Introduction brassier than I'm used to

snowball

Member
Messages
71
Location
East Sussex
Hi

I've played the clarinet for several years and now I'm trying to play the alto sax. I've learnt the fingering quickly but getting the embouchure right is more of a problem. The notes G and above are ok but F and below tend to come out an octave too high or as two notes at once, or as a strange strangled sound javascript:emoticon('πŸ™')
Sadwhen I play in the second octave.

I am using a Rico 1 1/2 reed and a Jupiter sax.

Any help gratefully received! πŸ™
 
Hi Catherine and welcome,

from what I have read, it could be you need to be loser with embouchure that on a clarinet, I have a Jupiter and they are good


Others will give you more info than I can
 
Hi Catherine,

Welcome to the BR.

I went from sax to clarinet and I found the clarinet embouchure very much more stable, in fact so much so very little needed to change to reach all the notes.

I guess the other way round highlights this, you need to make fairly large changes to your embouchure to realise the compass of an alto sax. This comes with practice, although I guess you'll probably realise this.

Keep at it, its such a lovely instrument you wont regret it. I can also vouch for Jupiter saxes, provided its been set up correctly you should be able to reach all the notes.

Try running down a C scale and relax your embouchure as you slide down the notes, after a while you'll realise just how much adjustment is required.

Good luck.

Simon
 
Hello Catherine, and welcome.

Assuming the sax is OK I'm pretty sure that Smiffy has hit the nail on the head. I tried the clarinet once and it took a much tighter embouchure so I suppose the reverse apply's.

Still, best wait for someone who knows for sure to answer.

Col.
 
Many thanks, all!

I've tried Smiffy's suggestion and did notice an improvement. Ive tried running up to G in the second octave and down again - F E & D were ok, but when I tried running down from A they went all peculiar again.

I'll try Pjonah's suggestion when I practise tomorrow (a bit late for strangled saxophone noises now)
 
Welcome to the forum!

Hope you are enjoying being on the same planet as Smiffy.
Well done for making a sensible move from Clarinet to Alto sax, which I think is really my favourite of the lot
Look forward to chatting with you over coming months.

Kind regards
Tom 8)
 
Welcome Catherine from the Cultural Centre of the Country, Croydon.
Keep going on both, Mozart's slow movement doesn't sound the same on alto and Bird on clarinet is unthinkable.
Snowball? Do you enjoy them?
 
Hi Catherine, Welcome to the breakfast room.

I have recently gone from alto to tenor and finding the same problem. I also had the problem when I first started on alto (having never played anything before)

I think it is embouchure as mine is definately improving with time. (I've had it about a month). Try and do plenty of excercises and long tones in the lower notes, in time I'm sure it will improve. I have had a little dabble with my daughter's clarinet and I agree with the others about the embouchure. I can only play it with a 1.5 or 2 reed whereas my daughter can play a 3. I assume it's because I've been used to playing sax.

Sharon
 
Hi Catherine and welcome to the breakfastroom. The others are right, you may need to have a more relaxed approach with the saxophone embouchure.
 
TomMapfumo wrote:
Welcome to the forum!

Hope you are enjoying being on the same planet as Smiffy.
Well done for making a sensible move from Clarinet to Alto sax, which I think is really my favourite of the lot
Look forward to chatting with you over coming months.

Kind regards
Tom 8)

What planet is that , the pink or the blue or the one that's flat πŸ˜‰
 
Hi Cathy (snowball)
welcome. Suitable nome de plume at the moment!
I started with clarinet, and the others are right, slacker embouchure needed. Also the angle is different, the clarinet is held closer to the chest, where the sax is out in front, if you know what I mean. It'll come - practice, practice, practice!
 
Thanks everyone for all the advice! I've been playing long notes up and down the C scale this evening, trying different embouchures, and I think there's a slight improvement.

Good to know it's not just me.

Coming down the second octave, I've found it helps to release the thumb key and press it down again before I go from G to F. Don't know why this should make a difference but it does.

So it's just practice and perseverance...

Snowball was the name of a pet gerbil we had once. I'm not very imaginative with user names!
 
Hello Catherine, welcome to the lounge, I'll second some of the above -
I've had pupils with Jupiters, if you're playing the standard Jupi' mouthpiece you may find the 1.5 reed a bit too soft, certainly worth trying a number 2, the increased stability may cure the problem.
gruss - spike
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,060
Messages
578,336
Members
8,128
Latest member
Roger Atlas
Back
Top Bottom