Miscellaneous Barone Shills on SOTW?

steve_gaddfly

Member
Messages
5
Location
USA
Hey everyone! First time poster, yada yada yada…

I’m in the market for a new horn, and after initially looking into P. Mauriats I was drawn to Phil Barone’s instruments because of the glowing reviews on Sax On The Web. They seem almost too good to be true–a Taiwanese horn from (nearly?) the same factories as P. Mauriat, Eastman, and Cannonball at almost half the price.

I tried to learn as much as I could about these obscure horns, and in my research I came across something shocking: a post from 2012 on this forum (link at the end) in which Pete Thomas said:
Sadly it was established that many of the glowing reviews [for Barones on SOTW] were from shills.

What?!!! If this was true, it would change everything I had read about these instruments. I had to find out more! But a couple admin edits in the thread (possibly from Pete?) remove any further reference to this claim. One edit reads:
ADMIN EDIT: Paragraph removed. As mentioned above, we do not want to get into a discussion of what did and didn't happen on SOTW, or their moderation decisions.

I’ve tried my best to find out more, but as it stands I can find no evidence in the forums of that time (neither here nor SOTW) to support Pete’s claim. Furthermore, positive reviews of Barone’s horns have continued to surface on SOTW in the years since 2012–are we to believe the mods there have been aware of shills for over 10 years and done nothing during that time to stop them?

It’s not my intention to be a gadfly just to stir up controversy, especially on Pete’s own site. I haven’t bought a Barone, haven’t tried a Barone, so I don’t have a horse in this race: I'm not "Team Phil" or "Team Pete." But I do want to be as informed as possible, and the accusation of widespread Barone shilling, without supporting evidence, and now contradicted by over 10 years of positive customer reviews, seems too important to leave alone.

Can anyone here who remembers this scandal (including but not limited to Pete himself) share their recollections of the event? And, if possible, links to threads that document how everything went down? This is too interesting a discovery for me to leave alone!

Link to the 2012 accusation: Saxophones - Phil Barone Tenor -Classic or Vintage?
Link to SOTW’s Barone Subforum with several positive reviews within the last 4 years: https://www.saxontheweb.net/forums/barone.388/
 
so I don’t have a horse in this race: I'm not "Team Phil" or "Team Pete."

I have no horse in any such race, and am not aware of any "Team Pete" in this context. I was just reporting what I knew to have happened regarding moderator action SOTW.

What?!!! If this was true, it would change everything I had read about these instruments.
Why? Surely it would only mean that you take a more realistic approach to believing everything you read on the internet. Do people believe all the 5 star reviews on Amazon? I hope not.

However ten years later I do not remember any specifics so I can’t help I’m afraid. Whatever evidence there was about thes Australian reviews has probably now disappeared, I certainly would not know where to find it now.

I never advise paying much attention to reviews unless you know them to be independent. I would always advise to try before you buy, but if you must believe reviews make sure you know they are legit. I have no idea about Phil Barone saxophones these days, except to say it wouldn't surprise if the majority of reviews are sincere. I also believe (without any first hand evidence) that they are probably value for money.

And as you say:

I’ve tried my best to find out more, but as it stands I can find no evidence in the forums of that time (neither here nor SOTW) to support Pete’s claim.
So the best thing for you might be to ignore it.

Can anyone here who remembers this scandal
Not what I would call a scandal. Some people probably thought it was normal.

All I remember about SOTW is it was mentioned some posts were removed and accounts closed so it will be very difficult/impossible to find what you want, especially as the software changed and probably post edits, user notes etc. would have been lost. A search for things that are no longer there just doesn’t work.

Regarding more info here, please note, as I said in the paragraph you quoted:

ADMIN EDIT: Paragraph removed. As mentioned above, we do not want to get into a discussion of what did and didn't happen on SOTW, or their moderation decisions.

So as that was the case 10 years ago, it's even less likely now we would get into a discussion of what SOTW moderators did or said.

But I do know (sadly) that there are still many shill reviews for various products such as mouthpieces (either people getting a discount in return for a good review, or people making duplicate accounts up). We get that here as well and we do our best to deal with it when we know it is happening. So you just have to be healthily sceptical IMO.

I do feel quite strongly about this as I so often see people buying stuff based on "research" and it turns out the research is just reading and trusting reviews. I have my own endorser agreement which stipulates that any public review should disclose whether there was a discount.
 
Last edited:
There are shills but ai really dont think Barone did a lot of shill grooming. I think people liked his horns and especially at the price point they were offered. My impression from people who wrote is that they stood toe to toe with other good Taiwan horns but his price was considerably better.

There are a lot of people with undue brand loyalty on the internet. Its a double edge sword. Some people cant tolerate not having the best of the best so they compensate. Note that I have not played these horns and Im not concerned with them one way or another. There exist shills everywhere and some vendors pay and offer discounts to have them do their underhanded bidding. Id be worried about folks involved with other products on the forum than Barone horns.
 
Last edited:
Id be worried about folks involved with other products on the forum than Barone horns.
So would I these days.

Regarding any Australia thing, I would be very surprised if whatever action taken by SOTW modertors did not put an end to it, hence I think it's fair to assume any reviews these days of Barone horns are no more nor less likely to be shill posts than other saxophone "reviews."

Mouthpieces though...
 
Last edited:
I've seen a few Barones over the years - I even got halfway through reviewing one before time caught up with me, so I never finished it. From what I've seen they appear to be respectable horns. You know, nothing hugely special - but not rubbish.
 
I have played a vintage tenor in the past. I also had a hollywood mouthpiece.
They were both really good. The tenor was fat sounding reminding me a P.Mauriat 66.
I also have played about 10 years ago one of his necks. It was great.
I have never dealt with him directly, but the products I have personally used, were great.
 
NB re: commenting on the saxophones in general, I originally moved this thread from the saxophones subforum because it is not actually about the saxophones. So if at all possible, we should keep this on topic (however redundant that topic may be). Please post anything about saxophones here.
 
I used to have a Phil Barone tenor. I thought it was rather nice, but it eventually gave way completely to a YTS-82z. I think one get a discount (it was small) on the next purchase from PB if one reviewed one's current purchase. That encouraged some reviews. I did not buy another one. The Australian in question was banned from SOTW years ago. He seemed to have been rather enthusiastic about PB saxophones, but I don't know what in particular led to the banning. Anyway, all of this had been forgotten until OP asked about some aspect of it.
 
I think one get a discount (it was small) on the next purchase from PB if one reviewed one's current purchase.
Doing a review in return for a discount by itself is not really something that defines a shill IMO, unless of course they don't disclose the fact about the discount.
 
I've never played a Barone horn but I have several of his mouthpieces and I've dealt with Phil personally a number of times and never had even the slightest problem. With any product, you can get good ones or bad ones. Like in the case of my PMauriat sop where the entire anchor for the octave mechanism popped off the neck and it turned out that it had only been held by 3 tiny solder spots (it did not flow). Are Mauriat horns bad because of that? No!

Same thing applies to any other brand. But I do know that Phil stands 100% behind his products.
 
I am always skeptical of raves and reviews by new users that join a forum only to post about a new product then vanish.
An admin has various tools to winkle out shills and spammers, sometimes they can find actual evidence, other times not so. It's quite interesting so I might start a new thread on that. The OP here seems to not be too interested in the answer to their question. I did my best.
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,069
Messages
578,511
Members
8,131
Latest member
Jef B
Back
Top Bottom