Accessories Broken stand Hercules HCDS-730B

When saxrax went on sale the UK was still in the EU. Had I been younger I would have serioulsy considered buying it. I did entertain it but then I remembered I was getting old.
 
Took the top section off my tall hercules stand as I wanted rest of it for something else. I then made a triangular base and fitted the top section to it.
My diy at it's best. :rofl:
20240605_212233.webp
 
I've purchased a K&M 14300
1000001619.jpg

Which does feel exceptionally sturdy -I like the way the bell holder can be bent to an exact fit to your saxophone. I'll see how I get on with it going to and from lessons.

Still umming and ahhing about buying myself the Woodwinddesigns carbon fibre one - for no reason other than I want one

 
My stand broke -fortunately it happened while I was holding the saxophone so no damage: a bolt on one of the leg stays has sheared, so the leg is now floppy.

The stand is one of these:


I could just replace the bolt, but it's somewhat rattled my faith in this model/brand. I've never been particularly impressed with the build quality of this stand, and given that it's only had home and lesson use over the last 3 years -it's clearly not up to professional usage.

Now I'm shopping for a new stand.

I have a K&M Saxxy: Saxophone stand »Saxxy«

But I've never been able to get this set up to fit my sax as I'd like there seems to be no way to not have it squeezing the bell off the sax (perhaps the bell on my sax is larger than what it's designed for).

The basic K&M Saxophone stand seems to be bulletproof and is very much of a standard design. Although the contact points are different from most.

I'm trying to talk myself out of getting a Woodwinddesign carbon fibre stand alto saxophone stand - WoodWindDesign I like the way it grips the bell and the inherent flexibility of the material makes the stand absorb vibration.

Hercules will be sourcing parts from all over the place, and quite likely the lowest quote wins the order. There are a ton of nuts & bolts about made from the lowest quality chinesium, and your's probably had an existing weak spot fracture. I've used the K&M 14300 for many years on both tenor and alto, the build quality has been excellent, and the centre of gravity is definitely lower, and the weight of the base really helps with stability. They're not as portable as the Hercules, but I value my instruments more than convenience. I've lost a couple of the lower "clip on" bow support bits when packing away in a hurry, but Dawkes sell spares for them for £6 so I got a couple just in case.​

 
Stuff happens, why manufacturers have warrantees on new items. Is it still within warranty? It is probably a defectively manufactured fastener or in this case, perhaps a weaker strength fastener was substituted during manufacture. (Example, ANSI Strength# 1 - 3: lowest used instead of next up 5. Metric equivalent follows similarly. You could go up to automotive strength#8, but IMO not necessary. I'd use a replacement nut with a nylon insert, so bolt fitment remains loose enough to hinge properly but stays together.)

Replacing a broken bolt is a simple thing. You can increase its structural strength by going to tougher strength fasteners.

I'd say, replace the bolt and the ones on the other legs and be done with it. Life is too short to worry about the "what if's".
 
There's quite a few inferior copies of the Samson stands out there.

Is Hercules one of them?

Or is it the other way round

Hercules is a well known, well established brand -they invented the 'Autogrip' system that has been well adopted and much copied -particularly in the guitar industry. It's a system where the weight of the instrument activates a couple of catches that make it nearly impossible for the instrument to fall out. Very valuable in a guitar shop where lots of customers are pulling guitars off the wall to try and hanging them back up again not very carefully!

I bought the Hercules stand based on reputation and experience with thier other products.

Ironically this stand is in two parts -the upper part is a unique design that I like the functionality of and screws in to the base which is of a fairly very generic design but very poorly executed. I have started to worry about the quality of the parts that I can't see.
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,069
Messages
578,505
Members
8,131
Latest member
Jef B
Back
Top Bottom