The word edgy is not used so often. "Pointed", "punchy", "sharp", "keen" is better to describe an "edgy" sound. Other words that are also used when we talk about "bright" and "edgy" are "cracking", "cutting", "piercing", "raucous", "screaming", "shrill" ..... . Words that are used by persons that don't like "bright" sound.Most people can agree on the difference between dark and bright. When you try to make a more precise description it is necessary to check if the words used mean the same to all people. Especially when the sound is 'wanted' in one genre and not wanted'' in another. This introduces emotional bias which can blur the meaning of the terms. For example: the sound of Clarence Clemons can be described as a bright edgy sound or as a bright sound with a metallic edge. I think that compared to edgy metallic edge is a more universal understood descriptor.
I think Clarence Clemons had a dark sound. Just because he played in the upper register doesn't mean he was "bright". A guy told me that Martin saxes are dark saxes. Just because the low tones comes out easy and good due to the construction, doesn't mean it'a dark sounding sax. High and bright, low and dark is no the same. Wood pads, do they give us a "woody" sound?
