Theory & Impro Chord transposition

For example just as most adults won't get very far learning a language if they don't know the basics of sentence structure (noun, adjectives verbs etc),
An adult person can learn new things. But we have to use other methods to learn adult person to be become improvisers. Adult teachers are used to teach younger persons. Many adult/old persons often ask "Why should I learn this?"
 
Because when the vast majority advise it to be extremely useful, why would you not? Easy ride? Can’t be bothered?
I taught adult persons as well. I had to use other methods to person that was older than me. They had done and knew lots of things that. I learned a lot from them. IMO lots music education is living in the past.
 
Last edited:
Plenty of major 7ths in the pop/rock/folk of the 70s, the sort of harmonic sophistication that made that music so great. But that's not the kind of "rock" @thomsax is talking about.
Yes, that's is correct. "Rock & Roll" is one thing and "Rock" is another thing. Rock like "Chicago" and "Blood Sweat and Tears" is rock with jazz influences.
 
Many adult/old persons often ask "Why should I learn this
Actually I think this is the wrong way round.
The music teacher I went to over 40 years ago and I'm still friends with, used to say it was the younger students who didn't want to learn and they would say "I only want to play for fun", many of the older students knew what was involved to get where they wanted to be, and were prepared to put the time to get there.
 
Last edited:
I taught adult persons as well. I had to use other methods to person that was older than me. They had done and knew lots of things that. I learned a lot from them. IMO lots music education is living in the past.
But the theory remains the same. Eddie has consistently asked questions whereby the answer is difficult to give without basic knowledge and terminology. There have been many pages on threads that could have been condensed by 90% if just very basic theory was known.
These basics could be read about in a few hours and then re-read several times in order to digest. It’s not a book-worth, it’s maybe the first 20-30 pages of a small book with small pages.
“Maximum gain, minimum effort” can’t be applied to everything.
Essentially, you’re bemoaning a very “dry” style of teaching, and yes, that is out of date. But at some point, some learning does require being studious.
 
Actually I think this is the wrong way round.
The music teacher I went to over 40 years ago and is I'm still friends with, used to say it was the younger students who didn't want to learn and they would say "I only want to play for fun", many of the older students knew what was involved to get where they wanted to be, and were prepared to put the time to get there.
That was always my experience of teaching adults. With the exception of one, they were v quick to learn, and understood reasons for learning this and that, to achieve something else further on down the line.
Coming back to the exception (one of the worst player/students I ever had), his profession was brain surgeon.
 
But the theory remains the same. Eddie has consistently asked questions whereby the answer is difficult to give without basic knowledge and terminology. There have been many pages on threads that could have been condensed by 90% if just very basic theory was known.
These basics could be read about in a few hours and then re-read several times in order to digest. It’s not a book-worth, it’s maybe the first 20-30 pages of a small book with small pages.
“Maximum gain, minimum effort” can’t be applied to everything.
Essentially, you’re bemoaning a very “dry” style of teaching, and yes, that is out of date. But at some point, some learning does require being studious.
What about a mechanic who just likes to get in and rummage around. “Ok Fred, the cylinders are scored, it needs new piston rings and there’s a problem with the camshaft and timing chain”….
 
I taught adult persons as well. I had to use other methods to person that was older than me. They had done and knew lots of things that. I learned a lot from them. IMO lots music education is living in the past.
Your approach will potentially need to be modified for everyone.
 
You would think the brain surgeon would be better than most at realising that the right learning was key to get to where he wanted to be musically.
Yep. But he was truly awful and couldn’t hear mistakes. Obviously skilled hands and eyes, but no ears.
 
Many adult/old persons often ask "Why should I learn this?"
The problem with this need for validation or proof is that until a certain technique or whatever is worked on, the results won’t happen. At some point you need to put your trust in someone or a group of people/printed materials in order to give you forward momentum and progress. It’s a pointless dream otherwise.
 
