Playing the saxophone Bright or dark tone

Not a recommended approach: Trying crappy mouthpieces, dark vs bright, leaves so much out of the mix.

How ‘bout a good mouthpiece with a decent facing, rails, and tip, featuring a medium chamber and moderate baffle, then learn to control your tone?

Whoa. Revolutionary, eh?

Or keep tossing money down a rat hole, get frustrated because you can’t make a decent tone or control your intonation , then quit playing the horn before you ever get anywhere. I understand your point. Not recommended if you actually want to learn to make music on the saxophone.
Inexpensive and readily available because it's produced in large quantities doesn't make it crappy. Nor does it mean that the facing and rails will be bad. And if you can get it for <$50 than you can actually buy a couple tip openings to see what works better for you. It beats buying one "good" MP for $300 and just being stuck with it. And the difference between a good MP and a great one is not going to make that much of a difference in how you play. Players 50 years ago didn't have a million high tech MP to choose from, but we still talk about them today.

It's like buying fancy wheels and low profile tires for your car. Is there a performance advantage and do different tires and wheels handle differently? Sure, but for 99% of the driving you do, it's not going to make a hill of beans difference. In that case, any low profile tire will show you the difference between a low profile tire and a regular tire. Once you're out on the race track then it becomes whole different story.

There's more than one way to skin the cat. We disagree. That's fine.
 
This thread took a sudden shift from "tonguing and articulation" to "bright and dark tone". In my teaching, I found that the oral cavity can have a great effect upon the "color" of the tone just like in singing. A good example is what we do to play "subtone" in the lower register. I used to do an exercise with my 2nd year students having them sing "EEE" and playing a phrase with that feeling, and then singing "OOO" and playing with that feeling. The tonal difference in an ensemble is quite pronounced.
 
Inexpensive and readily available because it's produced in large quantities doesn't make it crappy.
Very true. I was among the first people to acknowledge that some very cheap Chinese mouthpieces were OK. However there are still loads of them that aren't so beware.

The cheap ones that were around before the Shrakbites etc such as Hite and Yamaha are all good mouthpieces. The problem is beginners are not really in a position to know if a mouthpiece is good or not just from trying it.

And the difference between a good MP and a great one is not going to make that much of a difference in how you play
Indeed not. But the difference between a bad one and a good one could well make a huge difference.
Players 50 years ago didn't have a million high tech MP to choose from, but we still talk about them today.

I think most mouthpieces around then were good. Today there is a much higher percentage that aren't. Again, I'm not saying just because a mouthpiece is both cheap and Chinese doesn't mean it is bad.
 
Last edited:
I played for years on the mouthpiece that came with my B&H Lafleur alto. Being self taught I had no idea if it was good or bad or that there was such a thing.
Still got gigs.
Then I was given Ben Davis and realised that the mouthpiece can help.
My point is, that when starting out, you make such a God awful noise that a so called, good, bad or indifferent mouthpiece is irrelevant so long as it plays.
I'm excluding poorly made or poorly finished kit.
Maybe Trying to get the best out of cheap gear trains a player to listen and push the limits.
I'm currently playing a horn rated as bright with a mouthpiece reputed as stuffy.
This set up will go dark or bright and out project a trumpet.
Gear helps but practice is all. Focus should be on practice. Not shopping.
Apart from hats. A good hat is essential.
 
Inexpensive and readily available because it's produced in large quantities doesn't make it crappy. Nor does it mean that the facing and rails will be bad. And if you can get it for <$50 than you can actually buy a couple tip openings to see what works better for you. It beats buying one "good" MP for $300 and just being stuck with it. And the difference between a good MP and a great one is not going to make that much of a difference in how you play. Players 50 years ago didn't have a million high tech MP to choose from, but we still talk about them today.

It's like buying fancy wheels and low profile tires for your car. Is there a performance advantage and do different tires and wheels handle differently? Sure, but for 99% of the driving you do, it's not going to make a hill of beans difference. In that case, any low profile tire will show you the difference between a low profile tire and a regular tire. Once you're out on the race track then it becomes whole different story.

There's more than one way to skin the cat. We disagree. That's fine.

No, Ves, it’s really not “fine”. You make a strong stand for something you seem to know little about. I am not pressing people to buy expensive boutique mouthpieces, rather to buy mouthpieces that have good facings so they can actually evaluate the effects of tip opening, baffle, and chamber.

I was playing 50 years ago, so I have a pretty good handle on what was available. You didn’t need a “high tech MP” because many of the ones that were being made in production, such as Meyer and Otto Link, were good middle of the road mouthpieces with decent facings that delivered good tone.

I really don’t care to learn even one way to skin a cat. I find the idea repugnant.
 
I was playing 50 years ago, so I have a pretty good handle on what was available. You didn’t need a “high tech MP” because many of the ones that were being made in production, such as Meyer and Otto Link, were good middle of the road mouthpieces with decent facings that delivered good tone.
Yes, there were no “boutique” or “high tech” mouthpieces. Or ligatures for that matter. Now that there are I’m so glad because we now all sound better than the players back then 🙂
 
Something that helped me to get a better tone on alto; a teacher once told me to play the higher register as if you’re playing low notes. Works for me with altissimo on clarinet too; when I stop thinking about them as high notes, my throat/mouth automatically relaxes, which makes them sound fuller.
 
I'm pretty bright on the baritone as well. I have a mouthpice with a step baffle (like Berg Larsen "2" chamber) with a small roll over baffle. And I don't play plasticover reeds on bari. Ordinary cane reed, american cut.
 
