Best solution to home recording on mac

Linky Lee

Senior Member
Messages
1,953
Location
Salisbury, UK
I'm in the process of getting a Macbook Pro and a copy of Logic Studio 8. Once I've got this I'd like to be able to record my saxophone into Logic. I also want to have something that I can use for live performance. My budget is anything up to ?150.

What do you think the best combination would be?

Should I:
A) buy a USB Microphone. I've seen two, the Samson CO3U and the sE USB 1000a. I've used the 2200a before and really liked it. I've seen the USB 2200a and it looks really good, but out of my price range. The problem with the other USB mics is that they are USB only and can't be used in most live venues because of that. I also don't know on how the quality of USB mics are at the moment.

or

B) Buy a quality microphone, looking at the SM57 (?80), M-Audio Nova (condenser) (?80), AKG C1000s (?100) which has optional phantom powering and I've used before and like a lot. This would mean I need an interface to get it into my Mac. Phantom power would also be needed for the M-audio. - What would be the best way about doing this? I don't need to record a whole band, just the 1 mic at a time meaning a simple XLR to USB key would work, or would it be better to go with a 'real' interface, if so what would you recommend? I wouldn't mind paying a bit more if I could plug two mics in and record them simultaneously.

So something like the Sure SM57 and a M-Audio Fast track USB (?65)

or is there an option C?
 
Lee,

Have you already got Logic pro? if not, you might be better with logic express and spending more on a separate interface/mic

One problem with USB mics is the monitoring and input connections. Believe you me, connections are very useful. Want to plug in a guitar and keyboards? leave them connected? then this is going to be tricky with a USB interface and mic in one. Want two headphones when a mate comes around? hmmmmm tricky...I think the USB mics are ok, but you will soon out grow it.

I got a great deal on an alesis interface

http://www.guitarampkeyboard.com/en/alesis-io-14/69020

couple this with a rode NT1A, and you will be flying......if a trifle over-budget....probably more like ?250 total
 
BTW Lee,

The alesis worked straight out of the box with my macbook and is simple to set up, and has two superb quality pre-amps

It is bit like HIFI kit, at least you can upgrade your mic in the future or even add an outboard pre-amp, but buy an "all in one" solution and it is limiting.

Just my twopenneth...
 
I've no experience of USB mics but that sounds like good advice above.

The only thing I would say is that for recording you will be better off avoiding the SM57 and other dynamic mics and going for a studio condenser mic. As you have seen they are just as cheap nowadays but will give you nearer to the full range of frequencies when you come to record.

With dynamic mics the frequency range is limited and so the sound is more 'coloured'. They are also more directional, meaning that if you move slightly off-axis the sound wil change noticeably. But they have the advantage that you can take them on stage with you and avoid nasty feedback issues, so that may sway your decision.

BTW Logic 8 is a steal right now and unbelievable value for money, however you may want to see how you get on with GarageBand (free with your Mac!!) first, as it may just be all you need. Then you can spend your money on a dynamic and a good quality condenser for at home! 😛

The world's your lobster! Hope you enjoy your new setup.
 
Thanks for the response.

I know I want logic 8. I use it on my course and it has all the sequencing needs I have as well for composing to video.

The Alesis looks like a really good unit. I was looking at this unit for flexibility and future use. http://www.guitarampkeyboard.com/en/74914

I could couple that with a Rode NT1 as the Mac and Logic Pro is only about ?1200 becuse ofa big discount buying through the University. At the moment this is what I think I'll do. It means I can record bands and things too.
 
That tascam looks killer. Like I said, it is all about connections, and this one will last you a few years.....

I had tascam portastudios for years, great kit. I chose the alesis over the little tascam fireone thingy because it was only 2 in 2 out. The alesis has got 4 inputs, which means I can leave my guitar and keyboard hooked up all the time (and the gain settings the same)

Glad you are going this route, very future proof.

Looks like i'm moving on up to Logic as well...Just had problems with the AUMatrix reverb plug in on garageband on multiple tracks, getting very noisy. This is a known issue........ oh well.
 
Lee,

Just looking in more detail at the tascam, and just ne note of caution.

There is no such thing as zero latency monitoring from your computer, there is a very slight lag which is mighty annoying, OK on the sax beacuse you get a lot of "head sound", but hard work on the guitar.

So to get around this nearly all interfaces have headphone outputs and monitor outputs than have a fader knob which reads "hardware-computer" This blends or excludes monitoring from either source. So, if I am recording my guitar I rotate this knob to "hardware" so I am hearing only the sound in my headphones directly from the guitar input with no slight lag.

Basically this "zero" lag monitoring situations are crucial, and I can see occasions when you might need to create custom mixes for more than one set of headphones.

This tascam only has one headphone out. Which could be a real limitation. At this price it might be worth trying to find one with multiple headphone sockets.

The bigger alesis has these

http://www.andertons.co.uk/acatalog/info_IO26.html?utm_source=Froogle&utm_medium=Froogle

Or others will have!!
 
