- Messages
- 3,431
- Location
- West Midlands
I am surprised that you aren't considering an Ed Pillinger mouthpiece?Thanks..i noticed that yesterday. Think ill contact @Phil at check out the eclipse
I am surprised that you aren't considering an Ed Pillinger mouthpiece?Thanks..i noticed that yesterday. Think ill contact @Phil at check out the eclipse
Only because ive played a few of Marks pieces..ive noticed mouthpieces rarely sound the same listened to online compred to in the flesh..It is absolutely amusing to compare the descriptions of mouthpieces on their respective websites.
tenor — Phil-Tone Custom Woodwinds
phil-tone.com
[URL un
Only because ive played a few of Marks pieces..ive noticed mouthpieces rarely sound the same listened to online compred to in the flesh..
Ive played the gen 2 classic it is dark and focused, thr gen 1 robusto hr snd metal, tbf I was not ss taken as i thought I would be expected to love it. Ive also played the Showtime which I enjoyed as much as the clsssic. They were all 7* tho i prefer a 6* 7 at a push..Trouble is getting the tone, projection depth of the website recording is hard..I think more tip openings are available stateside. I was hoping someone had played the eclipse and 10mfan who could say for e.g. its similar to the robusto tone but more projection or its as deep as the classic but more spread etc..OK, so which have you played and how do they compare to 10mfan.com descriptions?
You still haven’t answered my question regarding how your experience with the 10mfan mouthpieces compare to the website descriptions. That’s a starting place to evaluate how a piece responds for you.Ive played the gen 2 classic it is dark and focused, thr gen 1 robusto hr snd metal, tbf I was not ss taken as i thought I would be expected to love it. Ive also played the Showtime which I enjoyed as much as the clsssic. They were all 7* tho i prefer a 6* 7 at a push..Trouble is getting the tone, projection depth of the website recording is hard..I think more tip openings are available stateside. I was hoping someone had played the eclipse and 10mfan who could say for e.g. its similar to the robusto tone but more projection or its as deep as the classic but more spread etc..
Thanks...I thought i had answerdd lol..The 10mfan reviews are quite accurate i think..The classic is well named..A classic tenor sound.. The robusto was as described more than the classic punchier i found the projection for me was less than expected hence trying the showtime which was great but to open. I couldnt get a 6*. I always read Steves reviews and listen to the soundclips..Issues are that he's a much better player than me..plays a 7* with a larger size reed as you say to the darker side..soundbites are hard to judge..All the mouthpieces responded well, within my capabilities anyhow..If i could stay with the link i would the tones nice i can manipulate my playing, there are some issues with reeds and ligs but overall im happy with a low baffle large chamber piece..in metal..I think i need a hr piece now im peeved ive put soooo much work into the stm.You still haven’t answered my question regarding how your experience with the 10mfan mouthpieces compare to the website descriptions. That’s a starting place to evaluate how a piece responds for you.
Here are some comparisons from an experienced tenor player on some of the pieces you mention:
![]()
Phil-Tone Eqinox and Eclipse Tenor Saxophone Mouthpiece
Steve Neff's review and sound clip of the Phil-Tone Eqinox and Eclipse Tenor Saxophone Mouthpiecewww.neffmusic.com
![]()
Search Results for “robusto”
www.neffmusic.com
It seems that you are interested in medium baffle, medium tip openings - that’s a great solution for a lot of people. It leaves a lot of room for manipulating air to vary the response of the mouthpiece.
Steve plays to the darker side of a mouthpiece than I do, so I know to listen to his demonstrations with that in mind. His Lamberson J7 was once mine, so I have direct knowledge of how my mouthpiece sounds on his horn. Of course, if you are handling air differently, your sound may vary considerably, but it’s good to know the possibilities that exist.
Tenor Medium Baffle Reviews
www.neffmusic.com
