Playing the saxophone Bright, dark, focussed, core, open - what do these terms mean to you?

Most people can agree on the difference between dark and bright. When you try to make a more precise description it is necessary to check if the words used mean the same to all people. Especially when the sound is 'wanted' in one genre and not wanted'' in another. This introduces emotional bias which can blur the meaning of the terms. For example: the sound of Clarence Clemons can be described as a bright edgy sound or as a bright sound with a metallic edge. I think that compared to edgy metallic edge is a more universal understood descriptor.
The word edgy is not used so often. "Pointed", "punchy", "sharp", "keen" is better to describe an "edgy" sound. Other words that are also used when we talk about "bright" and "edgy" are "cracking", "cutting", "piercing", "raucous", "screaming", "shrill" ..... . Words that are used by persons that don't like "bright" sound.

I think Clarence Clemons had a dark sound. Just because he played in the upper register doesn't mean he was "bright". A guy told me that Martin saxes are dark saxes. Just because the low tones comes out easy and good due to the construction, doesn't mean it'a dark sounding sax. High and bright, low and dark is no the same. Wood pads, do they give us a "woody" sound?
 
Baritones are an interesting subset.
They are. The low frequency fools you to the dark side of the spectrum, but the low conicity (diameter increase per length) makes it volume dependent brighter. Also, you don't need an extreme mouthpiece to make it bright. The same goes for bass saxophones. I often use the descriptor haunted for those instruments besides cutting, they are related terms but they can be used as different axis for these subsets.
 
Yes, speaking about sound is difficult for many reasons, not the least of which ius that we all hear differently. That said, when trying to describe a sound, I want people to use as many terms, comparisons, metaphors as possible. Collectively they all point in certain directions which help to understand the idea trying to be conveyed.

"Rich", for me, is the opposite of "dull" or "bland" or even "small".

But sometimes we are also describing "feel" at the same time, knowingly or unknowingly.

"Small" can be about the feeling encountered, when the player cannot feel the resonance as they play. "Constricted" is also a term that suggests that.

"Spread" might refer to a broad sound and/or a tubby or imprecise sound, as opposed to "focused", where the core is both felt and heard.

If you play a handful of different horns, such as a Mark VI, a Borgani, a Balanced Action and a vintage Conn, you will hear and feel some of these things in comparison to one another. I think we hear it and feel it, too, as the response of the horns varies.

But, I don't believe the terms we use are problematic. It's just that they are shadows of the real thing and we have to want to try to understand what the speaker is trying to communicate. When you've played enough setups, these terms start to define themselves for each player.

There is a certain poetry involved, alongside the measurable aspects of the sound.
 
When you've played enough setups, these terms start to define themselves for each player

This feels like the key idea for me. I've been playing for a month and most of these terms don't have much meaning for me. When someone lacks direct experience it's convenient to use words that seem to have accepted definitions (dark, bright, warm, cold). However I feel like it's too easy to fall in the trap of hearing one example of something and assuming that's the case for everything.
 
This feels like the key idea for me. I've been playing for a month and most of these terms don't have much meaning for me. When someone lacks direct experience it's convenient to use words that seem to have accepted definitions (dark, bright, warm, cold). However I feel like it's too easy to fall in the trap of hearing one example of something and assuming that's the case for everything.

I also think that it's a good idea to try to express what you think you are hearing and feeling, knowing that it is just an attempt to define something for yourself. Use whatever words or comparisons or phrases that seem to have meaning for you. Will they change? Likely, but, that doesn't really matter. What matters, I think, is finding a way to think about your sound in a meaningful way.
 
It’s so hard to put these concepts into words. When I say “A”, I know I mean a note with a fundamental frequency of (approximately) 440 Hz, or an even multiple/division thereof. No imprecise fuzzy terms like “color” or “core”.

But so often teachers ask students to “focus” their sound, or “play with more core”, and then demonstrate what they mean by playing, and/or playing recorded examples. When I play I often manipulate my tone by playing “warmer” or more “intensely”. What this actually means is I manipulate my oral cavity to speed up or slow down my air, and/or focus the air stream or spread it out. So when I read words like “core” or “focus” or “spread”, I relate them to how it feels to play a certain way. Much like when I read “apple” I remember the taste sensation of a nice HoneyCrisp.

Also, when I listen to recorded saxophone music, I often relate viscerally to the sounds I hear, just like I relate viscerally to a video of a beautiful young thing chomping down on a juicy hamburger dripping catsup. I mean, can’t you just taste it? (Whatever “it” is…)

So it’s hard to put precise descriptions of what these words mean, at least in terms of saxophone sound. These words are fuzzy in nature, and their meaning is, for me at least, bound up in memories of physical sensations.
 
I think a universal saxophone language would help to understand and cooperate better. I live in Sweden and I use to read saxophone information and talk with saxophonists. UK and USA are not always using the same terms/words. A more common "language" is not wrong?

I worked in restaurant kitchens with 8-10 chefs and none of us were talking same language. I'm glad I learned the "restaurant French" and that I learned the students I was teaching a more updated "technical language/jargon/vernacular" so they could go out and work in other countries.

I like subjects like this. But as an autodidact woodshed honker playin on my own, I have my own words/terms in my head. I just do, talk, play, think ..... in a way that is fine by me.
 