One small point I would make re Mac, Audio Interfaces and Logic Studio.

I use Logic Studio on the Mac and think it is absolutely fantastic. But be careful if you have the new Leopard OS pre-installed on the Mac that the audio interface has upgraded drivers for use with Leopard. I use a M-Audio Firewire 410 interface which works really well - however, I am still on the Tiger OS for Mac. One reason I have not upgraded (and believe me I would if I could) is that I know that this audio interface has not been upgraded for Leopard yet.

So the message is - carefully check the websites of any audio interface you are thinking of buying and make sure it is compatible with the Leopard OS.

Hope that helps.

Steve
 
The bigger Alesis does look good.
I've just received my money through today so I will probably order stuff in the coming weeks.

Only trouble is I've found an alto sax I want which means not being able to buy until I sell my Hanson to make back that money.
 
Problem Solved.
I've just ordered an Alesis IO/14 and a Rode NT-1a with mic stand, pop shield as freebies.

I should be getting my Mac before march. For now I can record into Audacity on my laptop. Thanks for all the help from everyone.
 
Problem most definitely not solved!!!

Two weeks after I placed my for the order Alesis IO/14 with GAK.co.uk
they e-mailed me saying the product has been taken off of the market and that they can't get one so I need to order a different product!

I'm thinking I'll just get the lower model as I can't really stretch to the one above and don't think it's really needed for my uses.
 
I got an Alesis IO/14 from a different site and am sending the smaller one back as it doesn't quite cut it for me. The 14 is only ?20 more too.

I've been thinking about the macbook pro recently, it struck me that the high end macbook with a memory upgrade to 2GB is exactly the same as the low end macbook pro I was going for, except for a 13" screen instead of the 15" and the graphics card (which I don't think is beneficial to me as I won't be doing any gaming on it, and probably just basic picture stuff. It's also considerably cheaper by about ?350+ not sure of the actual figure as I can get a big educational discount.

Are there any other differences I should be aware of?

I've just noticed, the macbook doesn't have a firewire 800 port. Since I'm using a firewire interface that supports either 400 or 800 this could be a big issue? The Macbook does have a slightly larger hard drive though. 160GB instead of the 120GB of the macbook pro.
 
I've finally got everything for my home studio ordered or arrived.

I ended up getting;

iMac 2.4Ghz, 2Gb Ram, 20" screen
Logic Studio 8
Alesis iO/14 firewire interface
Rode NT1-A condenser mic + Shockmount
AKG C519 clip on condenser mic
M-Audio Keystation 88ES Midi Keybaord
Pop Shield and Stagg Microphone Stand

In total I got the lot for a steal because of student discounts and bundle deals on the Rode mic, pop shield and stand.

Just waiting for the Mac to arrive, it was shipped last week and I just ordered the keyboard, everything else has arrived and is great.

I'm really looking forward to getting it all set up and getting creative with my recording/sequencing and all sorts.
 
Linky_Lee wrote:
Problem Solved.
I've just ordered an Alesis IO/14 and a Rode NT-1a with mic stand, pop shield as freebies.

I should be getting my Mac before march. For now I can record into Audacity on my laptop. Thanks for all the help from everyone.
Lee,
Could you pm me with full details of, your address, when you are absent, types of locks and security as well as leaving everything neatly boxed and near the door. Could you also leave the name of an disinterested taxi driver and the fare back to the station.
Thanking you in anticipation,
old git. >:)
 
Lee

You will not be disappointed with your iMac - that's what I got about 6 weeks ago. Sooo much better than PC (imho), I also gor Logic 8 but haven't figured how to use it yet - I am not a theorist- very much an activist and can't be doing with tutorials but I will have to if I want to get the most out of Logic.

I'm thinking about getting one of those little Zoom H2/H4 gadgets - did you get one and is it OK?
 
I didn't get one. I don't really feel the need for one. I don't do any recording out and about and the iMac is reasonably mobile if I do go anywhere I'm planning on recording.

I'm very new to Macs and have only just started using them a month or so ago as part of my course. I'd heard a lot about them but never had the chance to use them properly. As soon as I used one I realised how much better one would be for me, especially as I hope to write music for TV adverts and medias in general.
 
Linky - the iMac is a desktop - did you get a Macbook? My husband bought the Macbook Pro and he loves it. He is 'the least interested in IT' person you could meet but loves his music. Even he finds it a doddle to use.

Good luck withyours 🙂
 
yeah I know it's a desktop, but it's all built into one unit, and a small one at that. I also wanted the larger screen size than the macbook pro because of running logic which is much nicer to use on a larger screen.

The macbook pro also has less HD space, not as many USB ports and would of been ?400 more. On a student budget I think the iMac outweighed the Macbook pro even though portability was a high priority for me. It's not like the iMac has a huge CPU to lug around.
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,063
Messages
578,430
Members
8,129
Latest member
Bartman
Back
Top Bottom