From someone who has been on the mouthpiece journey my tuppence worth..the mouthpiece and crook is all part of the journey..my 2nd hand z came with 2 necks c1 narrow bore and g1 wide bore..there is a difference in tone per se. Its not the sax thats bright this is just the medium to play the notes generated by the mpce reed and neck. Resistance is key for me an easy blowing sax will usually play brighter til resistance is added. This can be from reeds or mouthpiece. There are so many variants chamber size, baffled or non baffled, metal or HR. I found with metal its the beak size and design that suits me the material is irrelevant to the tone. I have a thin hr piece thats brighter than my metal piece...mpce and reeds are a very important part of your set up and as I have said there are many variables...sooo..there are in my mind 2 ways of approaching it..trawl e bay and buy loads of mouthpieces not knowing if they are going to work ( for you) you may get lucky like me and learn your preferences ( it only took 6 years lol )..this is time you could be playing much more fun and beneficial..or...take your sax to a local dealer and try out different pieces..wide chamber medium chamber, metal ( beak size only) baffled non baffled try some reeds if you need to be happy and BUY the one that works and sounds best for you regardless..comfort is important...then get mpces out of your mind ( if you can ;-) ) and enjoy your journey...ps don't forget it will sound different when you get it home environment plays a part too..
 
Bright vs dark or bad vs good?

As I wrote earlier I'm "bright" because I want to be bright. A bright, piercing, centered, compact, cutting, dense, distinct, focused, hissing, intensive, metallic, nasal, peppery, piercing, pointed, powerful, prominent, pronounced, punchy, raucous, rocky, screaming, sharp, strong ....... tone/sound is best for me. I just play electric blues and Rock 'n' Roll. A baffled mouthpiece and Martin Committee saxes helps me. A Fender Stratocastor or a Telecastor is good company. Of couse, it's me that is Rock & Roll Saxophone. A good example of selfmade brainwashing 😉

It would not be fun if we all sounded the same, played the same music, took lessons from the same teachers that taught the same stuff ....... .

Play bright, dark, pretty, , filthy, airy, brittle, course, dirty, fat ..... just do it and have fun. I hope I can play bright for many more years.
 
Yeh I think I spoke too soon when I said the mouthpiece and/or sax was too bright. It was just a couple days where it wasn't great, maybe I hadn't sufficiently warmed up or something. I got it sounding pretty good lately, it's not too bright, or if it is it isn't a problem-interesting discussion regarding mouthpieces though for sure. I will try and find my Selmer C* just to try it. I need to remember I can get it sounding good when it's set up right and I've done a decent warm-up. It's like the least little thing can make it sound not optimal to my ears. But when it's good I'm happy with the sound, I just need to remember that. Only thing is my middle C is still out-is this known to be one that doesn't tune very well? All my other notes are good, even the high ones now and then I do that C and it just hits me how out it is.
 
Reed placement is crucial. A little forward or back can affect how a reed plays.
Don't to forget to swab out the neck and mouthpiece.
Washing out the mouthpiece in COLD water with a toothbrush and a little toothpaste keeps it fresh.
We all have good and bad days. The bad days will get fewer as you progress.
Some notes need special attention. You'll hear players talking about voicing.
 
@Colin the Bear Thanks Colin! Yeh it's frustrating because one day it sounds great another day rubbish and I spend most of my time taking the reed off and putting it back on or moving the mouthpiece. It totally puts me off when I can't get the sound I want so that affects how I play as well. I probably don't spend enough time warming up either so that doesn't help-I'll be working on that and doing long tones before I play from now on. My fault for trying to take short-cuts! I just have sooo many songs on my list I can't help but wanna get right into it!
 
@Colin the Bear Thanks Colin! Yeh it's frustrating because one day it sounds great another day rubbish and I spend most of my time taking the reed off and putting it back on or moving the mouthpiece. It totally puts me off when I can't get the sound I want so that affects how I play as well. I probably don't spend enough time warming up either so that doesn't help-I'll be working on that and doing long tones before I play from now on. My fault for trying to take short-cuts! I just have sooo many songs on my list I can't help but wanna get right into it!
Don’t blow too hard. Learn how much air is enough on each note as you go up and down the register. After a while you’ll be able to modulate your sound to bright or dark with subtle changes to your embouchure and breath control. Am self taught so ymmv.
 
I got one good song out my sax last night...after like an hour of playing, then after that it started sounding too loud and tinny-which I think is what I meant by "too bright" which was probably the wrong description. Yeh tinny is I guess the best way to describe it.

I'm using 2 1/2 reeds so I'm gonna order some 3s maybe even 3 1/2 because they are supposed to give a better tone (although I understand this may make vibrato harder). I'm also trying to play with a more open throat which I understand is what you want to do. Will give myself a couple weeks of solid long-tone practice and see if that helps. Many thanks for all the advice I've gotten 🙂
 
A reed needs to suit mouthpiece and player. Sometimes a stiffer reed suits both, better.
Bear in mind a stiffer reed will tire your embouchure more quickly.
Sometimes we play too loud for the set up.
Sacrificing volume for tone is a judgement call.
I think we forget how loud saxophone is/can be.
Sometimes a different cut or brand is the answer.
I haven't looked back since I found Daddario reserve.
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,076
Messages
578,675
Members
8,134
Latest member
banjo
Back
Top Bottom