Nice and not nice. That's me done.
Desmond has a nice sound.
Parker had a not nice sound.
I aim to sound nice.
This is why it's so difficult to try to define sound because I like both of these players and they're sounds for different reasons.
I think the bottom line is you have to like your own sound, however you describe it doesn't really matter because another listener might well describe differently but it has to sound right to your ears.
 
Let's talk about Arthur Blythe. I don't hear a "reedy quality" in his tone at all. But it certainly cuts like a knife. I'd call it "bright", but you're saying "bright" involves reediness, or maybe that's just one of the qualities that contributes to a "bright" effect.
The reedy quality must be something related to complexity of harmonics as opposed to the dominance of high harmonics that people think of as creating brightness maybe.
 
I don't suppose anyone has done anything so obvious, but does anyone here know of a study that relates these woolly terms to anything physically measurable - spectrum analysis, differences in harmonic content depending on listening position, etc.
Using meaningless (to me anyway) terms such as "core" to describe equally meaningless terms such as "spread" just muddies the waters.
 
terms such as "core" to describe equally meaningless terms such as "spread" just muddies the waters.
Im on the fence about the term spread, because I think it is used to mean two things. (1) There is a wide spread of frequencies (2) the sound is less directional, it literally spreads out left and right more than usual. (he sound will always travel in all six directions (left right forward backwards up and down) but there can be varying degrees.

Core is one I don't know, but if I had a definition it might be that if you bought of the sound like an electrical wire, the core is the copper, outside the core is the insulation. Or else the sound appears to have several "layers" and the core is the dominant one.

But when people say core, I'm not sure that's what they mean. "It has that Selmer core" is something I've seen written.
 
I don't suppose anyone has done anything so obvious, but does anyone here know of a study that relates these woolly terms to anything physically measurable - spectrum analysis, differences in harmonic content depending on listening position, etc.
Using meaningless (to me anyway) terms such as "core" to describe equally meaningless terms such as "spread" just muddies the waters.

Back in 1972 FS Wyman wrote his excellent PhD Thesis "An acoustical study of alto saxophone mouthpiece chamber design" which you can download here.

The Thesis abstract is as follows:
This thesis is the result of a study made of the influence of the saxophone mouthpiece chamber design upon tone quality, intonation, and other playing characteristics. Its aim is to furnish information which will be helpful to teachers and performers in choosing an appropriate mouthpiece for a particular desired tone quality. The research is limited to investigation of alto saxophone mouthpieces. Tests were conducted on twelve different designs. Measurements of each design were correlated with objective and subjective test results in order to isolate the effects of individual design parameters. Tone quality tests made use of spectrum analysis of selected tones from the range of the instrument. A Stroboconn tuner was used in making frequency measurements. The use of mechanical embouchures was avoided in order to duplicate actual playing conditions and to benefit from subjective reactions of the players taking part in the testing. The major conclusions are concerned with the relative brightness of tone quality and the evenness of tone quality throughout the playing range of the instrument. The design factors responsible for these characteristics are identified. Other premises are formed on intonation, mouthpiece resistance, dynamic range, and carrying power. Findings from the spectrum analysis indicate some new considerations for tone quality theory in the form of undamped and "accessory" harmonics which are not accounted for in presently held theories.​
​
So more than 50 years ago there was detailed spectrum analysis done examining "tone quality theory" based on frequency measurements for a range of different players, mouthpieces and instruments (all alto saxophones). It considered both objective assessments (measurements by machines) and subjective assessments by experienced musicians.

Among the conclusions are several points relevant to this thread:

The major conclusions are concerned with the relative brightness of tone quality and the evenness of tone quality throughout the playing range of the instrument.​

The facing curve of a mouthpiece affects its playing qualities ...... ​
  • LONG CURVE & CLOSE TIP - favoring of low register, darker quality
  • LONG CURVE & OPEN TIP - bigger tone
  • SHORT CURVE & CLOSE TIP - reedy, stuffy tone
  • SHORT CURVE & OPEN TIP - favors upper register, more penetrating quality
Rhys
 
Im on the fence about the term spread, because I think it is used to mean two things. (1) There is a wide spread of frequencies (2) the sound is less directional, it literally spreads out left and right more than usual. (he sound will always travel in all six directions (left right forward backwards up and down) but there can be varying degrees.

Both 1 & 2 should be measurable in an entirely objective way. I know that (1) has been done but what about (2) - does anyone know ?

And the Wyman Thesis doesn't use the term "spread" in either of these ways but does investigate "Octave Spreading", meaning "the tendency for tones of the second register to be sharper than the same tones in the lower register."

Rhys
 
Last edited:
(2) - does anyone know ?
It could be a usefulPHD study. I'm not sure if manufacturers would be interested because I don't think there is any USP involved in being either spread or not spread (omni or directional). My Conn tenor is supposed to be spread (spatially) and my Martin not so spread. I don't find a preference for one over the other.
 
  • Focussed
  • Spread
  • Fat
  • Thin
  • Centered
  • Open
Focussed: minimal audible air sound. Only note sound.
Spread: rich blanket of air and deeper resonance surrounding the note.
Fat: deep resonance that feels like the sax is vibrating with it
Thin: lack of lower supporting resonance
Centered: same as focussed
Open: means nothing to me honestly
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,072
Messages
578,576
Members
8,133
Latest member
walthang
Back
Top Bottom