Saxophone beginners Bending Notes

I can't do a Bulleid, but this is the newly built A1 Tornado, after Peppercorn.
tornado - small.jpg


Kev, I have an electric bass playing friend who also makes live steam models of Garratts.
Yes, Der W, even at my rudimentary stage of playing I can manage that kind of lip slur from just under a note, but I certainly can't sustain it.
 
Johnny Hodges was a master at bending up ...Did he do it all with embouchure, I wonder, or with careful use of keys?
YC

The most effective pitch bending takes place in the oral/vocal cavity*β€” NOT with the embouchure. This is how Johnny Hodges did it, from what I have observed. And Jimmy Heath told me that Hodges used a "double-lip" embouchure, with his TOP lip padding top teeth. Though, I took this more as a technical idiosyncrasy than the secret to his bending success.

When you use your embouchure to bend or alter pitch, you're also changing your tone, right? Listen to a Hodges bend of a 3rd, or 5th, (or more!) and his tone/timbre remains pretty darn constant, just like a violinist sliding a note right up the fingerboard.

Practicing overtones is an important way to develop the control and flexibility of your vocal mechanism.

Here are a couple of tips to get started on overtones, if they're new to you: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mOhmDYfbcD8

Any other thoughts?
~ Rick
 
How? And what exactly do you mean by effective?

How? - when I'm bending notes (including squealing up to altissimo) it's usually about altering throat and tongue positions, and trying not to fiddle with my embouchure too much. I do the same for playing in tune too, just less!

Effective? Well it's not the only way, you could of course lip-slur (thanks DW) but it is possibly easier to produce even tones this way, since your lips don't change so much, only the pitch.

I always thought Rabbit was a bit frivolous
- I've also heard of Johnny Hodges referred to as 'Dewey', since his bending style often made a note sound like 'doo-ee, doo-ee'... Not sure if it's lip slur or throat-bend!

Nick
 
How? - when I'm bending notes (including squealing up to altissimo) it's usually about altering throat and tongue positions, and trying not to fiddle with my embouchure too much.

Yes, I get your point about altissimo. How far down can you bend a note without altering your lip position? Do you do vibrato like that too?

Sorry about all the questions - spirit of inquiry and all that. Information is good.
 
Ok. I've had a good bash at this. In the normal range of the sax (ie not alt) I can bend notes down around a tone - more or less depending on which part of the range. Keeping lip and jaw rock solid I can bend a note about 10 cents with just tongue movement - although the change in timbre is probabaly more noticeable than the change in pitch. In the altissimo range, of course, most of the work is done with the oral cavity (but by no means all). So, please, could anyone explain exactly how you're managing to achieve useful bends in the normal range of the sax with just oral cavity alone? Are you sure your lips and jaw aren't moving just a little bit? Also, this is a new one for me - in 38 years of playing I've never come across it.
 
Now I'm getting confused. In normal range I understand a bend as a microtonal adjustment of less than the adjacent tone or semitone. I can do that with embouchure, but I just can't hold it that long yet. I can also do an octave and plus a fifth using the throat (and possibly the oral cavity). To me that's a clear jump in pitch, although I can see that it can be done very smoothly by a more experienced player. However, that is surely more of a glissando than a bend, isn't it?

Johnny Hodges was also called Jeep, after a cartoon character I believe. His colleagues also named his composition Squatty Roo after him because of his short stature. Any other musicians had more nicknames?
YC
 
Now I'm getting confused. In normal range I understand a bend as a microtonal adjustment of less than the adjacent tone or semitone.

Doesn't have to be as small as that. Can be as much as the player can manage using that fingering - up to about 3 semitones.

I can also do an octave and plus a fifth using the throat (and possibly the oral cavity). To me that's a clear jump in pitch, although I can see that it can be done very smoothly by a more experienced player. However, that is surely more of a glissando than a bend, isn't it?

Not a bend or a glissando. You're just picking out the harmonics - like a bugle player.
 
Yes, fair enough Nick, it's probaby slightly more than I suggested.
On the harmonics, I was going by what Rick's video proposed as kind of preparatory to using the throat/oral cavity for (what I would call) a glissando. Indeed I can't yet get a very smooth transition between fundamental, octave and third harmonic, but then I've never really tried before!
 
Ok. I've had a good bash at this. In the normal range of the sax (ie not alt) I can bend notes down around a tone - more or less depending on which part of the range. Keeping lip and jaw rock solid I can bend a note about 10 cents with just tongue movement - although the change in timbre is probabaly more noticeable than the change in pitch. In the altissimo range, of course, most of the work is done with the oral cavity (but by no means all). So, please, could anyone explain exactly how you're managing to achieve useful bends in the normal range of the sax with just oral cavity alone? Are you sure your lips and jaw aren't moving just a little bit? Also, this is a new one for me - in 38 years of playing I've never come across it.

Oh yes, probably I am (not about to try it now, the neighbours will kill me). In practice I think I'm using a combination of Flipper's whistling technique to achieve a bend (up or down), a little bit of lip to smooth things out, and careful (slow) fingering to achieve a big glissando type thing.

Johnny Hodges was also called Jeep, after a cartoon character I believe. His colleagues also named his composition Squatty Roo after him because of his short stature.
Yes, you're right about Jeep - the little mousy thing from Popeye. Never heard of Squatty Roo before, but I like it!

Nick
 
I've never heard him referred to in public as squatty roo either. Perhaps it was a band thing, or just a one off to give a title to an otherwise annonymous tune he had written. The first recording of it (I think) was in 1940 in one of Ellington's small group sesssions. Hodges takes several solos, the final whole chorus one has up tempo bends and other superb bits of playing, helped along by Jimmy Blanton's bass. There is at least one other recording in 1955 with Hodges suported by some Ducal people but also Shorty Rogers and Louis Bellson.
 
There's an interesting paper on the effect of vocal tract on sax pitch here:
www.phys.unsw.edu.au/jw/reprints/Chenetal.pdf

Bottom line is they say that vocal tract is tuned to different pitches in different players - until it gets to altissimo, when the altissimo players all have their vocal tracts tuned slightly above the desired notes. And that guys who can't do this tuning can play altissimo.

And another interesting paper of theirs (clarinet based) here:
www.phys.unsw.edu.au/jw/reprints/ChenetalJASA09.pdf

Which says that the reed's natural vibration frequency can be overcome by tuning the vocal tract (gross simplifiaction by me) and that skillful combination of this with fingering changes allows the clarinetist to produce a smooth glissando, like the opening of Gershwin's Rhapsody in Blue. By inference, given the similarity of the instruments, one would expect this to be possible on a sax as well
 
Last edited by a moderator:

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,069
Messages
578,501
Members
8,131
Latest member
Jef B
Back
Top Bottom