According Yamaha literature, the "budget" tenor 5C has a 1.80 mm (0.070 in.) opening whereas the 4C has a 1.70 mm (0.067 in.) opening. Both have the same facing length of 24.0 mm (0.944 in.) .Nothing wrong with old threads, they can be better than new ones. But maybe worth discussing the switch from 5C to 4C in the context?
I have neither, but recently for my tenor sax, purchased a Bari ESKTSP Esprit Tenor Saxophone Mouthpiece Kit with ESMTSP mouthpiece of tip opening 0.073 in. (1.85 mm), facing length not stated. It is probably closer to the Yamaha 5C. Appears thus far from playing to work for concert community band work.
Have to agree with @MikeMorrell , for the past 59 years, have found that no matter the box and make, there will be a couple reeds that require adjusting, some that just simply don't play. Even the alleged better purple box Vandorens of the 1970's, clarinet, alto and tenor sax reeds I had would have a couple that way.
Now I buy the standard orange box of 25 (10 if on sale) Rico reeds. There'll be a few that just don't play or play poorly even with adjustments. IMO it is just the nature of the game.
In a push if I have a reed on the soft side, will push it up a little (so more tip exposed) will play. (Later I'll trim with the clipper.)
Plus on mouthpieces, seems I always have a couple that I bought but just don't like in my case. I gather other musicians more or less have similar. A while back, I accidently dropped my hard rubber clarinet mouthpiece on a job, the tip shattered. I took my spare, quickly found a reed to match and finished the concert.
It is always good to have a backup mouthpiece.
