Playing the saxophone Beato Basics of Music Theory

Nicely presented in a "friendly way" for those who like to understand the academic mechanics of music. However if you're thinking of using these references for improvisation, then you're always "translating" from theory to practice without necessarily knowing the sound of the note you're trying to play. It also ignores the more important aspects of melody, which doesn't necessarily correspond with chord structure that's backing the melody.

Nice stuff to know/understand, but IMHO useless if you wish to improvise effectively and have something to "say" other than I can play chord tones as cut and paste arpeggios.

The more important aspect is simply as the language of communication between musicians when working on tracks and discussing what they want it to sound like, e.g. can you play bar 16 as an Eb7?

Learn as much as you can, but this is NOT the way to learn to improvise. IMHO improvisation is about having a good music library in your head, hearing (melodic)?) lines that you think will sound good and being able to play those on your instrument. It's having a head/ear to hands relationship rather than intellectual concept, to visual to finger placement for an arpeggio that you can't hear until it comes from your instrument.

How do you play with feeling or communicate when you can't hear what you're about to play? You can't! Knowledge and understanding doesn't make for a good improvisor any more than memorizing a dictionary makes you a good speaker. It takes practice in the art of communication in any of the arts. Canned references thrown out as cut and paste riffs and arpeggios can be practiced until you can play them quickly, but what does it say to a listener? Unfortunately not much.

The video is good in the same way that it's fascinating to learn about the parts of your car that work together so that you can drive it. It may give you respect for the designer/engineers who made it, but it's not likely to make you a better driver. In the last section he gives the key to his justification for knowing/memorizing all of this information: He VISUALIZES the chord changes and memorizes those so that he can further apply a VISUAL reference for his improvisations. He isn't memorizing how the music sounds or creating an improvisation based what it will sound like, it's 100% mechanical!

If you have any modicum of talent, can hear and sing a tune, or better still play it by ear, then this video is not mandatory knowledge in order for you to be a good effective improvisor. In fact it's probably a bad idea to put too much time into learning how to mechanically "ape" what you can do naturally.

If you can't hear or play music except by reading or memorizing mechanistically, then this video, and the book he's flogging may be a great reference. It's not IMHO a way to be creative, but you may achieve some level of mechanical competence.

My suggestion: have fun, and play the music you want to hear. Improvisation is potentially a creative art form, and hopefully some of you are working towards adding to that.
 
Last edited:
When someone tries to explain soloing with modes my brain goes numb.
The chord structure of an arrangement can be a key to get you in, but the way you join it all up has to be musical.
Counter melody and passing notes make a solo. Finding a different way to get from one section to another can be fun. Getting yourself into trouble and plugging your way out will often get a round of applause.
Sometimes just a gasp of "nice try" and a smile from the band is all you get.
Music is art not science.
Something beautiful can break all the rules.
 
I don't think the point was to offer a way into improv, although he does touch on it here and there and doesn't really offer much useful advice, I certainly don't think dorian, mixolydian, Ionian when soloing over a ii, V, I for example but as he says it's stuff that's valuable to know and I'm often amazed at how difficult some people find the concept of modes. I found it useful that he just lays it all out in 40 minutes. It's like a public service announcement.

I found the stuff I know, principally the Major scale, easy to follow but the minor scale chord naming always makes me want to give up and I'm not sure that being able to name them is much use, not to me at least, but I was pleased to see it written out and explained. Putting it to use is a different matter and wasn't the point and would take hours, days, even weeks to cover in videos.

If you want to be a pro then maybe you do need to know this, and I think a lot do, but I think his idea of a pro is someone who can read, write, analyse and score parts that is way beyond me and not something I want to do.

I have his book, it's very long, I found it when I was looking for info on soloing over 12 tone stuff. Sure enough he covers it. It was on sale and I thought it looks as if it covers everything I could want. It does but I never look at it because it's so dense and I don't care for books in digital format. I think I found it during lockdown when I was looking for some stimulus. A fair chunk is given over to guitar as that is his main instrument and there's good and comprehensive info on harmony for song writing. So it covers pretty much anything you could want but it's not for your average joe.
 
I don't understand why people suggest using modes to think about how to improvise over diatonic chords. It seems to me to be an extraordinarily complex and very unhelpful way of describing something rather simple.

For example, I once heard a teacher describe at great length how we could use the Locrian mode scale to improvise over an F#-half-diminished chord. It seemed to me to be much simpler just to say that we could use the normal scale notes from the underlying key of G major.
 
Check out at 35 minutes 40 seconds (you rightfully may have been asleep by then). He makes it pretty clear that he considers this the ONLY WAY to improvise and insisted his students memorize, visualize and follow those chord progressions. Sorry, I just can't think of a way to be less creative or musical. This (along with the pitch to sell his book) are the climax/justification for all that was described in the previous 35 minutes.

I still find it all very interesting, but completely disagree with it being the one and only true way for any talented musician to improvise. To my mind it's the antithesis, and quite clearly a classic example of the the problem with a completely academic approach to improvisation. Paint by the numbers will never produce a creative art work, the same is true for music.

There is also an inherent error/prejudice in this type of academic approach. The discussion is limited to only thinking in terms of the modes of a major (Western) scale. There are thousands of modes that can "add spice" to the way you play. think Eastern European modes, Middle Eastern and the 10,000 or so ragas (all a mode of their own) from India. All those genres use improvisation as well as many other parts of the world. Be skeptical...very skeptical when anyone tries to codify creativity to fit with their limited abilities or ideas.
 
Last edited:

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,076
Messages
578,675
Members
8,134
Latest member
banjo
Back
Top Bottom