Saxophones Baritone: Second hand Selmer or new Rampone e Cazzani?

The Flutist

New Member
Messages
4
Location
Middle of Norway
Given the choice: would you go for the new R&C R1 baritone or the second hand Selmer Series II baritone?
Any one has experience with Rampone e Cazzani's R1 baritone? Intonation, ergonometri, craftsmanship and so forth?
I play Selmers on tenor and alto and in a norwegian netshop (kind of eBay) there's a second hand Selmer Series II baritone that's for sale - cheaper than the new R1. But it is still a considerable amount of NOK, so I need some information and opinions.
I must of consider the fact that I like the sound of the old master, Gerry Mulligan. And the R&C R1 baritone that I've found, looks more like an old Conn - including low Bb.
On the other hand, I know Selmer, the ergonomics, the intonation and general quality. But this one goes down to low A, and weighs somewhat more than the low Bb baritones.
My use of my future baritone: some big band, but probably mostly in other settings. Therefore I think that the low A is of less importance.
So which would you buy: the second hand Selmer or a new Rampone e Cazzani?
 
Given that you're already a Selmer player, I'd go for the low A Selmer. I've gotten by playing a low Bb horn for 41 years as my primary saxophone, but if you're starting from the beginning just go low A.

You might think now "I'll rarely need a low A" but a few years from now you may find yourself in a different situation and really want it.
 
Any one has experience with Rampone e Cazzani's R1 baritone? Intonation, ergonometri, craftsmanship and so forth?
I have no experience with those, so can't advise.
I play Selmers on tenor and alto and in a norwegian netshop (kind of eBay) there's a second hand Selmer Series II baritone that's for sale - cheaper than the new R1. But it is still a considerable amount of NOK, so I need some information and opinions.
Given your experience level as both teacher and player, you are your best judge. I can share my experience as a retired US Army Reservist clarinetist and saxophonist. Back in the 1980's I played an old King low Bb Bari for concert, stage band and marching in parades. I found it adequate, didn't see a need for low A.

In 2012 I came across an early 1950's low Bb Beaugnier Vito Bari needing considerable repairs but had good pads, all for $315 US shipping included.

(Stenciled on the case was a high school name. Apparently it was a loaner instrument, well abused, repaired many times, taken out of service then stored in an unconditioned space as case was very musty smelling, had about 40% of its lacquer left.)

After straightening the key racks, removed dents, resoldered broken solder joints, installed missing cork bumpers, reset pad heights, etc., it played very well in tune. Used it in the local community band and solo gigging. Got by fine without the low A.

Several years ago during Covid, got a new discontinued model Antigua Winds low A bari with really nice luggage grade case with wheels for $2,500 US (about half price) from Quinn the Eskimo in the Seattle area of Washington state. Called intermediate but plays like a pro model. Yet, with the Beaugnier in a gig bag is easier to lug around plus is lighter, remains my favourite.
So which would you buy: the second hand Selmer or a new Rampone e Cazzani?
Since you are debating as to which may satisfy your needs within budget and have questions in your mind regarding these 3 and have time on your hands ... perhaps it is just a matter of waiting until another suitable bari is available at the right price?
 
My main horn is the tenor (Conn 10m) but I also have a (cheap, second hand) Bari that I play from time to time.

I tried a R&C tenor last October and I was very impressed with the tone of that sax. A very rich tone that comes close to my Conn. I could not do a direct comparison, I didn't have my Conn with me.
But when I was looking to buy a second hand curved soprano in December, i started looking at R&C soprano's and got myself a gold plated R&C curved sop in January. It also has a very rich and warm sound.

So I would think that a Selmer (never played any Selmer horn myself) will play and sound quite a bit different than a R&C horn. Maybe you have to try them both before deciding. Nobody can make the choice in your place.
R&C horns don't appear in the second-hand market as often as Selmers ..... That might also be worth considering.
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,062
Messages
578,396
Members
8,129
Latest member
Bartman
Back
Top Bottom