Playing the saxophone Bright or dark tone

I don’t understand why they are supposed to. Wouldn’t we all be using them if that was the case?
I dunno I'm just going off google lol. I thought most players did use 3 reeds. 2 or 2 1/2 for beginners in general then you move up to a harder reed. I didn't mean to speak for everyone it's just what I took as the general consensus on google. Am I wrong again...

@Colin the Bear for sure I know 3s will tire me out more, used to happen when I played on 3s before. I only got 2 1/2 this time because it's all they had. 3 1/2 may be too hard but I'll give em a go just to see.

And yeh it's plenty loud enough, I'm a bit worried I'll break the sound barrier when I get a mic haha. Will defo try and play softer sometimes.
 
I dunno I'm just going off google lol. I thought most players did use 3 reeds. 2 or 2 1/2 for beginners in general then you move up to a harder reed. I didn't mean to speak for everyone it's just what I took as the general consensus on google. Am I wrong again...
Crap, I’ve been stuck on a 2-1/2 since 1977. Guess I’m a slow learner. But that’s all I can handle on a .125” tip on tenor. Any harder, and it’s like blowing through an open pipe.

But, in general, yes, beginners typically start on a very closed tip (~.71” on tenor) and a soft reed (1.5-2). When they build strength, they end up on 3.5-4 on a closed piece. That’s impossibly hard on a typical jazz piece. But a few manage it, like Branford and Grover. Us mere mortals can only handle 2.5, no matter how much (or little) we’ve progressed.
 
Interesting thanks. I'll try not to have any preconceived notion about what I'll sound like and just give different reeds a go with no expectations.

This must've been the site I was going off- Reeds - What Size / Strength Do I Need?

A thicker reed is more difficult to play but thicker reeds do offer a much better tone production and thus improve the sound of an instrument.

Beginners or young students almost always start on a 1 ½ or a 2 reed and progress through the thicknesses as they progress and become more advanced players.


Though I realise like most things with the sax, opinions vary.
 
Crap, I’ve been stuck on a 2-1/2 since 1977. Guess I’m a slow learner. But that’s all I can handle on a .125” tip on tenor. Any harder, and it’s like blowing through an open pipe.

But, in general, yes, beginners typically start on a very closed tip (~.71” on tenor) and a soft reed (1.5-2). When they build strength, they end up on 3.5-4 on a closed piece. That’s impossibly hard on a typical jazz piece. But a few manage it, like Branford and Grover. Us mere mortals can only handle 2.5, no matter how much (or little) we’ve progressed.
I totally get it, I guess I'm just always wanting solid answers but not really possible with the sax! So much is personal experience and opinion and what else your set up is like. Sorry if I word things as if I'm some sort of authority, I don't mean to it's literally just what I read on google. I know I'm way behind the experience and knowledge of others on here. If 2 1/2 works for you that's great!
 
I totally get it, I guess I'm just always wanting solid answers but not really possible with the sax! So much is personal experience and opinion and what else your set up is like. Sorry if I word things as if I'm some sort of authority, I don't mean to it's literally just what I read on google. I know I'm way behind the experience and knowledge of others on here. If 2 1/2 works for you that's great!
That's cool. I was being a little snarky in my response. I know exactly what reeds to use, and I do indeed play 3.5-4 on some of my horns and 2 on others. Just trying to show there are too many variables to generalize about reed strength.

My advice to you is don't change reed strength based on dark/bright. That's controlled by voicing (the angle and velocity of your air stream plus the shape of the inside of your mouth/throat and tongue position) and embouchure (how much lip surface and pressure and how much mouthpiece you take in). Change reed strength based on embouchure strength, air support ability, upper/altissimo and lower register response, ease of playing at all dynamics, ability to maintain intonation across the entire range of the horn. Yes, harder reeds will indeed play darker. But you can brighten them up with your technique, either accidentally or on purpose.

Long story short, stick with what you've got and learn to dial the darkness/brightness up and down by how you play it. Of course there are natural limits imposed by the mouthpiece and reed properties. But you will typically have quite a bit of leeway regardless.
 
No, Ves, it’s really not “fine”. You make a strong stand for something you seem to know little about. I am not pressing people to buy expensive boutique mouthpieces, rather to buy mouthpieces that have good facings so they can actually evaluate the effects of tip opening, baffle, and chamber.

