ProfJames
Elementary member
- Messages
- 11,758
- Location
- Berkshire, UK
Made me laugh....Convoy was a spirit of rebellion! Cop this ...........
View: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IvG3is7Bm1w
Another no-go area for me is "country and western". I was shocked to discover that my long-term George Thorogood favourite, "Move It On Over", was written by Hank Williams.
😱I've never much liked C&W either but some time ago my son, who has wide musical tastes, sent me a Hank Williams CD. I put it on in the background a few times and after a while realised I quite liked it.
It worried me a bit
😱 Oh no... Well I hope I don't develop a taste for Conway Twitty... Although that does remind me that I need some Cuprinol for the fence..Now that's proper music.A few years later I realised it had Disraeli gears.
Don't be too sure. Conway Twitty was a rocker before he started on C&W. Here's an example, not the best, but I've chosen it for the sax solo. If you want more, go to youtube and type in "Conway Twitty Rockabilly".Well I hope I don't develop a taste for Conway Twitty
... oh dear. I will close ranks and join the "I don't understand/like C&W". I remember the OH of a choir friend telling me at a dinner party that the 1950s C&W he liked was musically 'more advanced' and technically more complex than the Mozart Requiem we had sung in our previosu concert...
Given my age, gender, middle-age spread and lack of hair (and what is left is mostly grey) that at best is optimistic 
Find out what he's talking about, listen to some of it and form your own opinion - if you can be bothered.Where do you start with a claim like that?
I've never listened to C&W by Conway Twitty and I'm not sure I want to.Thank you Richard 🙂 I had no idea about Conway Twitty's roots. I have only seen him performing CW in his latter career and formed my opinion on that.. I thought he must be the worst example of the lot when we were discussing our own dislike of Country and Western, but perhaps he isn't.
No, I totally agree.I've never listened to C&W by Conway Twitty and I'm not sure I want to.
I was familiar with the music he was referring to. One of the challenges is he had no background in music theory so it was not possible to describe harmonic language for example. His thesis was simply that "This was written in C20th, that was written in C18th, therefore C20th must be more complex/sophisticated." There's no point in entering such a debate as the absence of a common platform of understanding just makes it far too hard.Find out what he's talking about, listen to some of it and form your own opinion - if you can be bothered.
Hope he wasn't in IT. With logic like that he'd be a dangerous liability.His thesis was simply that "This was written in C20th, that was written in C18th, therefore C20th must be more complex/sophisticated."
One thing that has come as no surprise to me as a result of joining the Cafe is how little I know about music. I've always recognised that classical music and some jazz is "musicians' music" that can be properly appreciated only by those who know enough. So, when I talk or write of my recently acquired taste for jazz, I always say that I enjoy it without understanding. People who know enough to "appreciate" such music are surely only a tiny proportion of the market. I wonder what, for example, @tenorviol or @jbtsax think of enjoyment without understanding?I was familiar with the music he was referring to. One of the challenges is he had no background in music theory so it was not possible to describe harmonic language for example. His thesis was simply that "This was written in C20th, that was written in C18th, therefore C20th must be more complex/sophisticated." There's no point in entering such a debate as the absence of a common platform of understanding just makes it far too hard.
At the end of the day, if that is the music which makes him happy, it's not for me to argue.
Civil engineer....Hope he wasn't in IT. With logic like that he'd be a dangerous liability.
There is no problem with 'enjoyment without understanding' as you put it: the vast majority of people listening to music do not "understand" it in the music theory sense. My point was that it was of little value having a debate on the subject (harmonic complexity) as we lacked a common basis of understanding in order ot have a meaningful discussionOne thing that has come as no surprise to me as a result of joining the Cafe is how little I know about music. I've always recognised that classical music and some jazz is "musicians' music" that can be properly appreciated only by those who know enough. So, when I talk or write of my recently acquired taste for jazz, I always say that I enjoy it without understanding. People who know enough to "appreciate" such music are surely only a tiny proportion of the market. I wonder what, for example, @tenorviol or @jbtsax think of enjoyment without understanding?
By contrast, sitting-in with a local jazz band involves a very different kind of music, shallow but great fun both for the musicians and the audience, a sort of folk music where people are encouraged to have a go.
