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,064
Messages
578,438
Members
8,130
Latest member
tommyliehe
Back
Top Bottom