Playing the saxophone Bright or dark tone

A wise man seeks good counselors and is not satisfied with uninformed opinions.

I get that you are into “experimenting”, but you are just sampling. You remain all over the map with regard to variables and have little chance of understanding what’s going on in a mouthpiece.
So, we all need to be mouthpiece experts to decide what sound we like? The broad strokes, main variables, of mouthpiece design are actually pretty simple. Tip opening, camber size, and baffle (none, low, high, short, long). High long baffle, small chamber, is going to be bright. No baffle with large chamber is going to be dark. All I'm saying is it's cheap and easy to actually try the major variable combinations. As a beginner, trying to find your sound, that has value. And yes, it's sampling, but it's sampling across a wide field, at the extremes, which gives the most knowledge with the least amount of effort.

Everything else about mouthpiece design is just nuance that will be lost on a beginner player.

I suppose there are worst things than buying a "good" mouthpiece and just using it. Or if you want to sound like a certain person and you buy their mouthpiece, so you can try to sound like them. To each their own. But if you want to develop YOUR unique sound, then yes, you will want to experiment.
 
@Ves @Dr G
I hope you realise that you are both right because whichever route the aspiring player chooses the end result imho will be the same. Only time and money varies.
 
The broad strokes, main variables, of mouthpiece design are actually pretty simple. Tip opening, camber size, and baffle (none, low, high, short, long). High long baffle, small chamber, is going to be bright. No baffle with large chamber is going to be dark.

Even given “broad strokes” that is way oversimplified and in some aspects inaccurate.
But if you want to develop YOUR unique sound, then yes, you will want to experiment.
I don’t follow this. Experiment with what? If you mean experiment with tone and sound exercises absolutely.

Experimenting with mouthpieces can be useful or it can actually be less than useful. But I don’t see how it can develop a unique sound ( unless you find a unique mouthpiece) but mostly a unique sound or voice comes from within. Along with a lot of practice.

All a mouthpiece can do is affect the tone. But I always think it’s best to learn to do that yourself first.
 
My first lesson with my teacher, he asked me to play a note.

"Now play it better" he says

Again I play the note, this time better

"Again better" he says

Again I play the note, and it was better again.

I've done all sorts of strange exercises with my teacher, at first I thought he was barking mad, he's no madder than I am but all these exercises help with my tone and sound.

It just means I now sound much better whilst playing out of time :rofl:

Now I must go and clap my hands :clapping:
 
The broad strokes, main variables, of mouthpiece design are actually pretty simple. Tip opening, camber size, and baffle (none, low, high, short, long). High long baffle, small chamber, is going to be bright. No baffle with large chamber is going to be dark.
Not that simple really, you forgot to mention facing curve and length, this has a big difference to how a mouthpiece plays.
Whats not that important relating to "bright and dark" is the material, Some of the brightest pieces I have owned were hard rubber and some of the darkest were metal.
Where usually the metal mouthpiece matters is size, they are generally slimmer profiles and that might suit one player over another.
 
you forgot to mention facing curve and length, this has a big difference to how a mouthpiece plays.
Yes it can have a huge difference. But it is still not to that simple. I believe it can be not just each Lampeter but the combination and way they interact.

Then we also have issues of terminology. One person’s bright may be another person’s edgy. One person’s dark is another person’s stuffy.
 
The broad strokes, main variables, of mouthpiece design are actually pretty simple.
Just to observe that, whatever the variables, their affects are coupled together through the vibrating air column, in a non-linear way, and similarly coupled to the reed, horn and embouchure. The result to turning the dial on one or another variable can, this, be surprising... This is evident from the interminable discussions on horn/neck/reed/mp/etc. combos with added spice from heavy screws etc.
 
I find this such an interesting thread..my durga definately sounded different onbthecref 54 than the z..my c1 crook sounds different than my g1...even playing subtones the z doesn't sound like the ref...maybe it will in time huh..
 
We could do this all day.. :rofl: I'm just a counselor, talking from my perspective. I think I've gotten across what I wanted to say, and so have others. I found it very useful in my early days to trial different mouthpieces and tip openings, rapidly. And what I've presented is how someone can do that, without having to be a mouthpiece scientist or having to spend hundreds of dollars for one MP. Nuf said, for me.
 
Your tone/sound is often a result what you are going to play. Playing in a noisy pubrock band you need a setup that cut through. I didn't use jogging shoes when I played football in rain. Most of us want to fit in. I like my set-up: Rovner Deep-V ( .130 tip, medium facing, high baffle), plasticover baritone reeds # 4, Rovner ligature with interchangeable plates. I so happy, after a long break, I still make noise with this set-up. The sax is not so important. I sound pretty much the same on a YTS 25, The New King or Martin Committee.
 
We could do this all day.. :rofl: I'm just a counselor, talking from my perspective. I think I've gotten across what I wanted to say, and so have others. I found it very useful in my early days to trial different mouthpieces and tip openings, rapidly. And what I've presented is how someone can do that, without having to be a mouthpiece scientist or having to spend hundreds of dollars for one MP. Nuf said, for me.

I picture you as a person who would nail one foot to the floor and then go for a run.

There is a HUGE GAP between having to be a mouthpiece scientist and ignorance. As a counselor, I trust you understand the meaning and benefit of finding a middle path.

There’s little use to trialing “different mouthpieces and tip openings, rapidly”, other then finding “ooooh, that didn’t work either”.

Still shaking my head in wonder and disbelief. I wish you the best of luck in finding a setup that works for you.
 
I picture you as a person who would nail one foot to the floor and then go for a run.

There is a HUGE GAP between having to be a mouthpiece scientist and ignorance. As a counselor, I trust you understand the meaning and benefit of finding a middle path.

There’s little use to trialing “different mouthpieces and tip openings, rapidly”, other then finding “ooooh, that didn’t work either”.

Still shaking my head in wonder and disbelief. I wish you the best of luck in finding a setup that works for you.
Competely disagree...experimenting is very beneficial...what tip opening facing length baffle vs non baffle metal vs hr beak size....advice is a yam 4c to start on a tenor thats bs..not suited to everyone..i started on a high baffle 7 opening..It was great
 
Competely disagree...experimenting is very beneficial...what tip opening facing length baffle vs non baffle metal vs hr beak size....advice is a yam 4c to start on a tenor thats bs..not suited to everyone..i started on a high baffle 7 opening..It was great

And how is that working out for you now?

 
And how is that working out for you now?

Its working ok. I made the mistake of buying a piece that i knew was probably to wide a tip opening because it was cheaper...no damage done ill carry on with the lebayle. It's no biggie and no sax practice was harmed in the experiment..it's all a learning curve.
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,076
Messages
578,675
Members
8,134
Latest member
banjo
Back
Top Bottom