I was playing 50 years ago, so I have a pretty good handle on what was available. You didn’t need a “high tech MP” because many of the ones that were being made in production, such as Meyer and Otto Link, were good middle of the road mouthpieces with decent facings that delivered good tone.

I really don’t care to learn even one way to skin a cat. I find the idea repugnant.
Sorry you're offended. We're just talking here right? If you were in the desert starving and a cat came along, you may need to know how to skin it. Ha!

Well, who said you should get a MP with a crappy facing? What's the assumption, just because it's mass produced it's junk?

You know what I'd like to see? A comparison between a RICO Graftonite, large chamber, $25 vs. a Jody Jazz HR Custom Dark $395 (anyone on here want to volunteer to do that?), same setup, same song, same distance from the mic. and lets see how they play. Maybe you could tell the difference, could a beginner? Even if there is a noticeable difference, will it really make him a better player for using one vs the other, long as it's the general tone he's looking for? And for that $395 I could buy a small chamber, larger chamber, in three different tip openings, and still have money left over. So, throw in a few Metalites while I'm at it, and I've got a smorgasbord or bright to dark in different tip openings I can try. Swap them back and forth all day, side by side! That is one way to quickly zero in on what works for you. May not be the way you do it.

Funny thing, on Youtube Sax.uk.co had a comparison test to find the ultimate dark setup. The guy finds out that the reed makes a bigger difference than the MP and screws up his whole comparison. Just use this reed!

A wise man has many counselors. If they are all telling you the same thing, you need some new counselors.
 
That's cool. I was being a little snarky in my response. I know exactly what reeds to use, and I do indeed play 3.5-4 on some of my horns and 2 on others. Just trying to show there are too many variables to generalize about reed strength.
Yeh I understand now-I was over simplifying things based on my limited knowledge. Totally fine with being corrected, just don't wanna think I'm rubbing people up the wrong way or something if they think I'm being a know-it-all! Of course you know what reeds work for you. I only play the alto sax right now and stick to pop rock songs mainly so I guess I was focusing on what I thought would help with that style of playing. But love to hear about other set ups and musical styles as well, just should've taken that into account cos obviously there are a lot of different players here that will use a whole range of reeds.

Thank you for the advice much appreciated will take it all on board.
 
I got one good song out my sax last night...after like an hour of playing, then after that it started sounding too loud and tinny-which I think is what I meant by "too bright" which was probably the wrong description. Yeh tinny is I guess the best way to describe it.

I'm using 2 1/2 reeds so I'm gonna order some 3s maybe even 3 1/2 because they are supposed to give a better tone (although I understand this may make vibrato harder). I'm also trying to play with a more open throat which I understand is what you want to do. Will give myself a couple weeks of solid long-tone practice and see if that helps. Many thanks for all the advice I've gotten 🙂
Going up to 3 or 3 1/2 will make you blow harder and it won't sound good. remember to match your mpc with reed and your embouchure. small opening mpc can be played with harder reed by most and the reverse is also true. Then the chamber comes into play. It gets too technical for me to comprehend and explain but.... You should be able to produce a decent tone blowing very softly with your setup with a wet reed. Otherwise it's a mismatch or your sax has leaks. Am self taught so ymmv.
 
You know what I'd like to see? A comparison between a RICO Graftonite, large chamber, $25 vs. a Jody Jazz HR Custom Dark $395 (anyone on here want to volunteer to do that?), same setup, same song, same distance from the mic. and lets see how they play. Maybe you could tell the difference, could a beginner?

I can only tell you about a Metalite, Graftonite, and a Meyer (all for baritone though).

Huge differences for me on the blowing end, much less when recording (on my Zoom recorder).

When I tried them in my combo, opinions were divided on the Metalite. They didn't hear much difference between the Meyer and Graftonite mouthpieces.
 
2 or 2 1/2 for beginners in general then you move up to a harder reed.
Totally the opposite for me. As a beginner I used 4s. Trying to seem macho I assume. Gradually over time playing professionally (40 years +) I improved enough to be able to use softer reeds because I had so much more control over tone once I'd developed my embouchure. I now use 2 or 2.25.

