Miscellaneous Barone Shills on SOTW?

I am also sceptical about a user who brings up a 10-year-old issue from another forum and then vanishes.
I guess if you don't reply within the hour you've vanished... 😉

In all seriousness, sorry for the delay everyone--I wasn't getting emails for this thread, so you can imagine my surprise when I checked back in. Will respond to the points throughout the thread shortly...
 
Why? Surely it would only mean that you take a more realistic approach to believing everything you read on the internet. Do people believe all the 5 star reviews on Amazon? I hope not.
A good point--you shouldn't blindly believe everything you read on the internet--but I'll stand by my original comment. If shilling for Barones was commonplace, which could have been plausible in a small community like SOTW, then the large number of positive reviews from that time would have essentially no weight. This would completely change the meaning of those reviews from "there seems to be broad agreement these are good saxes for the money" to "Phil Barone hijacked a small community to make a profit, and that's why there's so much agreement."

Indeed, the main reason I started this post was precisely because I was skeptical of your original accusation, especially given how few negative reviews of Barones I've been able to find.

However ten years later I do not remember any specifics so I can’t help I’m afraid. Whatever evidence there was about thes Australian reviews has probably now disappeared, I certainly would not know where to find it now.
[...]
All I remember about SOTW is it was mentioned some posts were removed and accounts closed so it will be very difficult/impossible to find what you want, especially as the software changed and probably post edits, user notes etc. would have been lost. A search for things that are no longer there just doesn’t work.
I really appreciate this context, even if it's not much. It goes a long way toward explaining why I couldn't find (and why it may be impossible to find) hard evidence to support the claim of widespread Barone shilling.

I never advise paying much attention to reviews unless you know them to be independent.
For that reason I think it's shame that the majority of his reviews seem to be on SOTW. When there's no way to try a horn in stores, and all you have to go off are written reviews, and most of those reviews are on a single obscure site...it makes it hard to know what to do. 🙁

Hence this post. Trying to find out as much as I can.

I would always advise to try before you buy, but if you must believe reviews make sure you know they are legit.
Great advice. I went in to my local music shop today to try out other Taiwanese horns for this exact reason. Funnily enough, the sheer variance between brands has made me much less confident about buying a Barone I've never played, even with a refund guarantee.

Not what I would call a scandal. Some people probably thought it was normal.
I'll use whatever term you'd prefer. Storm in a teakettle perhaps? 😉
 
A good point--you shouldn't blindly believe everything you read on the internet--but I'll stand by my original comment. If shilling for Barones was commonplace, which could have been plausible in a small community like SOTW, then the large number of positive reviews from that time would have essentially no weight. This would completely change the meaning of those reviews from "there seems to be broad agreement these are good saxes for the money" to "Phil Barone hijacked a small community to make a profit, and that's why there's so much agreement."

Indeed, the main reason I started this post was precisely because I was skeptical of your original accusation, especially given how few negative reviews of Barones I've been able to find.


I really appreciate this context, even if it's not much. It goes a long way toward explaining why I couldn't find (and why it may be impossible to find) hard evidence to support the claim of widespread Barone shilling.


For that reason I think it's shame that the majority of his reviews seem to be on SOTW. When there's no way to try a horn in stores, and all you have to go off are written reviews, and most of those reviews are on a single obscure site...it makes it hard to know what to do. 🙁

Hence this post. Trying to find out as much as I can.


Great advice. I went in to my local music shop today to try out other Taiwanese horns for this exact reason. Funnily enough, the sheer variance between brands has made me much less confident about buying a Barone I've never played, even with a refund guarantee.


I'll use whatever term you'd prefer. Storm in a teakettle perhaps? 😉

If you really don’t want to buy the horn, then don’t. Done. I think you’ve taken this too far - you are in unfounded defamation territory.

I have known Phil Barone for a long time, and played his mouthpieces for a decade.

There are a lot of similar business models. Why are you going after Barone?
 
If you really don’t want to buy the horn, then don’t.
Where did I give the impression I didn't want to buy the horn?

I think you’ve taken this too far - you are in unfounded defamation territory.
I disagree--the main point of this post is to shed light on a damaging claim against Phil and give @Pete Thomas a chance to clarify his original post, which I think he's done as best he can given how little hard evidence remains. And the conclusion--at least the one I've reached--is that there is little evidence that the positive reviews for Phil's saxophones over the last 10 years are anything but genuine.

Given how easy it was for me, a prospective buyer, to come across the damaging claim in my research, do you really think it would be better to leave it unchallenged? Would you rather I'd accepted it at face value and moved on to another Taiwanese horn from a big box music store? I'd much rather bring it back up, even after 10 years, so we can separate truth from speculation (or, as you view it, defamation).

There are a lot of similar business models. Why are you going after Barone?
Such as? Phil's business model seems unique to me and I'd be curious to know about others.

And I'm "going after" (read: researching) Barone in large part because of the overwhelmingly positive response to his products. If there really are a lot of similar business models, Phil's the only one I've heard of, and I've heard almost exclusively good things at that.
 
Where did I give the impression I didn't want to buy the horn?


