Miscellaneous Covid-related questions for members who play in orchestras/bands ...

This morning's news on the BBC is that social gatherings of more than six people will be illegal in England from Monday. The law change will ban larger groups meeting anywhere socially indoors or outdoors, although it seems there will be some exemptions.

Further details are due to be given in a Downing Street news conference this afternoon, but it is not looking good for music groups hoping to restart rehearsals.

Rhys
 
The key question will be whether a band rehearsal will count as a social group. My impression is that it currently doesn't as long as there is no tea break. It would make sense to ban amateur music groups right now. But the rules seem to be getting less and less clear.
 
Sigh.... I last played in the first week of March. It has been incomprehensible why amateur music-making has been banned for so long when other inherently more 'dangerous' activities like meeting in pubs have been permitted as has organised sports.

Several of my groups were just thinking of resuming later this month or in October... and now that's gone.

My view is that in reality we can forget about any amateur music making in 2020. Concerts are certainly not going to happen until next year. I think many groups will fold because of this. Whilst they don't in general have to worry about paying out fixed overheads, I think some people will be reluctant to return and that will probably result in some groups losing viability. I think that's what will happen to my Thursday orchestra, and I am worried about my Monday one as it meets at a boarding school and I wouldn't be surprised if 'outsiders' won't be allowed on site.

For those of us that live alone our musical activities are more than 'just hobbies' they're a crucial part of our lives.
 
This morning's news on the BBC is that social gatherings of more than six people will be illegal in England from Monday. The law change will ban larger groups meeting anywhere socially indoors or outdoors, although it seems there will be some exemptions.

Further details are due to be given in a Downing Street news conference this afternoon, but it is not looking good for music groups hoping to restart rehearsals.

Rhys
Strange.
But of course I have no idea how bad the situation in England is at the moment.
Over here in Flanders, cultural happening (concerts, theater perfomances, .....) are starting up again. There will be significantly less spectators attending, and strict rules will apply.
There were some concerts during the summer as well (max 200 people could attend). We went to 2 of those concerts at the venue where we usualy go for a summer festival (Dranouter). In the picture below you can see how far the tables were from one-another. It was in a tent and the sides were completely open to have excellent ventilation.
20200717_213022.webp
 
I am waiting for further guidance.
I fail to see how a covid secure band rehearsal of 20-30 musicians, complete with a risk assessment and mitigation measures is less safe than a soccer match.

I'd say the objective of today's announcement is to stop people crowding together at pubs and in back gardens, not to stop hobbies from occuring in a safe manner.

Pubs have felt somewhat ineffective in stopping people crowding in, until now.

So, we wait....
 
It’s a mystery to me why it’s safe for 50 people to be in a pub or restaurant as long as they don’t know each other, but not safe if they do, but that’s the new rule.

I think this means the end of band and orchestra rehearsals this year, unless there is a let-out in the small print.

But the rule of 6 replaces the two-household rule, so it looks as if quartets, and even sextets, are now permitted, even if the players all come from different households.

And of course, these rules only apply to England.
 
Last edited:
As a complete outsider but fairly well versed in English culture (the wife's from Kent and we visit a lot), it would seem to me that the government feels nervous about trying to restrict those activities that are most important to it's citizens. They rightfully fear repercussions if the majority can't have their outlets of the pub and footy. If you're in a small demographic group or one that's not likely to make a fuss, then the restrictions apply.

You may be saying why can't we meet up if others can, when what one should be asking is why the government doesn't have the balls to do what's right and apply the restrictions equally. You either are protecting your people by using distancing rules or you're not.
 
In my alter music ego I play in a successful garage punk rock band. We had to cancel local and international gigs. We kept on rehearsing and creating new material.... BUT rock n roll can’t be performed in a sterile setting. If the audience can’t feel free you better Not gig. Our gigs are loud.... people dance shout and drink a lot. You get the idea ....

covid has demolished all that. Our typical venues are collapsing financially. Clubs for gigs of 500 to 1000+ people can’t seem to keep their business plans....

we don’t think it’s possible to gig before 2022 ..?
it’s like a massive slap for the band.

we ll keep on playing though because it was never our profession.. just a hobby .... a nice way to see each other and play the music of our youth...

microphone caps... masks .... sanitizers and everything.... we all have health issues.... it just won’t worth it to have someone get sick :{

the sax is still my way out of this. I go outdoors .... study ... playing my changes ... my long tones ... trying to improve my technique .....just for fun... trying to reset my thoughts......

I hope all the best for all professional musicians. COVID has been like a curse 🙁

lucky are the ones that can gig outdoors or within Places that follow the new standards.

be careful everybody. Cheers.
 
It’s a mystery to me why it’s safe for 50 people to be in a pub or restaurant as long as they don’t know each other, but not safe if they do, but that’s the new rule.

I think this means the end of band and orchestra rehearsals this year, unless there is a let-out in the small print.

But the rule of 6 replaces the two-household rule, so it looks as if quartets, and even sextets, are now permitted, even if the players all come from different households.

And of course, these rules only apply to England.

I understand that rehearsalS in Covid secure situations is still fine.
 
I understand that rehearsalS in Covid secure situations is still fine.

It would be great if they are, but my interpretation of the new rules is that gatherings of more that 6 people are only allowed for work, education, weddings, funerals and sport. There is supposed to be a detailed version of the rules coming out before Monday, but I can't find it.
 
My husband tells me there was a discussion on Radio 4 this morning. It was about orchestras - the gist being an organised activity should not be affected about by the Rule of 6? Also it was said that brass instruments create sound by vibration not by being blown. The flutes being the ones to distance. Did any one else hear it?

Quote above from a local orchestra member

Jx
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,072
Messages
578,562
Members
8,133
Latest member
walthang
Back
Top Bottom