Actually I think this is the wrong way round.
The music teacher I went to over 40 years ago and I'm still friends with, used to say it was the younger students who didn't want to learn and they would say "I only want to play for fun", many of the older students knew what was involved to get where they wanted to be, and were prepared to put the time to get there.
Actually I got exactly that feedback (compliment) today from my flute (Nay) teacher this morning! I'm there (and, indeed, here) because I want to understand the whole game - not just pass an exam or toot out a tune or two - and put in the work over and beyond.
Indeed, due to my (independent) exploration of rhythmic modes, he decided to incorporate more clear drumming into his backing tracks / teaching material. Win Win.
But the inverse is also true. I'm quite prepared to put work into something that turns out to be useless or too advanced... It's just the cost of curiosity... not everyone is! We're all individuals
 
Last edited:
Playing devil's advocate here, as I get older, I have no problem grasping new concepts. The issue is remembering them. It takes a lot more time and effort to remember than when I was younger. I think this is what's going on with the OP. No matter how many times we present the information, it just doesn't stick.

Realistically, the OP is likely never going to be able to improvise based on reading chord changes. The theory foundation simply isn't there and likely won't ever be. So learning to read chord changes is a dead end in this case. The goal should be simple improv based solely on embellishing the melody by ear.
 
But the theory remains the same. Eddie has consistently asked questions whereby the answer is difficult to give without basic knowledge and terminology. There have been many pages on threads that could have been condensed by 90% if just very basic theory was known.
These basics could be read about in a few hours and then re-read several times in order to digest. It’s not a book-worth, it’s maybe the first 20-30 pages of a small book with small pages.
“Maximum gain, minimum effort” can’t be applied to everything.
Essentially, you’re bemoaning a very “dry” style of teaching, and yes, that is out of date. But at some point, some learning does require being studious.
I love Ed's threads. He asked questions because he had something to solve. But I'm afraid we didn't managed. A teacher must be able to think out of the box as well. When I had students that had problems with reading and writing I didn't use foreign names/words even if it would be easier for me. To teach this way is best to do side by side. We spent much time together. And it was not "babysitting'".

“Maximum gain, minimum effort”. As a more or less self-taught sax player I had to work hard. And I liked to work hard for minimum progress. Boring and hard work became my best friend.
 
I love Ed's threads. He asked questions because he had something to solve. But I'm afraid we didn't managed. A teacher must be able to think out of the box as well. When I had students that had problems with reading and writing I didn't use foreign names/words even if it would be easier for me. To teach this way is best to do side by side. We spent much time together. And it was not "babysitting'".

“Maximum gain, minimum effort”. As a more or less self-taught sax player I had to work hard. And I liked to work hard for minimum progress. Boring and hard work became my best friend.
Yeah, I’m pretty old school. At some point I expect the student to take some responsibility for their own learning and not just expect a teacher to make magic happen.
 
I love Ed's threads. He asked questions because he had something to solve. But I'm afraid we didn't managed. A teacher must be able to think out of the box as well. When I had students that had problems with reading and writing I didn't use foreign names/words even if it would be easier for me. To teach this way is best to do side by side. We spent much time together. And it was not "babysitting'".
As I see Ed’s situation, he identifies challenges and looks for an answer. No issue with that. But consider the scenario if he worked with a teacher that was adept at identifying the root causes behind Ed’s challenges, and was able to construct a path forward that Ed could commit to and benefit from. Ed cannot fix what he doesn’t know, and we cannot identify obstacles that we cannot witness.

Kudos to Ed for sustaining the effort, however frustrating it must be.
 
Eddie seems to be in the same place as many, many others. They don’t want to spend the time learning the basics because it uses up the time they have to practice things they see as being more important. The fact that learning the basics actually frees you and speeds up everything else doesn’t register so they spend days, weeks, years rerunning the same simple issues.
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,063
Messages
578,427
Members
8,129
Latest member
Bartman
Back
Top Bottom