To be honest you do need to work to be able to use softer reeds effectively though. It’s a skill worth acquiring because once you can handle softer reeds you get a lot more versatility.
 
Last edited:
Sorry you're offended. We're just talking here right? If you were in the desert starving and a cat came along, you may need to know how to skin it. Ha!

Well, who said you should get a MP with a crappy facing? What's the assumption, just because it's mass produced it's junk?

You know what I'd like to see? A comparison between a RICO Graftonite, large chamber, $25 vs. a Jody Jazz HR Custom Dark $395 (anyone on here want to volunteer to do that?), same setup, same song, same distance from the mic. and lets see how they play. Maybe you could tell the difference, could a beginner? Even if there is a noticeable difference, will it really make him a better player for using one vs the other, long as it's the general tone he's looking for? And for that $395 I could buy a small chamber, larger chamber, in three different tip openings, and still have money left over. So, throw in a few Metalites while I'm at it, and I've got a smorgasbord or bright to dark in different tip openings I can try. Swap them back and forth all day, side by side! That is one way to quickly zero in on what works for you. May not be the way you do it.

Funny thing, on Youtube Sax.uk.co had a comparison test to find the ultimate dark setup. The guy finds out that the reed makes a bigger difference than the MP and screws up his whole comparison. Just use this reed!

A wise man has many counselors. If they are all telling you the same thing, you need some new counselors.

A wise man seeks good counselors and is not satisfied with uninformed opinions.

I get that you are into “experimenting”, but you are just sampling. You remain all over the map with regard to variables and have little chance of understanding what’s going on in a mouthpiece.
 
Well, who said you should get a MP with a crappy facing? What's the assumption, just because it's mass produced it's junk?
Nobody said that!

Mass produced does not mean junk. But agin nobody did actually assume that (I think)
 
As a returning player, I may be talking rubbish.

When I was learning at school, there was only really 1 reed we all played on, Rico orange box. Until recently returning I didn't realise there was such a choice in reeds.

I've debated changing reed, changing mouthpiece, and then I've gone and see my teacher who within minutes has given me suggestion and the issues resolved.

Bright or dark, it won't matter really matter if the basics aren't there, the timing, articulation, rhythm, etc.

Whilst equipment does play a part its only ever going to be as good as the person using it.
 
Going up to 3 or 3 1/2 will make you blow harder and it won't sound good. remember to match your mpc with reed and your embouchure. small opening mpc can be played with harder reed by most and the reverse is also true. Then the chamber comes into play. It gets too technical for me to comprehend and explain but.... You should be able to produce a decent tone blowing very softly with your setup with a wet reed. Otherwise it's a mismatch or your sax has leaks. Am self taught so ymmv.
Thanks for the advice, agree a 3 1/2 probs too hard. I'm playing on a Yamaha 4C if that helps, I don't know the technical stuff, or how small or large the mpc is compared to others. My Selmer C* is knocking about somewhere if I can find it-I used to play a 3 on that no probs, again don't know the mpc dimensions. Was surprised to find a Yamaha 4C is a quarter of the price of a Selmer C*.

Totally the opposite for me. As a beginner I used 4s. Trying to seem macho I assume. Gradually over time playing professionally (40 years +) I improved enough to be able to use softer reeds because I had so much more control over tone once I'd developed my embouchure. I now use 2 or 2.25.

To be honest you do need to work to be able to use softer reeds effectively though. It’s a skill worth acquiring because once you can handle softer reeds you get a lot more versatility.
Oh wow 4s, were they not really hard to play?!
 
Thanks for the advice, agree a 3 1/2 probs too hard. I'm playing on a Yamaha 4C if that helps, I don't know the technical stuff, or how small or large the mpc is compared to others. My Selmer C* is knocking about somewhere if I can find it-I used to play a 3 on that no probs, again don't know the mpc dimensions. Was surprised to find a Yamaha 4C is a quarter of the price of a Selmer C*.


Oh wow 4s, were they not really hard to play?!
I don't remember them being the hard to play. I used them because at the time I bought into the fallacy that better players used harder reeds.
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,076
Messages
578,676
Members
8,134
Latest member
banjo
Back
Top Bottom