or there's something about the facing curve that's throwing you.
It's actually quite logical to think that a facing curve could cause reed pickiness. e.g. that the length of the facing curve dictates the length of the reed that is actually vibrating - hence the position of the heart of the reed relative to the tip must be optimal for the length of the curve.
However I'm sure somebody, a reed company or mouthpiece manufacturer, would have published something either properly scientific or (more likely) pseudo scientific.
But there is no formula for the ideal facing curve. I think mouthpiece experts know certain parameters, and have an innate knowledge based more on experience than having a load of data written down.
@Phil can surely correct me on that but my discussions with the good Dr Pillinger have concluded that once you get beyond the obvious technical considerations (of the rails being symmetrical etc) it is very much an "art" that is learned over time by doing it.
I have a huge respect for people like Phil and Ed who have learned this art. But another thing to consider is what what if this ace mouthpiece refacer uses only one specific type of reed, are they optimising the mouthpiece so it really does only work best on that reed, or is there such a thing as a mouthpiece that is great on any reed.
I remember Ron Coelho telling me I should use Rico Select on his mouthpieces. And when I tried a Jody Jazz and was struggling to get a
sound tone I liked, Jody told me my reed was too soft. Huh.