I disagree--the main point of this post is to shed light on a damaging claim against Phil and give @Pete Thomas a chance to clarify his original post, which I think he's done as best he can given how little hard evidence remains. And the conclusion--at least the one I've reached--is that there is little evidence that the positive reviews for Phil's saxophones over the last 10 years are anything but genuine.

Given how easy it was for me, a prospective buyer, to come across the damaging claim in my research, do you really think it would be better to leave it unchallenged? Would you rather I'd accepted it at face value and moved on to another Taiwanese horn from a big box music store? I'd much rather bring it back up, even after 10 years, so we can separate truth from speculation (or, as you view it, defamation).


Such as? Phil's business model seems unique to me and I'd be curious to know about others.

And I'm "going after" (read: researching) Barone in large part because of the overwhelmingly positive response to his products. If there really are a lot of similar business models, Phil's the only one I've heard of, and I've heard almost exclusively good things at that.
Let me try to put this thread out of its misery. I've known Phil for a number of years, not in person but through numerous online, text, phone and email interactions and if there is anything I can say about him, and also quoting my good friend and mentor Ron P. Coelho, Phil is someone who's always stood behind his products. To be honest, sometimes to the point of being annoying. When I bought my mouthpieces from him I had to pick them up from the UPS hub and hadn't even left the facilities yet when he texted me to inquire how satisfied I was. He tried to talk me into some reeds that simply wouldn't work at 7500 ft elevation to get the most out of his pieces. But he also listened to my arguments. The point here is that he takes pride in what he does and while there will always be someone who feels buyer's remorse,in most cases, that's just what it is, regardless of the product.
And yes, he's a bit vain and he wants customers to beam with glee over his products and tell everybody else.

And that's it. End of story.
 
Basing your decision to buy a horn on something that happened on the Internet 10 years ago is a poor strategy in my opinion.

A review, good or bad, is only as reliable as the reviewer. If you don't know the reviewer then you shouldn't trust the review. A collection of reviews is no more reliable than each individual review.

If you are interested in a new horn then the only safe way to make your choice is to try one. If you can't try it before you buy, then make sure the seller has a good returns policy.
 
A good point--you shouldn't blindly believe everything you read on the internet--but I'll stand by my original comment. If shilling for Barones was commonplace, which could have been plausible in a small community like SOTW, then the large number of positive reviews from that time would have essentially no weight.
@steve_gaddfly - I believe it makes no difference, as I mentioned above I think you get shills (of varying degrees of shillyness) on forums for absolutely any product - saxophones, mouthpieces accessories..., I would never attach any weight to any posts that seem to be a glowing review unless I know the person and am aware of their integrity. In other words, I might have given this advice originally whether or not I had seen reports of shills.

Arguably I am too sceptical and should just trust everything I read on the internet, even if it does seem too good to be true.
This would completely change the meaning of those reviews from "there seems to be broad agreement these are good saxes for the money" to "Phil Barone hijacked a small community to make a profit, and that's why there's so much agreement."
As mentioned, reviews (as happy customer posts on forums) only have whatever meaning you, as the reader, want to attach.
Indeed, the main reason I started this post was precisely because I was skeptical of your original accusation,
Nothing wrong with scepticism. I'm OK with that as long as nobody is shooting the messenger.
If you really don’t want to buy the horn, then don’t. Done. I think you’ve taken this too far - you are in unfounded defamation territory.

I disagree--the main point of this post is to shed light on a damaging claim against Phil and give @Pete Thomas a chance..............Given how easy it was for me, a prospective buyer, to come across the damaging claim in my research.................which I think he's done as best he can given how little hard evidence remains.

Given that (a) we are now seeing the words "damaging claim" and "defamation territory" (b) if any hard evidence remains then it is difficult to find and (to be honest) life is too short to spend the energy on something from 10 years ago that has been erased and/or forgotten. I think therefore it is safest from a legal POV for me to remove the text in question, albeit I was merely referring to something which at the time was publically and readily available knowledge.

I'm not at all invested in trying to damage anyone, and for the sake of the integrity of this forum I may respond to people who seem to be blindly trusting any online reviews (whether forum posts or on merchant sites), especially when people refer to reading them as "research."

Caveat emptor, sine qua non, glutus maximus.
 
Last edited:
It's sort of a good example of 'flavor of the month' gets going....You actually see it fairly often on chat boards.

There was another 'boutique' brand which I shall decline to name, ahem...that was 'hot' in a similar fashion for a while...with a purveyor of the brand who managed to successfully, aggressively cow any critics of it on the forums....and who had a Posse of folks over there doing the same....just literally ripping into any critic, disparaging their musicianship, etc.
Literally for a stretch of about a year, every comment one could find on the net was glowing.
The actual horns sorta, well...um....were not very good at all, from an (objective) tech standpoint.

THAT was far worse than any threads on the Barones.

FWIW I concur with Stephen on the actual horns (Barones)....I have serviced a few. Not bad horns.
For their price point a decent buy.
Yes, arguably NOT what they were cracked up to be in those early threads....and the Test of Time always eventually catches up with boutique brands....but, yeah, not bad horns. Decent. One can do worse for the price point.
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,069
Messages
578,511
Members
8,131
Latest member
Jef B
Back
Top Bottom