Tech/maintenance Can these mouthpieces be refaced?

I have to wonder, who the hell would chop the ends of a bunch of Otto Link mouthpieces and why? I don't think they're factory rejects because they look old and used.
Interesting question but I found a few of those in Ron's bonepile. I could never make sense of those but it appears more common than not. And they were not only links but all sorts of metal pieces. But why?
 
There is a technique of tip opening (and maybe closing ?) brass mouthpieces by carefully bashing the tip area with a hammer to bend the last inch or so upwards from the plane of the table.

Could these be Link pieces where the tip opener has been over-enthusiastic ?

Or alternatively, the Selmer FF mouthpieces were made in two parts with the tip area soldered onto the main part. Could these Links have been an experiment to make a new design but which were never completed ?

Rhys
 
There is a technique of tip opening (and maybe closing ?) brass mouthpieces by carefully bashing the tip area with a hammer to bend the last inch or so upwards from the plane of the table.

Could these be Link pieces where the tip opener has been over-enthusiastic ?

Or alternatively, the Selmer FF mouthpieces were made in two parts with the tip area soldered onto the main part. Could these Links have been an experiment to make a new design but which were never completed ?

Rhys
I don't think so, I just looked at one that I still have and it is plain and simply cut off with a sander or grinding wheel all the way into the bite plate. Nothing pretty about it and about at least 5 mm missing at the tip.
 
Whatever their past, quite a few of the tables seen to have been damaged or excessively ground leading to oddly shaped ragged windows

I've seen some pretty rough looking brand new Otto Links where the metal had tarnished underneath the coating.

Not that I'm a fan of guns -perhaps these could be melted down and turned in to ammunition: We had vintage saxophones made of 'cartridge bass' now you can have cartridges made of 'saxophone brass'
 
Whatever their past, quite a few of the tables seen to have been damaged or excessively ground leading to oddly shaped ragged windows

I've seen some pretty rough looking brand new Otto Links where the metal had tarnished underneath the coating.

Not that I'm a fan of guns -perhaps these could be melted down and turned in to ammunition: We had vintage saxophones made of 'cartridge bass' now you can have cartridges made of 'saxophone brass'
I thought that myth has been debunked? It was originally attributed to Selmer and the Selmer family vehemently denied any such stories.

But then, I remember vividly the "Lumpensammler" from my childhood, driving around in their horse buggies and collecting scrap metal, paper, clothing etc., so even if there was no dedicated cartridge brass sale, it is hard to see how one or the other did not sneak into the supply chain.
 
I thought that myth has been debunked? It was originally attributed to Selmer and the Selmer family vehemently denied any such stories.

But then, I remember vividly the "Lumpensammler" from my childhood, driving around in their horse buggies and collecting scrap metal, paper, clothing etc., so even if there was no dedicated cartridge brass sale, it is hard to see how one or the other did not sneak into the supply chain.


I wasn't being particularly serious. I'm well aware that the Selmer myth is probably a load of rubbish
 
I have to wonder, who the hell would chop the ends of a bunch of Otto Link mouthpieces and why? I don't think they're factory rejects because they look old and used.
The previous sales of other rough but intact mouthpieces by the seller claimed they were from the Stan Robinson estate but that means nothing to me. Maybe someone knows something that could shed some light on it.
 
The previous sales of other rough but intact mouthpieces by the seller claimed they were from the Stan Robinson estate but that means nothing to me. Maybe someone knows something that could shed some light on it.
Maybe this guy?

One thing’s for sure, he had a really bad temper or a really vindictive ex who still had the keys to the house and a Sawzall.
 
The previous sales of other rough but intact mouthpieces by the seller claimed they were from the Stan Robinson estate but that means nothing to me.

Maybe this guy?

I met Stan a couple of times, he was one of those very technically very proficient players that (I thought) didn't have the inventiveness or imagination that others from time had, e.g. Don Rendell, Ronnie Scott...
 
Last edited:
I thought that myth has been debunked? It was originally attributed to Selmer and the Selmer family vehemently denied any such stories.

But then, I remember vividly the "Lumpensammler" from my childhood, driving around in their horse buggies and collecting scrap metal, paper, clothing etc., so even if there was no dedicated cartridge brass sale, it is hard to see how one or the other did not sneak into the supply chain.
The "Selmer myth" came about because people don't understand about metals.

C26000 is a brass alloy that's highly formable with reasonable strength. It's used for most saxophone bodies (someone not too long ago did a materials analysis of several horns and came up with the formed parts of C26000 and the machined parts of C36000, no surprise there).

Before the Unified Numbering System for copper alloys came into effect, alloys were called by "common names". Because C26000 is highly formable, it's been used for generations for firearms shells, thus its common name is "cartridge brass". Saying something's made out of cartridge brass means that it's made of C26000 alloy, NOT that it's actually made from old cartridges.

I have read all kinds of lengthy BS about the cartridges and how they would have affected tonal qualities of the Mark 6 (which wasn't even introduced till 9 years after the end of WW2) just as if Selmer naturally had a freaking foundry and rolling mill right there in the factory! Nope, they've bought their brass sheet from a local metals distributor, all along, just like everyone else who uses moderate quantities of brass sheet to make stuff.
 
Nope, they've bought their brass sheet from a local metals distributor, all along, just like everyone else who uses moderate quantities of brass sheet to make stuff.
Unlike Adolphe Sax & cie who really do make them from cartridges @Karel Belgium

 
I met Stan a couple of times, he was one of those very technically very proficient players that (I thought) didn't have the inventiveness or imagination that others from time had, e.g. Don Rendell, Ronnie Scott...
Did he have a deep hatred of Link mouthpieces, no concept of money, and access to power tools?
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,072
Messages
578,566
Members
8,133
Latest member
walthang
Back
Top Bottom